Netanyahu's Historic Speech
Published May 25, 2011 • Read time: 6m
In what likely will be remembered as an historic speech, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made four points yesterday charting a path to peace which the Obama administration will not want to follow.
Netanyahu appeared relaxed, speaking in gracious but firm terms about Iran and for the third time in response to President Obama's push for the formation of a Palestinian state based on Israel's 1967 borders. He spoke to the congressional audience which included several members of the Obama cabinet from which both Secretary of State Clinton and Defense Secretary Gates were conspicuously absent. Speaking for about fifty minutes, Netanyahu was interrupted by bipartisan standing ovations about twenty-seven times.
The Israeli PM said that time was "running out" to stop Iran's nuclear weapons program from achieving its goal. Netanyahu pointed out that the ayatollahs only interrupted that program once, in 2003, when they believed a military action could thwart them. He said that the more Iran believes that "all options are on the table", the less likely a confrontation would be.
At this point, although the president insists that Netanyahu's statement of "all options" is American policy, there is a great distance between our policy and our actions toward Iran. There hasn't been a coherent policy toward Iran for more than a decade. Like President Bush before him, Obama has said that Iran's achievement of nuclear weapons is unacceptable. But neither Bush nor (to date) Obama has taken any steps to thwart those ambitions. Obama's cancellation of the ground-based missile defense in Poland, meant to protect Europe from Iran's missiles, leaves Europe vulnerable to such an attack. The only interference with Iran's nuclear program was the "Stuxnet" computer worm (of unknown origin) which disrupted Iran's nuclear enrichment facilities for months.
Nuclear Jihad: The Threats Are Inside Our Tent
Israel's "Sorrow of the Left"
Signs of Progress Against Extremists in Syria
The World Is Getting Worse, But This Time America Won't Save It
Speaking of Iran's Holocaust denial and stated intention to destroy Israel, Netanyahu emotionally renewed the Israeli battle cry that grew out of the World War 2 genocidal slaughter: "When we say ‘never again', we mean never again." By that, Netanyahu implied that Israel will take military action against the Iranian nuclear capability even if it has to act alone.
Netanyahu's three other points were directed at President Obama's push for immediate negotiation with the Palestinians to form a new Palestinian state based on Israeli withdrawal to the June 1967 borders with agreed "land swaps." In his speech last week, Obama made the demand casually, as if an easily achieved goal was blocked only by Israeli obstinacy.
Netanyahu's answers to Obama's proposals were calm but not casual. Putting the onus on Abbas, he reiterated the demand he made in the Oval Office meeting with Obama and reporters last week, that Palestinian President Abbas tear up his power-sharing agreement with the terrorist Hamas organization.
Defying the political correctness of Europe and much of America, Netanyahu said in compelling terms that the reason there has been no peace with the Palestinians and no agreement on a Palestinian state was the Palestinians' refusal to recognize Israel as a Jewish state.
He challenged Abbas to say six words: "I will accept a Jewish state." If Abbas said that, Netanyahu promised, "I will be willing to reach a far-reaching compromise."
Netanyahu said he was ready to make "painful compromises" to achieve peace, adding that those compromises would include giving up parts of the ancestral Israeli homeland. Some Israeli settlements on the West Bank, he said, would fall outside Israel's final borders. Now, about 650,000 Israelis live in those settlements.
But removing settlements doesn't bring peace. As Netanyahu pointed out, Israel withdrew from the Gaza Strip in 2005 in an effort to achieve peace. Palestinians burned abandoned synagogues and didn't stop firing missiles from Gaza into Israel. He said Israel would be generous on the size of a Palestinian state, but will be "...very firm on where we put borders with it."
Saying that Israel's borders had to be defensible, Netanyahu said that a Palestinian state had to be demilitarized and repeated that Israel would have a long-term military presence along the West Bank of the Jordan River. If the Palestinian state weren't demilitarized, he said, Israel would continue to be vulnerable to missile attacks of which Israeli citizens could have less than a minute's warning.
Netanyahu asked congress if they could imagine a siren sounding and having sixty seconds to find shelter from missiles raining down. He said, "You wouldn't want to live like that. We're not going to live that way either." The Israeli PM was unmovable on some parts of the compromise he offered. He was unshakeable on keeping an undivided Jerusalem as Israel's capital. Only while Israel has held sovereignty in Jerusalem, he said, was freedom of religion preserved for all three peoples - Jewish, Christian and Muslim - who claim it as holy ground.
The biggest question left unanswered in President Obama's speech last week is the "right of return" claimed by the people who claim to be descendants of the Palestinians displaced by the formation of Israel. It is one of the demands that no Palestinian leader has ever offered to negotiate.
There are about 2.6 million people who identify themselves as Palestinians who make up the majority of Jordan's population. Some 3.7 million live in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank. Over 1 million live in Syria and Lebanon, about a half million in Saudi Arabia and there are another 200,000 or more reportedly living in South America. Israel's population is about 7.5 million. If it were to absorb the nearly 8 million Palestinians, it would cease to be a Jewish state.
Netanyahu rephrased what he said pointedly to Obama and the press: that the Palestinian refugee problem will be resolved outside the borders of Israel.
Ending his address, Netanyahu again challenged Abbas to tear up the Hamas agreement and make peace. He said that Israel would be the first to support a Palestinian state resolution in the UN this fall if Abbas made the peace he offered.
Netanyahu's speech achieved his principal political goal, increasing his stock among Israel's congressional supporters of both parties. As a result, Obama will find few friends, even in his own party, to increase pressure on Israel to negotiate with the Abbas-Hamas Palestinian government. But it isn't clear how it will affect Obama's position with respect to the American Jewish community.
After Netanyahu's speech, further pressure on Israel to negotiate back to its 1967 borders - and to negotiate at all with the Abbas-Hamas government - could cost Obama much financial support and diminish his strength at the polls.
Will the president risk losing the support of Jewish liberals, or is he so confident of it that he will not mute his demands on Netanyahu?

Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
