Citizens All, or Not at All
Published Jan. 14, 2011 • Read time: 4m
BOSTON -- Is citizenship losing its meaning? In a world of relentless migration, dual nationalities and cultural inclusiveness, is the emotional attachment to the nation and to fellow Americans slowly withering?
These fundamental questions underlie the debate over birthright citizenship, but also have central implications in public support for taxes, health care reform, school funding, military service or just civil discourse, something particularly valued this past week.
Most of Europe, Australia, Canada and other countries with universalist ideals of tolerance are struggling with these same questions. But while opposing advocates hurl charges of racism, Islamophobia, welfare-gouging or immigrant criminality that have elements of truth, they add more confusion than clarity.
The public decibels drown out a more crucial discussion taking place among legal scholars and social scientists. This one turns on questions of whether citizenship is or should be based on blood or birthplace, be consensual or ascriptive, or be inclusive or exclusive. Each comes with its own debated policy cost.
If there is a conclusion for President Obama and congressional leaders it is that they should move with humility in tinkering with citizenship in the face of inexorable historical trends and unintended consequences.
One of the most provocative and discussed studies is fatalistic. Temple University professor Peter J. Spiro in his recent book, "Beyond Citizenship: American Identity After Globalization," maintains that the decline of citizenship as a "meaningful" or "real" concept is irreversible. It has become a mere legalistic idea based on rights, not duties, and nations compete for immigrants.
Culture Wars, Old and New
The Better Option
Trust -- Society Depends On It
Family Fragmentation: Can Anything Be Done?
The value of American citizenship has been diluted by over-inclusiveness, he writes. Inclusion may be necessary, but he says: "Once everyone is an American, no one is an American." He offers no solutions.
Jeff Redding of Saint Louis University, writing in the current issue of the Minnesota Law Review, is more hopeful. He says Spiro is wrong in using religion and some other institutions as proof that exclusion is necessary to build identity and internal cohesion.
Birthright citizenship is just one factor in Spiro's glum analysis. Garrett Epps of the University of Baltimore addresses the historical roots of the practice head-on in the current American University Law Review. An expert on the 14th Amendment, Epps extensively cites legislative debate transcripts, reigning 19th-century political theorists and other evidence to prove pretty much conclusively that the framers of the amendment, drafted after the Civil War, intentionally meant for it to include immigrants and not just freed slaves, as some claim.
He specifically takes aim at "Citizenship Without Consent," a 1985 book by Peter Schuck of Yale University and Rogers M. Smith of the University of Pennsylvania that is a bible for anti-birthrighters. Schuck and Smith call birthright "something of a bastard concept in American ideology. For all its appealing simplicity, it remains a puzzling idea."
They argue instead for consensual citizenship in general: You have to ask for it and the country has to agree to give it to you. The children of unauthorized immigrants are tainted from the get-go by their parents' status and so are excluded.
Epps allows that consensual citizenship might be worthy, but it is not an originalist position, as much as many of the anti-birthrighters claim.
The children of Chinese and Gypsy immigrants figured prominently in those 19th-century Senate debates. The Chinese were ineligible for naturalization, while most Gypsies had no papers at all. "Undoubtedly," Sen. Lyman Trumbull, an author of the 14th Amendment, replied to a question about whether its language applied to children of the two.
The proportion of foreign-born in the country was about the same then as now, Epps notes, as were concerns about assimilation and national unity.
Schuck returns to the fray in the current issue of the Hoover Institute's Policy Review with an essay on "citizen terrorists." He is surprised that not even 9/11 and the threat from naturalized citizens who become terrorists have been enough to get the nation to update its citizenship laws. He notes again that one of the problems with a birthright concept to citizenship is that, unlike naturalized citizenship, it is near impossible to take away.
For more than a century, however, it's been the American way.
Copyright 2011, Washington Post Writers Group

Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
