
In Va., Kaine and Allen Seek Elusive Ticket-Splitters
Published Nov. 3, 2012 • Read time: 8m
Join the Conversation
0RICHMOND, Va. -- Mary White, a retired guidance counselor from Northumberland, Va., drove an hour and a half from her home in the state's northern neck to attend a Mitt Romney rally near Richmond, arriving early to snag a seat. White is eager to vote for the Republican presidential nominee on Tuesday -- she points with pride to a Romney pin on her right lapel -- but when asked whom she will support in the U.S. Senate race there, she pauses to think.
“I’m not too particular about which one wins. I think [Tim] Kaine would do just as well as [George] Allen,” she says, referring to the Democratic and Republican candidates, respectively. Asked whether she saw differences between the two men, both former governors of the state, White wrinkles her nose. “Not a whole lot. I like [Kaine] more as a man than Allen. Both have been good as governors.”
Conventional wisdom over the course of this race has suggested that Kaine’s and Allen’s fates depend on how the tops of the two tickets perform here. But after five debates, nearly $60 million in spending by both the candidates and outside groups, and with more ads on air that can be reasonably absorbed, the Senate race appears to have some fluidity. In the final weekend of the campaign, the opponents are still appealing to a small sliver of the electorate that may be firm in their presidential picks but unsure about the down-ballot race. According to polling data and interviews with campaign strategists, these voters are more likely to be independent Romney backers.
Portman-Strickland Senate Race Finally Set in Ohio
Portman Wastes No Time Attacking Strickland
Strickland Skirts Primary Debates in Ohio Senate Race
Senate Says Climate Change Is Real
The presidential contest in Virginia is among the closest in the nation. The RCP Average shows Romney ahead by 0.3 points, and polls show Obama’s support shrinking since his historic win in the Old Dominion (by seven points) four years ago. But the Senate race between two well-known political heavyweights has been in a virtual dead heat for the past year, with Kaine now leading in the RCP Average by just under a single point, and Senate control possibly hinging on the election’s outcome.
Allen campaigned across Virginia with Romney on Thursday, hoping those who turn out to support the GOP nominee will pull the lever for him as well. He has been running a national campaign from the start, attaching Kaine to the policies of Obama, whom Kaine served as Democratic National Committee chairman. Allen has sought to bring national issues home, hitting the White House for burdensome EPA regulations that could hurt jobs in Virginia coal country, and focusing on potential defense cuts that threaten roughly 200,000 Virginians, mostly in the north and around Hampton Roads. At a rally in Doswell, a half-hour north of Richmond, Allen introduced GOP standard-bearer and characterized Virginia as the place that would determine which party runs both the White House and the Senate.
Some in attendance seemed to need the reminder. Asked after the rally whom she would be supporting in the Senate race, Ellen Neal, a health care professional from Victoria, crossed her arms to mull the question. “Is that the one with [Eric] Cantor?” she asked, referencing the area’s congressman and House majority leader. When told Allen’s name, she nodded emphatically and pointed to an Allen sticker beneath the collar of her jacket.
Kaine is banking on Obama’s entrenched ground game for high base turnout, and is confident that (as many polls indicate) voters who back the president will automatically choose the Democratic Senate candidate. But in the final days, Kaine’s team also hopes to cut into what they see as “soft” Allen support -- those who back Romney but aren’t so wed to Allen that they couldn’t be convinced to split the ticket.
That’s why a roomful of volunteers at a phone bank in Richmond Thursday evening were focused on persuading voters to do just that. The Kaine team will ramp up its get-out-the-vote effort over the weekend, but will also continue trying to persuade voters right until the end. Kaine has made a bipartisan pitch from the beginning of the race, touting his decades of public service in Virginia despite his partisan role as DNC chairman. He has been campaigning across the state with popular Democratic Sen. Mark Warner, who has been actively involved in bipartisan deficit-reduction efforts on the Hill. (Kaine is perhaps the only candidate running this cycle to feature George W. Bush in an ad. He cited the former president to explain how he worked with the opposition party to get a transportation project funded in Northern Virginia.)
