
Immigration Bills Are Taking Shape, but Can One Pass?
Published Jan. 29, 2013 • Read time: 8m
Join the Conversation
0Moments of bipartisanship are so fleeting on Capitol Hill these days that when a group of U.S. senators -- four Democrats and four Republicans -- introduced a rough outline for immigration reform Monday, it was considered a breakthrough. The plan, which includes a path to citizenship for illegal residents, prompted the question that will be asked about most major bills over the next two years: Can it get through the Republican-led House of Representatives?
But the lower chamber might soon have an immigration breakthrough of its own. A bipartisan group of House lawmakers is a step ahead of its Senate counterpart, and is currently writing reform legislation that could be unveiled within weeks. While there is little appetite on Capitol Hill for most of the major items on the president’s second-term agenda -- gun control and climate change packages, for example -- immigration seems to be a whole other matter, with a potentially far different fate.
The House group has been working on the issue for nearly four years -- keeping its work under wraps as the details are ironed out -- but the members have been in regular communication with John Boehner, who has expressed support for a comprehensive immigration reform. The speaker hinted at the group’s progress during an address last week to the Ripon Society (a centrist GOP think tank), noting he had not seen the legislation but has faith in the members’ efforts. In a post-election interview with ABC News, he said a “comprehensive approach is long overdue.”
The Rise and Fall of Marco Rubio
An Invasion of Artificial Outrage
Obama Administration Tells Agents to ID Which Immigrants Not to Deport
Green Shoots of Sanity?
President Obama will travel to Las Vegas on Tuesday to unveil his immigration reform plan. The White House has its own bill to back up what emerges in the Senate. The upper chamber’s blueprint, unveiled Monday, involves a comprehensive bill to deal with four key issues: a tough but fair path to citizenship for those already here illegally (while also securing the border); rehabbing the legal immigration system to include work visas for those pursuing advanced degrees; establishing a stronger employment verification system; and hiring immigrant workers for positions not filled by Americans.
Democratic Sens. Chuck Schumer of New York, Dick Durbin of Illinois, Bob Menendez of New Jersey and Michael Bennet of Colorado, along with Republican Sens. John McCain and Jeff Flake of Arizona, Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and Marco Rubio of Florida, have all signed on to the framework.
McCain knows well the legislative perils. He worked with Ted Kennedy in 2007 on a comprehensive bill pushed by President Bush that ultimately failed. What caused the climate change since then? Elections, McCain said. Mitt Romney lost Hispanic voters last fall by 44 percentage points, and McCain suffered a 36-point deficit as a presidential candidate in 2008. The GOP knows it has work to do. "The Republican Party is losing the support of our Hispanic citizens,” he said. “And we realize that there are many issues on which we think we are in agreement with our Hispanic citizens, but this is a pre-eminent issue with those citizens."
Florida Republican Rep. Mario Diaz-Balart, a member of the bipartisan House group, told RCP he is encouraged by the principles outlined by the senators, and called the approach “reasonable and reasoned.” The legislation soon to be introduced in the House is compatible with what the Senate group has proposed, Diaz-Balart said, though he would not elaborate on the specifics or name other lawmakers participating in the House discussions. In addition to Diaz-Balart -- a member of Cuban descent who has broken with his party before on immigration issues -- the group of fewer than a dozen lawmakers includes Democrats Zoe Lofgren and Xavier Becerra of California and Texas Republican John Carter.
The House members have also been in communication with the Senate leaders on the issue. Diaz-Balart said that while House leadership wants to get something done, the process will be arduous. And while one bill is preferred, the tactics for achieving passage are unclear.
Schumer told reporters Monday that the Senate hopes to have its legislation finished and ready for debate by March with passage anticipated in the late spring or summer. Senate Leader Harry Reid praised the proposal in a floor speech Monday.
Rubio, a possible 2016 president contender whose parents came to the United States from Cuba, has become a point man on reform. He recently released a plan of his own that included a pathway to citizenship, and he has been courting conservative activists and radio hosts on his ideas. At a press conference Monday, the freshman senator said the bipartisan proposal would “modernize our legal immigration so that it reflects the reality and needs of the 21st century.”
Despite these signs of progress, there are significant hurdles. The biggest one for Republicans involves the concept of amnesty. Another involves tactics: House GOPers are reluctant to embrace a comprehensive approach, and would instead prefer piecemeal legislation.
Idaho Rep. Raul Labrador (pictured), a conservative who voted against Boehner’s speakership earlier this month, was an immigration attorney before entering Congress and figures to be a key player on this issue in the lower chamber. He has told reporters that he’d like to see a comprehensive approach in the form of a series of bills that would each address a specific issue, allowing different majorities to vote for each one. “I don’t want to draw a line in sand, but it would be very difficult for me to vote for a comprehensive bill, because anytime we’ve done anything comprehensively in the United States Congress, there are a lot of unintended consequences, and a lot of problems with the bill,” he explained.
Other proponents, including some in the bipartisan House group, would like the legislation to come in a single bill because they fear important components could be jettisoned or fail to win approval if the process is a piecemeal one.
House Republicans are on recess this week, and many were mum on the Senate’s plan. Boehner was noncommittal but “welcomes the work of leaders like Sen. Rubio on this issue, and is looking forward to learning more about the proposal in the coming days,” his spokesman said.
South Carolina Rep. Trey Gowdy, the conservative chairman of the subcommittee on immigration, appeared open to the Senate’s outline. "The current immigration system is broken and inspires confidence in no one,” he said. “So, proposals which balance the humanity which defines us as a people with respect for the rule of law which defines us as a republic are welcome."
Judiciary Chairman Bob Goodlatte, a conservative from Virginia and traditionally a hardliner on immigration, said the system desperately needs repair and that his committee plans to explore ways to fix it. But how to address those already here illegally has long been a complicated point of contention. “When we look at proposals that deal with the legal status of 11 million illegal immigrants currently living in the U.S., we have a lot to discuss,” Goodlatte said. “The American people and members of Congress have a lot of questions about how this would work, what it would cost, and how it will prevent illegal immigration in the future. This will have a huge impact on the American people and so we have to carefully evaluate its impact.”
Goodlatte’s predecessor on the committee took a harder line, saying the path to citizenship outlined by the Senate group would only encourage illegal immigration. “No one should be surprised that individuals who have supported amnesty in the past still support amnesty,” said Texas Rep. Lamar Smith, the former Judiciary chairman who now serves on the immigration subcommittee. “When you legalize those who are in the country illegally, it costs taxpayers millions of dollars, costs American workers thousands of jobs and encourages more illegal immigration.”
The lawmakers working on reform legislation recognize that there are some members who simply will not come aboard. But having proponents like Rubio leading the effort on the Senate side helps to rally those who are reluctant. House Budget Chairman Paul Ryan has endorsed Rubio’s approach. “Immigration is a good thing. We’re here because of immigration. We need to make sure it works,” the former vice presidential candidate said Sunday in an interview on “Meet the Press.” “I think that there are Republicans and Democrats, many of us are talking to each other, that can come together with a good solution to make sure that this problem is fixed once and for all.”
Such advocacy could help change colleagues’ perception of a pathway to citizenship that smacks of amnesty. As Diaz-Balart asserted, “If we don’t pass legislation, we are going to have millions of people here. So if you want to do something about people here illegally, we’ve got to pass legislation. Right now there is amnesty.”

Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
