Musk: Zelensky Is Asking To Use Starlink Commercial Satellite System For Offensive Military Actions
Last updated 10:52 AM ET
Elon Musk explained the difference between use of the commercial product, Starlink, and the military-contracted version, Starshield, in the Ukraine War during an event at the NY Times Dealbook summit on Wednesday.
"What I'm trying to tell you is Zelensky is actually asking to use the Starlink commercial satellites for offensive military actions, and we have declined to do so, as we have declined to do so from the beginning of this conflict. End of story," he said.
"It's true that from an invasion standpoint, Russia is the aggressor. But it is also true that we Americans staged a coup to overthrow the democratically elected pro-Russian president of Ukraine," he said. "Without U.S. State Department and other agency help, this would not have happened. That is obviously an offensive action."
"There's been too much of this 'Ukraine good, Russia bad,' anything done to the Russians is excusable," Musk said. "You should have empathy not just for the Ukrainian boys who are dying, but also for the Russian ones, because they're conscripted and forced to go to that line. Nobody voluntarily goes to a line just to die in a drone strike."
ELON MUSK, SPACEX CEO: In the Starlink system, there's a speed limit... which means you can drive around and you can do anything up to 80 miles an hour. That's it.
So I repeatedly said, look, if they want to do something that's an offensive military action, it needs to be the Starshield system, where the kill decision is that of the War Department, perhaps ultimately the president, and not mine.
And that's how it's going to be. Those are the rules that have been in place since the beginning, for years. Now, people are pressuring me to change it, but I'm not changing it.
And let me tell you a bit more about this, because I can tell you a lot about this war and the origins and the history, a lot more than I think hardly anyone could tell you. Because I struggle with what is the right thing to do.
What troubles me morally is a continued conflict where thousands of kids are sent in to die every day with no change in the borders, forever. And I think anyone who supports that is a horrible human being or has not thought through the problem.
And you should have empathy not just for the Ukrainian boys who are dying, but also for the Russian ones, because they're conscripted and forced to go to that line. Nobody voluntarily goes to a line just to die in a drone strike.
And now those sons are never going to see their—you know, the kids of those men are never going to see their father again. Imagine if that was your son or your dad.
And I think that there's been too much of this "Ukraine good, Russia bad, anything done to the Russians is excusable." That's an unkind thing and a horrible position to take.
And I can go on on this topic for a while.
ANDREW ROSS SORKIN, THE NEW YORK TIMES COLUMNIST: But let me ask you one question.
MUSK: Let me anticipate some of your questions. "Russia is the aggressor." I can maybe spend a moment on this one, okay?
It's true that from an invasion standpoint, Russia is the aggressor. But it is also true that we Americans staged a coup to overthrow the democratically elected pro-Russian president of Ukraine.
Does that not strike you as an offensive action? Without U.S. State Department and other agency help, this would not have happened. That is obviously an offensive action.
I mean, the full answer would take too long. Maybe I should just write this up and articulate it. It sounds like I'm making excuses for Russia, but I'm not.
I mean, if you look at what my actions have done, SpaceX, for example, has resulted in the reduction of Russian space activities by two-thirds because we took away their Soyuz launches. We took away their commercial rocket launches and reduced the Russian aerospace industry by a factor of three. I'm not exactly someone who has aided Russia. We have no business in Russia. We have nothing in Russia.
SORKIN: So just help us with this, though. There's one piece that I just—and maybe this will clarify it. President Zelensky talks about the fact that they are using—he refers to it as Starshield, that he is using Starshield, the system of the U.S. government, and then claiming that that is the system that was slowed down. So that's what I want to understand.
MUSK: That's false. I don't want to blow your mind, but Zelensky is not always truthful. Okay? So maybe that comes as a shock.
SORKIN: No, no. So does Ukraine—
MUSK: He's not always truthful. No, he's not always truthful.
SORKIN: Does Ukraine have access at all to Starshield, the U.S. system? Is the U.S. giving that system to Ukraine, or are they simply working off of the commercial system called Starlink? Because maybe what's happening here is some of this is getting conflated.
MUSK: I think some of this is getting conflated. There are two satellite systems. One is the Starlink commercial satellite system. The other is Starshield.
