
Iowa Remains Deeply Unsettled as Straw Poll Nears
Published July 22, 2011 • Read time: 10m
DES MOINES, Iowa -- Republican establishment types in the nation's first voting state quietly refer to it as The Doomsday Scenario. And it goes something like this:
On a scorching, triple-digit Saturday in central Iowa next month, many of the casually attuned GOP caucus-goers who had planned to attend the Ames Straw Poll instead decide to stay home or make a beeline for the nearest air-conditioned movie theater.
Meanwhile, throngs of the famously devoted supporters of Texas Rep. Ron Paul wipe the sweat off their brows without batting an eye and descend on the campus of Iowa State University to propel the libertarian-leaning icon to yet another straw-poll victory -- but one that might actually be significant for once.
The win gets Paul some nice press but does little to shake the ingrained perception that he has little shot at winning the caucuses and next-to-zero chance of becoming the last Republican candidate standing, the one who will take on President Obama in November 2012.
Renewed questions about Iowa's relevance gain steam immediately -- not just with respect to the decidedly inequitable beauty contest in Ames but, more broadly, to the state's coveted "special status" that officials here have fought so hard to justify amid skepticism from Republican voters in the other 49 states, who wonder why it is deserved.
Though early polls and assessments of the candidates' organizational strengths have already established a pervading narrative about what is likely to happen here, conversations with likely caucus-goers, campaign operatives and state GOP officials reveal a consensus on just one point: The field remains fluid and the conventional wisdom of the moment will almost certainly change well before the leaves start to do the same this fall.
Lies, Assault and Cover-ups Don't Stop Donald Trump
Trump Stands by His Man; Obama on a Health Scourge; Hayden Interview; Reagan's Courage
Analysis: For Trump, Few Limits to Win-At-Any-Cost Approach
What If Clinton Isn't Indicted?
In an Iowa campaign cycle that has gotten off to a much slower and sleepier start than almost anyone anticipated, a Ron Paul straw-poll victory is one of several plausible scenarios that have the potential to dramatically alter the current dynamic, in which Minnesota Rep. Michele Bachmann has opened up a consistent lead in recent polls.
Late Entrants
For months, Republican political watchers here were particularly effusive in their praise for the budding campaign operations of three likely candidates: former Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, former Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum, and former House Speaker Newt Gingrich. They were seen to be doing Iowa the right way: making early and frequent visits to the state, signing veteran operatives, and building infrastructures that would pay dividends down the road.
But with just three weeks to go before the straw poll, all three have remained mired in the low single digits in most Iowa polls, as Bachmann, a relatively late entrant into the race who has not yet spent much time in the state, has quickly shot into the lead.
And with the potential late entries of Texas Gov. Rick Perry and former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin -- both of whom could prove to be major factors, even though they haven't made early investments in the state -- the ingrained gospel that there are no shortcuts to winning in Iowa could face a significant challenge.
"It's not too late for either of them to get in," Dallas County GOP Chairman Rob Taylor said of Perry and Palin, noting the power of social media to help make up for lost ground. Taylor paused for a second before adding, in a moment of candor, "In fact, maybe it was too early for some of the others who have been in."
The Perry buzz has been particularly palpable lately, as the easygoing Texan has become the latest unannounced candidate to garner the fascination of Iowans who have greeted the current field with a collective shrug.
In a recent incident that highlighted the tension between state officials who want to preserve the Ames Straw Poll's quirky traditions and those who fault the state party fundraiser for its archaic rules (which come across as silly to outsiders), the Iowa branch of Americans for Rick Perry -- a 527 advocacy group designed to generate interest for his potential candidacy -- earlier this week was unexpectedly denied the opportunity to purchase space for the August event.
A state party spokesman said that the ruling was a clear-cut case of the group having missed the deadline to reserve space, but the pro-Perry organization had a different take.
"In effect, the decision was made to prohibit our participation," Craig Schoenfeld, the group's Iowa executive director, told RCP.
Pawlenty's Last Stand?
Though he has worked relentlessly to downplay expectations in Ames, Pawlenty cannot escape the reality that the straw poll figures to make or break his campaign.
He has become fond of pointing out that he entered the race officially just two months ago, but Pawlenty has been working Iowa since 2009 and has thus far has little to show for it.
A senior campaign official told RCP that the Pawlenty camp has invested about $1 million in advertising, direct mail, transportation arrangements and other straw poll-centric ventures. The number is far smaller than what former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney doled out in advance of his 2007 Ames victory but it nonetheless surpasses what Pawlenty's competitors have spent and suggests an implicit acknowledgment of the do-or-die situation he faces.
A win in Ames -- or, just maybe, a close second-place showing -- could finally provide some momentum for Pawlenty, but anything less would likely be regarded as the first nail in his political coffin.
