
It's All Up to the Voters Now
Published June 29, 2012 • Read time: 5m
Before anyone had time to even read Thursday's lengthy Supreme Court decision narrowly approving the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act, the passions and furies of the losing side were unleashed.
One quick consensus, expressed by both liberals and conservatives, was that by upholding Obamacare’s controversial individual mandate on a 5-4 margin -- but only on the grounds that it fell under Congress’ power to tax -- Chief Justice John Roberts and the court’s four-member liberal bloc had handed Republicans a weapon they can use from now until November.
“So Obamacare,” Rush Limbaugh nudged his audience, “is nothing more than the largest tax increase in the history of the world.”
“John Roberts is an evil genius,” lamented liberal Cardozo Law School instructor Robert E. Malchman.
And in a hastily called press conference a few blocks from the Supreme Court building, the Republican Party’s presidential nominee broke it down to its campaign trail essence: “If we want to get rid of Obamacare,” Mitt Romney said, “we’re going to have to replace President Obama.”
Yet winning is almost always better than losing. And so it is with Thursday’s Supreme Court decision. This was a much-needed political victory for Obama. The high court not only saved his signature domestic policy achievement, but it snapped the string of bad news the president has experienced over the last few weeks.
In White House remarks shortly after the court’s ruling, a clearly pleased president declared the decision “a victory for people all over this country whose lives will be more secure because of this law and the Supreme Court’s decision to uphold it.”
Obama reiterated the litany of benefits included in the law -- free checkups and mammograms, kids staying on their parents’ health plans until age 26, prescription drug subsidies for seniors, automatic coverage for pre-existing conditions -- and said that while he didn’t push the law because it was “good politics,” he remains confident Americans will come to appreciate it.
“When we look back five years from now, or 10 years from now, or 20 years from now,” he said, “we’ll be better off because we had the courage to pass this law and keep moving forward.”
This is the case the president will continue to make to voters between now and Election Day. But of relevance right now is how Americans -- specifically, swing voters in swing states -- will feel about this issue when they go to the polls about four months from now.
Thanks to John Roberts’ legal reasoning, Obama’s victory is not an unqualified one. The distinct possibility exists that now that its constitutionality has been upheld, Obama can start to steer the conversation away from the law’s most unpopular feature, the individual mandate, and back onto its more appealing ones, most especially the prohibition barring insurance companies from discriminating against those with pre-existing conditions. That particular feature is so popular that it arose during the Republican presidential primary season at GOP candidate forums -- even among followers of the most conservative Republican contenders.
But what Obama and the Democratic Party will have to parry is the accusation that they slyly levied a substantial tax on the American public. Romney and his fellow Republicans have already begun making this case, asserting that it violates the president’s pledge that he would not raise taxes on anyone making less than $250,000 a year.
The literal answer to that charge -- that it’s only a tax increase for those who won’t buy health insurance -- is likely to strike many voters as too clever by half.
And so while Obama and the other members of his party are relieved by the court’s decision on Thursday, relief doesn’t usually motivate partisans to turn out on Election Day. Anger does. And the conservative base of the Republican Party is definitely livid over this ruling. “Thank you, SCOTUS,” Sarah Palin proclaimed on Twitter and her Facebook page. “This Obamacare ruling fires up the troops as America’s eyes are opened. Thank God.”
If she’s right, and this decision does fire up the foot soldiers of the Republican grassroots, this would be particularly good news for Mitt Romney. During the Republican primary, Rick Santorum often decried Romney as being “uniquely unqualified” to do battle with Obama over the issue of health care. Although Romney eventually outlasted Santorum and the other Republican competitors, he has been slow to win over movement conservatives, whether they are evangelical Christians or the fiscal fundamentalists who operate under the umbrella of the Tea Party movement.
The reaction to the health care ruling parallels how Obama’s coming out in favor of gay marriage galvanized social conservatives to Romney’s side. And although the 2012 Republican nominee may still seem an imperfect vessel for conservatives of any stripe, he’s the only vessel they’ve got. And Thursday’s decision gives him plenty of latitude to make the Republican Party’s case against Obama.
Now it’s all up to the voters, which John Roberts himself noted is exactly where it belongs.
“Members of this court are vested with the authority to interpret the law; we possess neither the expertise nor the prerogative to make policy judgments,” the chief justice wrote in his riveting majority opinion. “Those decisions are entrusted to our nation’s elected leaders, who can be thrown out of office if the people disagree with them. It is not our job to protect the people from the consequences of their political choices.”
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






