Obamacare Architect: People Were Supposed To Switch To Obamacare On Their Own, Not Get Kicked Off
Last updated 4:13 AM ET
MEGYN KELLY: Let me ask you this because you were there. It's so hard to find people who were actually there when the law was being debated and shaped and so on. And I want to ask you about what's become the most controversial thing we've seen so far and that is these mass -- millions of cancelations in the individual insurance market. Was that foreseen? Was it planned? Have you been surprised by it?
DAVID CUTLER, OBAMACARE ARCHITECT: There are two things the law is designed to do: it's designed to cover most everybody and it's designed to save costs. And the second part is the cost reduction that we've seen, the lowest rate of growth in 50 years.
The first part is the desire to cover people. It is upsetting how difficult that's been for the administration to get going on this. As you know, there were several of us urging a few years ago to try to change the way the administration approached this.
KELLY: You in particular. We'll get to it. Just so the viewers know, you wrote a scathing letter back in May of 2010 to Larry Summers foreseeing a lot of what we are seeing right now. And they apparently didn't listen to you, but I will let you finish your point.
CUTLER: Unfortunately not. So what we have to do now is to say, okay, given where we are, how can we best get people the care that they need? A lot of the difficulty now with the rescissions and so on comes from the fact that people cannot look at the premiums that they face. So for example, there have been any number of stories where people say, 'Gee, I'm being cancelled and it's going to be terrible.' And they feel that way. And then reporters go --
KELLY: And you're saying they can't get on the website. I understand that. But I'm asking a more fundamental, important point which is these cancellations. I mean, the individual insurance market is essentially going away. Was that foreseen? Was that understood by you, by the president, the team putting this law together that it would happen?
CUTLER: It was foreseen that there would be a lot of transition from policies that were less good into cheaper, better policies through the exchanges but that would be because individuals saw it and wanted to do that rather than they were being pushed and couldn't see what was in front of them.
KELLY: So when you saw all these cancellations start popping up in the past few weeks and then it was tied back to this [inaudible] application that Kathleen Sebelius had pushed through shortly after Obamacare became law. Were you surprised? Did you say to yourself, wait a minute, this is not how it was envisioned or did you say, yeah, this is about how we saw it going down? .
CUTLER: No, this is absolutely not how it was envisioned because what was envisioned is that people would be able to see the new premiums and see the new coverage. And many people would say, you know what, I actually don't want this old policy because I could get better coverage for cheaper.
KELLY: It would be a choice. Not that they would be kicked off --
CUTLER: It would be a choice, that is correct.
KELLY: -- because the insurance policies had no choice but to cancel policies that no longer complied with the law.
CUTLER: Correct. So the vast bulk of people who are in the individual market were paying higher premiums per dollar of coverage than people in group coverage. The coverage was much lower quality.
KELLY: I get it, you were trying to get them to behave as a group and not as an individual, which you thought would save costs.
CUTLER: Exactly.
KELLY: Here's my question to you now, because you say that one of the most critical things in this law was to cover almost everyone. That was one of the more overarching goals. Now, right now we're seeing too little coverage. Right now, the latest estimated is over 4 million people canceled and the estimates out tonight are only about 100,000, putting aside the Medicaid enrollees, have enrolled in the exchanges. So, what will happen professor if the numbers aren't there? If the people don't buy this product as was envisioned?
CUTLER: If the numbers aren't there, then the premiums in the exchanges will be very high because the people who will go through the most hoops to get coverage are those for whom the costs are the highest and the existing coverage is the worst. So, it is very important that people get enrolled, that enough people get enrolled through the exchanges.
KELLY: And if they don't, I mean, does the law collapse upon itself?
CUTLER: It doesn't collapse, but it is much, much weaker because all the sudden you have insurance companies that don't know exactly what the mix of enrollees will be, so it becomes very difficult.
Latest Videos

Hakeem Jeffries: Imagine How Angry People Will Be If Washington Fails To Do Anything About Affordability
Face the Nation
Rahm Emanuel: Democratic Voters In LA and NYC Aren't Socialists, They're Angry
Bloomberg Politics
Zelensky: Putin Needs To Understand Crimean Bridge "Will Not Stay"
World News0:27
Obama to Jeffries: "You've Got To Figure Out How To Actually Get Sh*t Done With Your Colleagues"
White House
Rubio: The Idea That The U.S., Russia, & China Should Not Engage Is Absurd
White House
Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report

Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Obama to Jeffries: "You've Got To Figure Out How To Actually Get Sh*t Done With Your Colleagues"
White House
Rubio: The Idea That The U.S., Russia, & China Should Not Engage Is Absurd
White House
David Brooks: China-U.S. Power Shift Mirrors Germany-Britain Dynamic Before World War I
PBS NewsHour
Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Musk: Zelensky Asking To Use Starlink For Offensive Military Actions
World News