Starshield is controlled by the U.S. government. Any action taken by Starshield is up to the War Department. Starlink is commercial and is not intended as a weapon of war. It is intended to just be helpful to people. It's meant as civilian infrastructure.
And so when President Zelensky talks about using Starshield, he is not using Starshield. He's lying. He's lying.
And what he is actually saying is he wants to use Starlink for offensive military operations.
SORKIN: Have you talked to President Trump about them, meaning Ukraine, having access to Starshield? Or has anyone in the U.S. government talked about Ukraine having access to that so that it's not controlled by the commercial side of this?
MUSK: Starshield is not controlled by the commercial side of things.
SORKIN: No, I understand that. That's why I'm asking. I'm asking whether—controlled by the U.S. government, right? I'm asking whether you asked them what they want to do with it.
MUSK: Right. No, what I'm trying to tell you is Zelensky is actually asking to use the Starlink commercial satellites for offensive military actions, and we have declined to do so, as we have declined to do so from the beginning of this conflict. End of story.
SORKIN: So what's so interesting about this is, you know, we talked to Mark Carney, the prime minister of Canada, and others. So many people have looked at this story and suggested that a single person, meaning you, shouldn't have the power to turn on or turn off one of these services in the middle of a war.
And that this is too much power for one single individual, right? I mean, that's the argument. You've read it, you've seen it.
And as a result, some of these other people are talking about diversifying away from either using Starlink or trying to find other satellite services or this or that.
MUSK: Diversify away. Don't use Starlink.
SORKIN: No, I understand that. But what I'm trying to understand is whether you think that there is a misunderstanding about who's controlling the satellites.
MUSK: I think there are both deliberate lies and misunderstanding and lack of understanding.
But nothing has changed with regard to Starlink. The same rules that have been in place for Starlink from the beginning are in place today.
And you can look at my X posts and my Twitter posts, and I'm very clear that the Starlink satellites are not for use for offensive military operations.
I don't want Starlink commercial to become party to a war, which we would be if we allowed Starlink to be used for offensive military operations. That's why Starshield was created, so that any kill decision there is done by the War Department, as it should be, not me.
And we've not turned off Starlink. This is false.
By the way, Walter Isaacson made an error in his book, because when he wrote the book—and he acknowledges this error, and you can ask him about it—a false statement was put out by Ukraine saying that, this is a few years ago, that I had turned off Starlink for an offensive strike against the Russian fleet in Sevastopol.
This is completely false. At the time, the Starlink satellite beams were not on in Crimea. They were not on because Russia was a sanctioned country, and it would have been illegal for us to turn the beams on in a sanctioned country without State Department approval.
Latest Videos

Musk: Zelensky Is Asking To Use Starlink Commercial Satellite System For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Warner: "These Are Not Coordinated Cyber Attacks"--AI Improving Existing Systems Faster Than They Can Handle
MSNBC
Rubio to Press on 'Dirty Bomb' Threat: "Some Of Your Intelligence Sources Are Liars, Others Are Liars And Criminals"
Campaign Ads
Halperin: Government's Cyberattack Response Is A "Dress Rehearsal And A Failure"
Special Report
Bezos: Trump Is The "Most Accessible" President; None Of His Predecessors Were Half As Communicative
World News
Megyn Kelly Reacts To Vance's Iran War Timeline: "They Don't Know How To Get Us Out Of There"
World News

Camille Paglia on Frat Parties and Consent: "He Is Right to Think You Have Consented"
World News
Jennifer Welch: I Want Barron and Tiffany Trump Investigated, "I Want Them To Have Trials"
White House
Megyn Kelly: Republicans Are "No Longer Interested In The Trump Show" And Are "Over The Grift"
World News
Bill Maher To Critics Of Trump Dinner: "I Did It Again, B*tches. You Know What? F*ck You. I Like These Dinners"
Real Time
NC Mom Challenges School Board on LGBTQ Issues: Schools Are "Not a Counseling Session"
Campaign Ads
Gov. Sherrill: Get Rid Of The Electoral College, One Vote In New Jersey Is Worth 1/5 Of A Wyoming Vote
World News












