
Kaine Embraces Obama Anew -- Thanks to Va. GOP
Published Feb. 27, 2012 • Read time: 7m
Join the Conversation
0RICHMOND, Va. -- In a speech to young voters here over the weekend, former Virginia governor and current U.S. Senate candidate Tim Kaine waxed poetic about working to elect the president four years ago.
"I've won seven elections already, but nothing, nothing, was as sweet, nothing was as meaningful, nothing was as important for the commonwealth, for the country and for the world," Kaine told the hundred or so gathered at a youth summit sponsored by Obama for America.
Kaine sounded sincere. Moreover, he sounded quite happy to be running on the same Democratic ticket as Barack Obama in November. That’s a demonstrable change from just a couple of weeks ago, when Kaine publicly pleaded with the White House to moderate its stance on a key feature of the health care reform law, and took the unusual step of openly disagreeing with the man who had tapped him to head the Democratic National Committee.
So what happened that enabled Kaine to so warmly embrace the president again?
Ironically, conservative state lawmakers have buoyed Kaine’s relationship with Obama. In his weekend speech, the former DNC chairman pointed to controversial state legislation regarding abortion rights and women’s health to highlight his concerns about a Republican winning the White House: “We're seeing what going backwards is like, and there ain’t a single thing about backwards that interests me at all.”
An early supporter of Barack Obama in the last cycle who co-chaired his national campaign, Kaine is a tempting target for Republicans, whose plans to win control of the Senate rest on tying Democrats to the president and his policies.
Portman-Strickland Senate Race Finally Set in Ohio
Portman Wastes No Time Attacking Strickland
Strickland Skirts Primary Debates in Ohio Senate Race
Senate Says Climate Change Is Real
But given the Republican Party’s rightward stance on social issues -- intensified in recent days by events in the Virginia General Assembly -- Kaine can more comfortably support Obama these days. Now, issues once thought to be a liability for Democrats might actually work in their favor.
Recently, Kaine found himself in an awkward position when the Obama administration spelled out a health law mandate requiring religious employers to include contraception coverage in their insurance plans. A devout Catholic but also pro-choice, Kaine said he supported the mandate but asked the administration to either broaden exemptions for religious institutions or explain how these groups can comply with the law without compromising their beliefs.
Bowing to the outcry -- echoed by other Democrats -- the president amended the rule by shifting the cost of contraception coverage from the employer to the insurance company, allowing women access to birth control even if their employers objected. (The move hasn’t won over religious institutions, however.)
Kaine applauded the accommodation -- to the delight of Republicans, who could again pin him to the president’s unpopular health care law. “This is an issue of the government overriding the First Amendment and dictating to religious organizations that they must provide services which are contrary to their deeply held beliefs,” said George Allen, Kaine’s likely opponent in November. “. . . Tim Kaine believes Obamacare is a ‘great achievement.’ I believe it ought to be repealed.”
Both sides have framed the contraception mandate to appeal to their respective bases: Democrats say it is about women’s rights and Republicans see it as a matter of religious freedom. The issue has come to the fore in the presidential primary, and all of the Republican candidates have attacked the president -- unsurprising, of course, since each has pledged to repeal “Obamacare” in its entirety. But somewhere along the way, the GOP lost the battle of public perception and now must reconcile its position with the widely held public desire for continued access to contraceptives.
The polling appears to be on the Democrats’ side. A Quinnipiac University survey found that more than half of American voters -- 54 percent -- approve of the Obama accommodation while just 38 percent disapprove. The breakdown between key voting blocs is telling: 56 percent of women and 56 percent of independents support the revised mandate.
Republicans’ health care argument is still salient, however: The poll found 50 percent of voters want the U.S Supreme Court to overturn the law, while only 39 percent wish it would remain in effect. The GOP has framed health care not only as an issue of government overreach but also as one of economics. Republicans argue, for example, that regulations alone place taxing burdens on employers that consequently deter them from hiring workers.
The Virginia legislature then stepped into the fray with two bills that made Gov. Bob McDonnell -- who set an agenda based on economics and cautioned his conference against wading into social issues -- wince. It also delivered Kaine a way to push Republicans into a corner even farther to the right.
The Republican-controlled House of Delegates recently passed an anti-abortion bill, sponsored by Allen’s GOP primary opponent, state Del. Robert Marshall, that defines “personhood” as beginning at the moment of conception. Allen came out in support of the bill with the understanding that it does not ban contraceptives. The language is unclear, however, and opponents say it would make birth control illegal.
The legislature also pushed through a bill requiring women to undergo an ultrasound procedure before having an abortion. Last week, however, it became clear that such a procedure would need to be done vaginally, a more invasive technique than the “jelly on the belly” procedure conducted later in pregnancy.
McDonnell, considered a potential vice presidential pick who supported the bill, backtracked. He softened the measure, making the vaginal ultrasound optional. A Senate committee passed the amended bill late last week. The personhood bill has been tabled until next year.
Still, the pieces of legislation undermined McDonnell’s leadership and enabled opponents to portray state Republicans as an undisciplined bunch. Both bills have been fodder for cable news and late-night television shows, including “Saturday Night Live.”
“What you're seeing here is what you saw with Gov. [John] Kasich and Gov. [Scott] Walker,” says former Virginia Rep. Tom Perriello, a Democrat who lost his conservative district in 2010, referring to the Ohio and Wisconsin governors who have been battered by voters for trying to limit collective bargaining rights for public employees. “Republicans have gotten elected on sort of a common sense and economic agenda and have governed on an extreme social agenda rather than focusing on the economy.”
The situation is an opportune one for Kaine. He is positioning himself as the candidate focused on jobs and the economy while Republicans are talking about social issues. He also sees it as a chance to make inroads with independents -- a key constituency that will determine both the Senate and the presidential race in the Old Dominion.
“Republicans are showing who they are. They're doing it for sincere reasons, but they're showing that their priorities are very different priorities than our priorities,” Kaine said in an interview Saturday with RealClearPolitics after his speech in Richmond.
“. . . I don't think that independent voters feel comfortable with the super-intrusive stuff that's happening in Virginia.”
He credited McDonnell for softening the ultrasound measure, but said “it is a patronizing attitude that suggests women are not able or capable to make their own health care decisions. So even watered-down, this is a very bad bill.”
When asked about the Republican charges that he is just playing politics, Kaine called that “completely cynical and a false argument.” He countered that his opponent brought the issue into the campaign by advocating for federal personhood legislation.
“We wouldn't be talking about this if my opponent had not taken such an extreme position, so out of step with what Virginia voters want their senators and federal legislators to focus on.”
And that is precisely the message that enables Kaine to align with Obama in a state that could make or break the president’s re-election chances. And it is perhaps why Kaine felt so comfortable praising the president with an energy reminiscent of the early days of the 2008 campaign -- when Kaine, as he likes to boast, was the first state official outside of Illinois to back Obama.
“I'm going to run as a proud supporter and friend of President Obama,” Kaine said. “Every once in a while we have some different points of view on things. Hey, I'll tell you I disagree with my wife on things. But I will always run as a friend and supporter of this president and I will always talk about the good job he is doing under extremely difficult circumstances.”

Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
The Primary System Is Losing the Next Generation
Sean Trende • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
