RCP Panel: Mamdani's "Warmth of Collectivism" Meets Cold Winter Reality
Last updated 3:35 PM ET
Join the Conversation
0Monday on the RCP Podcast, our panel looked at Zohran Mamdani appearing to fail his first big test as mayor, botching New York City's response to a larger-than-average winter storm -- with deadly consequences.
"He promised in January that he would not break up homeless encampments, taking a more lenient position than his predecessors. The problem, it turns out, is that when homeless people are left on the street during extreme weather, some of them perish. The reported death toll from the recent freeze is 14," Andrew Walworth explained.
"We were all speculating how long it would take him to wreck New York — turns out he did it in six weeks," Tom Bevan joked. "But this was his policy, and it had real-world consequences for these people, and he bears responsibility for that."
"But you see these pictures of trash piled up on sidewalks and the streets are still a mess eight days after the last snowflake fell," Bevan continued. "How much responsibility does he have for that? I would argue some. After a few days, it falls on the mayor to get the plows out and get the garbage taken."
"I'm in no position to criticize New York over snow; Arlington's schools are still closed. But the homelessness issue is different. That was a calculated decision he made," Carl Cannon added. "He believes homeless people should have agency, but people argue that when someone doesn’t know to go into a shelter when temperatures are near zero, that person is a danger to themselves. Previous New York mayors ordered police to clear these encampments and bring people to shelters."
"He clearly was troubled by the deaths," Cannon continued. "He talked about it publicly and said the city had to do better. But he’s struggling with his vision that homeless people should be treated with dignity... I bet he wishes he hadn't said that 'warmth of collectivism' phrase, with people freezing to death."
"Forty or 50 homeless people die from the elements in New York every year, and it is a tragedy. But Mamdani appears trapped by his ideology," Cannon said. "He talks about homelessness as if it’s purely the result of high rent, without acknowledging that most of these people are mentally ill, addicted to drugs, or both. That’s where the state has to intervene."
"You can have compassion, but you don't want to kill people with kindness," he concluded.
"He also said there’s no problem too small for government to handle," Tom Bevan said. "And here we are, five weeks into his tenure, and basic services like plowing streets and removing garbage aren’t functioning. If you promise to handle everything down to the smallest problem, you have to at least make the trains run on time."
Latest Videos

Rahm Emanuel: Democratic Voters In LA and NYC Aren't Socialists, They're Angry
Bloomberg Politics
Zelensky: Putin Needs To Understand Crimean Bridge "Will Not Stay"
World News
Obama to Jeffries: "You've Got To Figure Out How To Actually Get Sh*t Done With Your Colleagues"
White House
Rubio: The Idea That The U.S., Russia, & China Should Not Engage Is Absurd
White House
Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel

Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Obama to Jeffries: "You've Got To Figure Out How To Actually Get Sh*t Done With Your Colleagues"
White House
Rubio: The Idea That The U.S., Russia, & China Should Not Engage Is Absurd
White House
David Brooks: China-U.S. Power Shift Mirrors Germany-Britain Dynamic Before World War I
PBS NewsHour
Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Musk: Zelensky Asking To Use Starlink For Offensive Military Actions
World News