Pawlenty is currently winding down the first leg of a two-week Iowa bus tour, in which he has increasingly relied on warning caucus-goers to vote with their heads, not their hearts.
"One of the messages we're trying to convey to Iowa -- they've got this deserved status and important status as first in the nation, but Iowa doesn't just want to be first, they want to be right," Pawlenty told reporters in Indianola on Wednesday after addressing a politely subdued crowd of 40 people at a town-hall meeting.
His campaign purports to being satisfied with its direction, confident that a surge is just around the corner. But if Pawlenty puts in a sub-par performance in Ames, the latest bend in his road to the White House will almost certainly lead directly into a brick wall.
Romney's Quiet Campaign
Perhaps the most significant test to Iowa's relevance to date has been the decision by the national front-runner for the Republican nomination -- former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney -- to downplay the state and decline to compete in the straw poll, following on the heels of eventual Republican nominee John McCain's successful 2008 strategy, which used the same tactic.
But while the Romney campaign has done a solid job of downplaying expectations in the Hawkeye State as it focuses on New Hampshire and other early states, there are plenty of reasons to believe that the 2007 Ames Straw Poll winner may make a much stronger play in the state than what he and his aides have publicly let on.
The Romney campaign has just two paid staffers and about a dozen volunteers working in Iowa -- a far cry from the virtual army of operatives that blanketed the state on his behalf four years ago. But his team knows the names and numbers of each of the approximately 30,000 Iowans who caucused for Romney the last time around, and the vaunted Romney operation has already had a critical test-run to figure out how to get their supporters to turn out.
Though Romney's all-in Iowa campaign strategy of 2007 is often viewed in retrospect as a fool's errand, it is not too difficult to imagine that if one or two things had broken in a slightly different way, he may very well have overtaken former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee in the 2008 caucuses, rather than finishing in a debilitating second place.
The Iowa GOP electorate has a well-deserved reputation for emphasizing ideological purity above practical political considerations, but there is an often overlooked establishment wing of the state party, the members of which could very well coalesce around Romney, especially if Pawlenty fails to catch fire.
"They're quietly trying to play -- I've gotten calls," Romney's 2008 Iowa chairman, Doug Gross, told RCP of his former colleagues at Romney headquarters in Boston. "And they need to because they've got to be worried about Perry. If Perry comes in here and becomes the hot product and the alternative to Bachmann real quick, that's not a good thing for Romney."
In an acknowledgment of how unpredictable the situation in Iowa remains, Romney officials privately purport to seeing a "low ceiling and a high floor" for their candidate here. They know all too well that whatever effort they are perceived to be putting into the state will be met with a higher than commensurate spike in those dreaded expectations, but the Romney campaign is on standby to more forcefully mobilize its Iowa resources, in case the political waters here prove too tempting to resist.
The most effective manner in which it has thus far kept expectations low has been the decision to keep the candidate physically away from Iowa. He has made just one trip to the state thus far this year.
Romney plans to attend the Iowa State Fair on Aug. 11, RCP has learned, before taking the stage at the GOP debate in Ames that night. The former Massachusetts governor will then high-tail it out of town before the straw-poll gates open -- and before anyone might accuse him of trying too hard.
The Paul Wildcard
Of all the scenarios that could turn the situation in Iowa on its head, a potential Paul victory at the straw poll is among the most intriguing -- and also laden with unpredictable aftershocks.
The possibility of a Paul win in Ames may seem implausible at first glance, given the Texas congressman's fifth-place showing at the 2007 straw poll, but he is going all-in this year in a way that he declined to do the last time around.
The Paul campaign purchased the most coveted real estate from the state party for the event, has been advertising heavily on Iowa TV for weeks, and the libertarian-leaning icon will spend the better part of the critical days leading up to Ames on the stump in Iowa.
Paul's Iowa campaign is well organized and purports to have harnessed the recent political winds to position itself as more of a mainline entity than the eccentric insurgent operation that it was the last time around.
"Four years ago, I remember John McCain and some of the other candidates snickering when Ron Paul talked about the Fed printing money out of thin air, and now everyone's talking about it," said Paul's Iowa vice chairman, A.J. Spiker. "Congressman Paul has held several meet-and-greets throughout Iowa, and one thing that's really different from four years ago is we're seeing a lot of traditional Republicans at events -- county GOP people that are coming. The message is resonating and they're really paying attention to it."
Spiker downplayed the possibility that the relevance of a Paul victory in Ames would largely be dismissed. "If top-tier campaigns do poorly at the straw poll, it will be representative of their organizations," he said. "It'll be a big deal because it's Iowa."
Indeed, the "big deal" nature of the state that has long been sacrosanct in American politics appears safe for now. But depending on what happens in Ames and afterward, the role that Iowa plays in Republican presidential politics and the strategies that candidates take here may never again be the same.

Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
