
What Each Candidate Needs to Do in N.H. Debates
Published Jan. 7, 2012 • Read time: 8m
Join the Conversation
0BRENTWOOD, N.H. -- Last summer, Republican activist Claira Monier had to practically beg her family and friends to come to a barbeque and hear Rick Santorum explain why he thinks he should be president of the United States. "I had trouble getting people to come," she recalls. "You wouldn't believe the calls I had to make."
Eventually, some 30 people showed up in her backyard. But by the end of the night, in a foreshadowing of the success of Santorum’s one-person-at-a-time strategy in Iowa, she could barely get them to go home. “Senator Santorum answered every question they had, until it was about 11 p.m.,” she said. “He stayed and stayed and stayed.”
She laughs about it now, as does Santorum, who acknowledged this week that Monier chides him about his absurdly long answers to questions from voters. That trait has been on display at town-hall meetings, including one hosted by Monier on Wednesday after Santorum arrived in New Hampshire flush with his near-win in the Iowa caucuses. This time she didn’t have to worry about papering the house. Santorum packed them in -- the audience was 10 times as large as the one last summer.
“Don’t settle for someone who can win,” he told the big crowd, taking direct aim at Mitt Romney’s strategy of portraying himself as the best general election candidate. “This is the time for bold colors, ladies and gentlemen, not pale pastels.”
Pale is not in Rick Santorum’s normal palette -- and he certainly doesn’t do pastel. A full-throated social conservative and cheerful culture warrior, Santorum learned this week that he wasn’t in Iowa anymore when students jeered him for implicitly criticizing New Hampshire’s same-sex marriage law -- and by equating gay marriage with polygamy.
Lies, Assault and Cover-ups Don't Stop Donald Trump
Trump Stands by His Man; Obama on a Health Scourge; Hayden Interview; Reagan's Courage
Analysis: For Trump, Few Limits to Win-At-Any-Cost Approach
What If Clinton Isn't Indicted?
Santorum has been peppered with questions raised by John McCain and other surrogates for front-runner Romney about whether he availed himself and his constituents of pork-barrel projects known as spending “earmarks” when he represented Pennsylvania in the Senate. Earmarks, McCain has been saying this week, “are gateways to corruption.”
But Santorum’s biggest barrier in his quest to build on his Iowa success isn’t his opponents. It’s time. Santorum is drawing big crowds, contributions are flooding in, and his poll numbers are inching upward daily. But Election Day here comes Tuesday, only one week after Iowa. For Santorum, the upshot is that the money has come too late to buy television time here, which means that his hopes -- like those of his rivals -- rest to a great degree on a stage he will share with the other four candidates during debates Saturday night and Sunday morning.
Public opinion polls show Romney’s lead holding steady at above 40 percent, with Ron Paul at about half that number, and Santorum, Newt Gingrich and Jon Huntsman bunched in a third tier. Those numbers suggest a spirited fight for second place, with the likelihood that the guy who finishes last may be finished. So what does each man have to do in the debates?
Newt Gingrich: The former House speaker was riding high in the Iowa polls until a barrage of negative ads aired by pro-Romney forces brought him down to earth. Gingrich was embittered by it, and said so. He has signaled that he will go directly after Romney in the debates. Complaints about super PACs aren’t likely to galvanize New Hampshire Republicans, however. What would help Gingrich is the same thing that helped him earlier in the cycle: Perform so well in this format that Republican voters start spontaneously fantasizing about Gingrich talking circles around President Obama in general election debates next autumn.
“Watch the debates this weekend,” Herman Cain said Friday afternoon, “and I predict you will see a resurgence of Newt Gingrich.”
Jon Huntsman: Huntsman was a wildly popular governor of Utah, arguably the most conservative state in the union, when Obama tapped him to be ambassador to China. It’s a sign of the times that Huntsman is now the raging moderate in the field. That’s problematic enough in the modern GOP, but Huntsman’s other problem is that he doesn’t even rage. The affable candidate, mired in single digits, could help himself by showing some passion. Some nimrod fan of Ron Paul’s gave Huntsman just such an opening by posting a racist screed on YouTube targeting Huntsman and his family for adopting a Chinese girl.