“We are getting all the president’s support plus some of Romney’s, and I think that’s because even Romney supporters see a real difference in the Senate race and Kaine’s willingness to work across party lines,” said Mo Elleithee, the candidate’s senior adviser, who also worked on Warner’s campaign.
To underscore that point, Kaine spent Friday campaigning in the Republican stronghold of southwest Virginia, where his wife (the daughter of former Republican Gov. Linwood Holton) hails from. On Saturday he will then focus on getting out the vote by campaigning with Obama and former President Bill Clinton in Prince William County.
Ticket-splitters can be an elusive group. Anyone on the lookout for them would be hard-pressed to find signs for Romney and Kaine, or Obama and Allen, sharing space on the same lawn (though the former scenario is more likely). But Democratic campaign aides say the scenario is more subtle than that. Splitters tend to be white, educated, middle- to upper-class voters in the three most populous suburbs of Richmond (Henrico, Chesterfield and Hanover counties) as well as the Northern Virginia swing counties outside Washington, D.C. (Loudoun, Prince William and Fairfax, which Kaine carried in his 2005 race for governor). Henrico has become more diverse in recent years and is considered a key swing county in Virginia. Cantor represents half of it, while Democratic Rep. Bobby Scott represents the other half.
Campaign strategists envision suburban women who may dislike Obama but are personally drawn to Kaine, or Northern Virginia businessmen and -women who don’t like the president’s policies but aren’t taken by what they remember of Allen’s Southern conservatism and personality. Allen is running a noticeably tempered campaign, humbled, he has said, after losing his Senate seat in 2006 to Democrat Jim Webb (the close race was apparently lost after Allen used a derogatory racial term to describe a Webb volunteer).
The ticket-splitting scenario seems possible on paper, as Kaine tends to run ahead of Obama and Allen tends to run behind Romney in Virginia polls. A recent CBS/New York Times/Quinnipiac University survey, for example, found Obama leading Romney just 49 percent to 47 percent, but Kaine leading Allen by 50 percent to 46 percent. Kaine received roughly 10 percent more supporty from Democrats than Allen did from Republicans. But Republicans run well with independents in Virginia, who appear to be growing in number. That same poll found Romney leading Obama among this group, 57 percent to 36 percent, and Allen leading Kaine among it by a similar margin.
But to some extent the Senate outcome still depends upon the margin in the presidential contest. If Romney wins the state by one or two points, Kaine could conceivably capture enough crossover support to win. But if Romney wins by more than that, his coattails could be long enough to carry Allen.
Virginia Democratic Chairman Brian Moran said Kaine can do better than most Democrats in the Richmond area because he served as mayor of the city and currently lives there. Allen lives in Alexandria, a Democratic stronghold outside of Washington. The key, though, is Democratic turnout. “We knew we weren’t going to catch the Republicans napping” after 2008 Moran said. Republican Gov. Bob McDonnell succeeded Kaine in Richmond after an 18-point victory in 2009, and the 2010 midterms swept a handful of state Republicans into the U.S. House of Representatives and the party later took control of the state legislature.
The presidential race looms large in the Richmond suburbs, where both Senate candidates hope to do well. As conversations with voters in the area show, however, politics can be local. Skimming books at a Barnes & Noble in Chesterfield, Thomas Milhausen, a CPA from Richmond, said he’s voting for Romney because he doesn’t like the contraception mandate in Obama’s health care bill. Milhausen says he will also vote for Allen. “Personally, I prefer Kaine to Allen,” he added, citing the Democrat’s Catholicism, mission work in the Honduras, and his public service on the Richmond City Council decades ago. But Kaine’s support for the contraception mandate bothers him. (Kaine had asked Obama to ease some of the exemptions in the bill, and later agreed with the administration’s changes.)
In another aisle of the bookstore, Nancy Kreye, a retiree from Richmond, said she is supporting Romney but hasn’t given much thought to the Senate race. She will probably vote conservative, she said, but those kinds of decisions are often left to that solitary moment in the voting booth on Election Day.

Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
The Primary System Is Losing the Next Generation
Sean Trende • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
