Jonathan Alter: Obama Knew Promises He Made On Obamacare Were Not True
Last updated 4:17 AM ET
HUGH HEWITT, HOST : And here is what Clarence Page, he stunned me on my program earlier this week, by doubting the President’s veracity when he made that statement. Here’s the exchange with Clarence.
HEWITT: He knew he was lying?
CLARENCE PAGE: Probably. Probably. But that’s one of those political lies.
HEWITT: Do you agree with Clarence?
JONATHAN ALTER: Wow. I don’t know exactly how to react to that, because first of all, I don’t know when the statement was that he made it, that he made when he said you know, you absolutely will be able to…was that in 2008? Was that in early 2009?
HEWITT: He said it many, many times throughout 2009 when he was selling the bill.
ALTER: Yeah, so I think where Clarence is right is that politicians in order to get stuff through, they often make a lot of nice sounding promises that they then can’t necessarily keep. But it’s very, in terms of whether he lied or not, I think it’s very important to know whether he said it before or after the law was passed.
HEWITT: If he said it after, if he said it before the law was passed.
ALTER: It was a moving target. If he said it before the law was passed, then I wouldn’t call it a lie, because, you know, the law went through a number of permutations. If he said it after the law was passed, then he knew that wasn’t going to be true.
HEWITT: Jonathan Alter, I always appreciate your candor. I really do, because I think he’s got an amazing, we’ve got a minute left here, he’s got a meltdown on his hands. This is a catastrophic moment.
ALTER: I don’t think so. You and I disagree on this. I think it is pathetic. I’m not rationalizing it in any way, but you know from when I talked to you about Franklin Roosevelt they had a lot of these problems with Social Security, and eventually, it’ll get straightened out. The bill is too complicated, there are things wrong with the bill, but Republicans and critical Democrats need to serve their constituents by trying to fix the bill, not wreck the law. In other words, the thing that’s better for the average person is to make the technical fixes so that it works. It will not be killed, Hugh. You don’t the votes for it. He’s got the veto pen, he’s got the votes in the Senate. Obamacare will not be killed.
HEWITT: Oh, I agree. It’s a zombie program. It is the walking dead, Jonathan Alter.
ALTER: It cannot be…
HEWITT: It cannot be killed.
ALTER: Right. So people should try to fix it and make it work.
HEWITT: It will eat everything available, and then it will die on its own.
ALTER: But if Republicans would change their motive from trying to kill it, which is a futile effort, to trying to fix it, which is a necessity, it must be fixed.
HEWITT: I will not save the zombies, Jonathan. I will not go…We’re out of time. Thank you, my friend. Jonathan Alter, Bloomberg columnist, you’ve got to come back soon. Go read his FDR book. Everyone on the Obama team should. It will encourage them. (Hugh Hewitt Show, October 31, 2013)
Latest Videos

Rahm Emanuel: Democratic Voters In LA and NYC Aren't Socialists, They're Angry
Bloomberg Politics
Zelensky: Putin Needs To Understand Crimean Bridge "Will Not Stay"
World News0:27
Obama to Jeffries: "You've Got To Figure Out How To Actually Get Sh*t Done With Your Colleagues"
White House
Rubio: The Idea That The U.S., Russia, & China Should Not Engage Is Absurd
White House
Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel

Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Obama to Jeffries: "You've Got To Figure Out How To Actually Get Sh*t Done With Your Colleagues"
White House
Rubio: The Idea That The U.S., Russia, & China Should Not Engage Is Absurd
White House
David Brooks: China-U.S. Power Shift Mirrors Germany-Britain Dynamic Before World War I
PBS NewsHour
Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Musk: Zelensky Asking To Use Starlink For Offensive Military Actions
World News









