
Cummings' Decision Looms Over Md. Senate Race
Published Jan. 31, 2016 • Read time: 8m
BALTIMORE – Nearly 11 months after Maryland Reps. Donna Edwards and Chris Van Hollen quickly announced they would run for the Senate seat being vacated by Barbara Mikulski, one key question has loomed over their campaigns: Will they get a high-profile opponent in Rep. Elijah Cummings?
With the filing deadline Wednesday, it’s a question that will soon be answered. Cummings’ entrance into the race would shake up the campaigns, while a decision not to run would leave the two lawmakers in a head-to-head contest that’s expected to be extremely close.
With both announced candidates hailing from districts that include large portions of the D.C. suburbs, the city of Baltimore would become a critical battleground. Both have spent significant time and resources to increase their name recognition and shore up support in Charm City.
“I believe the Senate race will be won or lost in Baltimore,” said Martha McKenna, a Democratic strategist based here. “…Donna Edwards has a lot of strength coming out of Prince George’s County and Van Hollen has a lot of strength in Montgomery County, but Baltimore is the battleground.”
Cummings’ Choice
If the 7th District congressman does decide to run, it will shake up the race, particularly in Baltimore, where he is well known and extremely popular. He’s won at least 70 percent of the vote in every election but one since 1996 (in 2014 he got 69.9 percent) and his national profile has increased significantly as the top Democrat on both the Oversight and Government Reform Committee and the select committee investigating the Benghazi attacks.
Portman-Strickland Senate Race Finally Set in Ohio
Portman Wastes No Time Attacking Strickland
Strickland Skirts Primary Debates in Ohio Senate Race
Senate Says Climate Change Is Real
Cummings has openly flirted with a bid for months, with a decision incorrectly assumed to be imminent multiple times. Now, with the filing deadline nearly at hand, he has no choice but to decide – and is still up in the air. Dave Heller, a Democratic strategist who is close with Cummings, said he talked to the congressman as recently as Tuesday, and that he was still actively considering a run.
“He’s mulling it, he’s weighing it,” Heller told RealClearPolitics. “He’s taking in a lot of information and trying to figure out what’s best. Mr. Cummings has a different calculus than most people. He really sits there and doesn’t ask what is easiest or what’s likely or what’s best for him or his family. He really sits there and says, ‘What can I do that’s going to be best for Baltimore, for my city, for my state and for my community?’”
Heller said that there was “no question” that Cummings would immediately be the front-runner if he enters the race, even at this late stage in the campaign. Polls last year consistently showed him with a significant lead over Van Hollen and Edwards if he joined the fray, and Heller said he thought the effectiveness argument would be critical for him.
Cummings – whose spokesperson declined an interview request for this story – said in November that he was convinced he could win but that his calculus centered on whether he would have more influence in the House or Senate.
In his November interview with RCP, Cummings said he wasn’t concerned about fundraising for the Senate and was confident he could raise enough to mount a viable campaign. A filing with the Federal Election Commission showed that he raised just under $200,000 in the last three months of 2015, leaving him with just under $1.1 million cash on hand, significantly less than the $4 million Van Hollen had in October, at the end of the third quarter, though substantially more than the $370,000 Edwards had at that time (end-of-the-year filings for the two announced candidates are not yet available).
Cummings also told RCP that despite his strength in polls and fundraising, his careful deliberation might cause him to run out of time to mount a successful campaign.
“It’s important to make a decision,” he said. “Because if you don’t make a decision, a decision will be made for you.”
The Importance of Baltimore
If Cummings doesn’t throw his hat in the ring, it likely won’t change the trajectory of what’s already been a months-long battle between Van Hollen and Edwards to gain recognition and support in Baltimore.
The race at this point is extremely close – Van Hollen held a double-digit lead in a November poll, but a survey released earlier this month showed Edwards down just two percentage points. In that survey, Van Hollen had a double-digit lead in the Baltimore suburbs, while Edwards had nearly double her opponent’s support in the city of Baltimore. (They both had substantial leads in their respective D.C. area counties).
The two candidates have spent significant time on the ground in Maryland’s largest – and overwhelmingly Democratic -- city, and both have opened campaign offices here. Most of the time spent on the ground has been grassroots-oriented – meet-and-greets with party activists and voters, visiting churches and meeting with faith leaders.
Van Hollen has had more than 70 events in Baltimore since March, according to his campaign, including visits to churches, schools, party dinners and to receive endorsements, with multiple events nearly every week last year. Edwards planned to spend Sunday meeting again meeting with faith leaders in the area, according to her campaign, and has a major meeting with women supporters in Baltimore scheduled in two weeks.
Both candidates have also been visible on the Baltimore airwaves. Van Hollen launched two ads in October, and in December, the women’s group EMILY’s List – a key endorser of Edwards – responded with a $1 million ad buy in the city. Van Hollen earlier this month released a third ad talking about his support for women’s issues.
In an interview with RCP, the seven-term congressman said that in the time he’s spent in the city, the issues he’s heard from voters include greater investments in job opportunities, criminal justice reform and education, and he highlighted the spending plans he’s created as the top Democrat on the Budget Committee that increased resources for the president’s early-education plans.
“I think there’s a real focus on trying to make sure we bring out all that is good in Baltimore and the huge potential in Baltimore, and that means bringing the communities together and really taking a neighborhood focus,” Van Hollen said in the interview.
He declined to comment on Cummings’ decision other than to say that he’s worked closely with him during their years in the state legislature and in Congress, and that he respects “whatever decision he makes.”
He also highlighted the endorsements he’s received from local city leaders, including the City Council president, state lawmakers from the region, all four Democrats on the Baltimore County Council and the local NAACP leader.
Brooke Lierman, a state delegate from Baltimore, said she would have likely supported Cummings had he announced a run for Senate, but didn’t expect him to enter the race. Instead, she endorsed Van Hollen, saying that he has put in the work to understand issues like mass transit, jobs and education that are critical to Baltimoreans.
“He has really taken the time to get to know and understand Baltimore better than he did before, and based on his record in Congress, I feel very confident that people will be able to make a difference and get things done,” Lierman said in an interview with RCP.
While Van Hollen has the support of a significant number of Baltimore lawmakers, Edwards has made a strong effort to speak out on issues important to the city. Earlier this month, she called on the city’s housing commissioner to resign amid a scandal involving workers demanding sexual favors in exchange for making repairs. She also recently criticized the media for their portrayal of the militant standoff on federal property in Oregon, comparing it to their characterization of protesters in Baltimore last year.
The violence and demonstrations surrounding the death of Freddie Gray last year and the trials of the police officers charged in the case have motivated Baltimoreans to become more civically engaged in recent months, said McKenna, the Democratic strategist. That, combined with the open race to replace Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, who declined to run for re-election, will likely result in extremely high turnout for the April primary.
Mikulski, whom Van Hollen and Edwards are running to replace, was born and lives in the city. McKenna called the retiring senator, who has served in the upper chamber for three decades, an “extraordinary champion” for Baltimore and Heller said she would go down as “one of the greatest Maryland senators ever.” Earning the support of voters in her city will be a major step for all of those hoping to replace her.

Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