The former ambassador called the hit piece “stupid,” but Huntsman can do better. Also, judging by an anti-Romney attack ad aired by Huntsman’s political action committee, he also finally may be willing to go directly after the front-runner in the debate. He probably needs to.
Rick Santorum: Earlier in the process, Santorum was often shunted off to the side -- “stage right” it’s called -- and was given short shrift by debate moderators. That’s less likely to happen this weekend, which is the good news. The bad news is that some of the answers Santorum has been giving in town-hall meetings seem stark in a debate format.
The former senator is a friendly and good-looking man who speaks with a ready smile. But the words that come out his mouth can be jarring. This week he asserted that the “pursuit of happiness” language in the Declaration of Independence was actually a call for “restraint” from our hedonistic impulses, that the excesses of the French Revolution could be traced to the revolutionaries’ failure to enunciate natural rights -- didn’t believe in God, in other words -- and that Barack Obama “hates” the blue-collar workers who work in the energy sector of our economy.
Santorum’s task is to keep inspiring social conservatives who admire his faith and principles without sounding extreme.
Ron Paul: This is also Ron Paul’s task, although his views are diametrically opposed to Santorum’s on foreign policy and social issues. Paul’s non-interventionist stance and libertarianism on domestic policy are anathema to most Republicans. But he remains in second place in New Hampshire, and has saturated the airwaves with hard-hitting and effective ads. Given the YouTube video, Paul would be well-served to express racial tolerance, and perhaps make a direct overture to Huntsman.
In fact, a pro-Paul political action committee is already running poignant television spots this week featuring an African-American man who credited Paul with saving his wife’s life -- without even charging him a fee. “He’s just an honest man,” the man says, “and that’s something we need now in this day and time.”
Paul is also the least likely candidate to be hurt -- or helped -- by how he does in the debates. His supporters are that loyal. “He has a ceiling, but he also has a floor,” says Patrick Griffin, a fellow with the Institute of Politics at Saint Anselm College, where Saturday night’s debate will be held. “But his ceiling is his floor.”
Mitt Romney: His job is to not fall down. He’s a known commodity in this state, and should win, barring an unexpected gaffe.
“Imagine him debating Obama,” Gingrich said contemptuously of Romney on Friday. “Obama’s going to laugh at him.” That seems unlikely, and it’s unlikelier still that New Hampshire residents will laugh at Romney, who is so confident of his chances here, he spent a couple of days this week in South Carolina.
“It was an unusual thing we did four years ago,” Romney said while campaigning with South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley. “We elected someone we didn’t know very well to be president.”
In New Hampshire, at least, voters know Romney, so he’s in the enviable position in the debates of only having to be himself. The trick will be ignoring the jabs from his rivals, who will allot some of their time to making the case that there are several Mitt Romneys, and it’s hard to keep them straight.
Santorum made this point rather cleverly earlier in the week.
“Americans don’t vote for a president based on a check list of issues,” he said. “They elect a leader they trust. You’re not going to agree with me on every issue. But I always agree with me.”
Rick Perry: The Texas governor started out at the top of the polls, and descended -- largely on the basis of his weak debate performance -- to the point where he’s not really campaigning in New Hampshire. Obviously, Perry cannot have another “oops” moment or forget a Cabinet-level department he wants to abolish. The other candidates are likely to avoid clashing with Perry, but there is enough friction between he and Romney (and he and Paul) that they may tangle. Rick Perry has no real hopes of finishing in the money in New Hampshire. His audience Saturday night and Sunday morning will be Republican voters in South Carolina, the site of the next primary and the place he is headed Sunday as soon as the debate ends.
Saturday’s debate airs on ABC starting at 9 p.m. Eastern. On Sunday morning, the candidates will square off again on NBC’s “Meet the Press.”

Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
