David Brooks: China-US Power Dynamics Very Similar To Germany-Britain Dynamic Before World War I
Last updated 5:39 PM ET
PBS NEWSHOUR: David Brooks of The Atlantic and Jonathan Capehart of MS NOW join Amna Nawaz to discuss the week in politics, including President Trump's trilateral summit with Xi and Putin, the ongoing debate surrounding data centers, and Elon Musk's attempt to distance himself from MAGA.
AMNA NAWAZ, PBS NEWSHOUR: Let's start with the president, this trip overseas to China, the trilateral meetings with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin. You heard Governor Shapiro there say that the president looked weak. He said that U.S. interests were not advanced in these meetings.
David, you also heard him reference specifically images in which the president was walking with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, and it was Xi Jinping in the middle, President Trump to the side as they all stood together and walked together. What was achieved in this meeting?
DAVID BROOKS, THE ATLANTIC: Did FDR always sit in the middle and try -- when he was with Churchill and Stalin? I don't know -- think it matters who sits where.
You know, I interviewed an eminent historian yesterday named Arne Westad for my important podcast "The Permanent Questions."
And he's worried that we're on the verge of a global war. And his argument is that world affairs becomes most dangerous when you have one rising power, China, and one relatively declining power. That's us.
And when that happens, as it happened before World War I, when you had a rising Germany and a declining Britain, is that the power dynamics of the world are scrambled. Nobody knows where they stand. Everybody feels insecure. You get these combinations of hubris and fear and anxiety, and people -- and they get rising nationalisms.
And people do crazy stuff because they're just terrified of what the world has come to. And his argument is that the world is now -- with Xi and Putin and Trump, we're in that kind of world. And so that he thinks there's a possibility something like Sarajevo, some assassination, some crazy thing will happen, and everything will just go ballistic.
So having had that conversation with Arne, and then seeing this, I think nothing was advanced in the summit, but I can't be upset that the three leaders are meeting, because one of the things you do not want in a volatile world is people misinterpreting each other. You don't want them judging each other by their public statements.
You want them judging each other by the private statements that they say to each other, and that has a pacifying effect. And so I don't love the fact that Trump thinks Putin is a friend or that Xi is a friend. I don't think they're friends. But in -- with this alarming thing in my mind, I think, OK, at least they got together.
NAWAZ: So, Jonathan, whether it's to mitigate a world war by meeting, or, as the president said, look, you have to engage even with your adversaries, what do you make of that?
JONATHAN CAPEHART, MS NOW: Yes, you should meet with your adversaries. President Trump is not the first American president to meet with America's adversaries.
What puts President Trump in a league of his own, one is that he believes that the leaders of Russia and China are his friends. Two, he went to the table to talk to them with no real agenda that is sort of an America-first agenda. And, three, he did not come away from the table with any deliverables.
You have a war in Ukraine that President Putin is waging, and you have got the United States at war with Iran, that China is helping Iran. Both of them are helping Iran. President Trump should have been at that table pounding his fists, saying to them, you guys have to cut out what you're doing, because, at a minimum, you are putting my service members at risk.
None of that happened. And the press conference today was enraging, because the president, the first thing he says is nothing about this -- nothing about the summit, nothing about any deliverables or tangible achievements.
It was about that plane that he got from Qatar, a used plane, mind you, that he flew overseas, bragging about how it can go faster and go farther, which makes me wonder, has it been armed with all the things that made Air Force One, a flying fortress -- we still don't know if the president of the United States is flying around on an extremely vulnerable plane.
And, as you can tell, I'm still mad about that -- about that press conference.
NAWAZ: Well, can I get David to respond briefly to what you just said there about sort of -- take away the fact that maybe there weren't hard deliverables, that it is good that world leaders meet.
The messaging from the president after the fact has been very much that this was a win for the U.S., that he is friends, personal friends, with Putin, maybe not friends with the U.S. What do you make of that?
BROOKS: Yes, I think both what Jonathan and I said are true at different levels.
And so I'm talking about the global picture of a possible another World War I. Like, that's up here.
But in the immediate context of the next six months, the war in Iran, the war in Ukraine, these are pieces of that, and they have the potential, not as big as Taiwan, but they have the potential to be flash points to create that larger crisis.
And so I agree with what Jonathan said. We are not friends with Putin. We should make that clear we find him repugnant, and we find Xi kind of repugnant. And the problem with Xi is that they're not just a rising power. They're a rising power possibly on the verge of decline. Their growth rates are collapsing.
Their demographics are terrible. Their debt is terrible. Their government is getting more and more erratic. And the most dangerous part of what you get when you get these power transfers is when a regime decides we have got a window to act, and that window is closing. And so we better do something about Taiwan.
And did Trump talk about any of this? Does he have the global vision to think what the world situation is? Obviously not. But it doesn't hurt to at least have some communication, so they don't -- the misunderstandings of each other are not legion.
Recommended

Presidential
Erick Erickson: Republicans Risk Losing The White House By Nominating JD Vance
Conservative commentator Erick Erickson, host of The Erick Erickson Show , argues that Republicans risk jeopardizing their 2028 White House chances by...

Presidential
Trump: I Didn't Say I Was Unhappy With What Vance Said About Iran
President Donald Trump responded to a question about the Iran war and Vice President JD Vance by CNN's Kaitlan Collins at a press conference on...

Foreign Policy & National Security
Hillary Clinton: Trump Cares About Looking Like He Belongs In The Company of Xi & Putin, They "Play Him Like A Child's Guitar"
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton joins Kara Swisher on The On Podcast to discuss President Trump's trip to China. KARA SWISHER, HOST: But...
Latest Videos

Obama to Jeffries: "You've Got To Figure Out How To Actually Get Sh*t Done With Your Colleagues"
White House
Rubio: The Idea That The U.S., Russia, & China Should Not Engage Is Absurd
White House
Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Musk: Zelensky Asking To Use Starlink For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Hakeem Jeffries: Musk And Others Behind Trump Administration "Carnage" Will Answer For Their Actions
MSNBC

Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Musk: Zelensky Asking To Use Starlink For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Rubio: The Idea That The U.S., Russia, & China Should Not Engage Is Absurd
White House
Obama to Jeffries: "You've Got To Figure Out How To Actually Get Sh*t Done With Your Colleagues"
White House
Trump to Xi: As Long As You And I Are In Charge Of Things, We Will Never Have A Problem
White House










