
Social Media Texas
NetChoice v. Paxton: Fifth Circuit Saves Social Media Free Speech
COMMENTARY
Published Oct. 4, 2022 • Read time: 10m
It is rare when a RealClearPolitics op-ed becomes a law. But that happened just a few days ago, happily, as the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals fought back against censorship of free speech on the big social media platforms, in a case called NetChoice v. Paxton.
The common wisdom has long been that the Big Tech Giants, as private companies, are outside of the First Amendment free speech requirements directed toward government, and are free to censor any political views at whim. Standing for the minority position, this column has argued five separate times over the last four years (we are nothing if not persistent!) that the common wisdom is wrong. We argued that the big social media sites such as Facebook and Twitter have grown so strong and dominant that they have become equivalent to the "public square" for political speech, and therefore can be prohibited from censorship under the Marsh v. Alabama doctrines or as common carriers. On Sept. 16, 2022, the Fifth Circuit used the same logic, and almost identical language, to allow Texas House Bill 20 to move forward, a bill which mandates equal access to the Internet regardless of political viewpoint. The question is likely to reach the Supreme Court eventually, as the Eleventh Circuit ruled differently in a seemingly analogous case called NetChoice v. Attorney General, State of Florida. The Fifth Circuit’s free speech position in NetChoice v. Paxton deserves to win in the end, however, and there may be some potential refinements that this essay will suggest.
When Protesters Trample Trump's Rights
Donald Trump Should Read Up on Libel Laws
The Left May Well Get Trump Nominated
Trump Foes Should Stay Off His Stage
The debate over Texas House Bill 20 revolved around two sections: Section 7 and Section 2. Section 7 of HB20 states that a social media site with over 50 million users and focused on user generated content cannot censor a user's expression or ability to receive the expression of another person, based on the speaker's viewpoint. The site can only censor speech that it "is specifically authorized to censor by federal law"; expression that "is the subject of a referral or request from an organization with the purpose of preventing the sexual exploitation of children and protecting survivors of sexual abuse from ongoing harassment"; expression that "directly incites criminal activity or consists of specific threats of violence targeted against a person or group because of their race, color, disability, religion, national origin or ancestry, age, sex, or status as a peace officer or judge"; or "unlawful expression."
The remedy is that the blocked user can go to court and sue for declaratory and injunctive relief to remain on the site, and may recover costs and attorney's fees. The attorney general of Texas can also sue to enforce the section and may recover costs and fees if successful as well. Separately, section 2 of HB20 puts some reporting procedures on the big sites, including disclosure of their "acceptable use policy," a "biannual transparency report" with statistics on content-moderation efforts, and requires that the sites maintain some complaint-and-appeal system for their users.
The two lead parties in the case were NetChoice, which represents the big tech social media firms, and Ken Paxton as the attorney general of Texas. Before HB20 was ever actually put into practice, NetChoice sued to enjoin it, and won at the District Court level. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals just lifted the injunction, allowing the law to proceed, and thereby limiting Internet censorship. Judge Andrew Oldham wrote the opinion for a three judge panel.
Judge Oldham's opinion runs for 90 pages, because he carefully addresses each case and argument that the NetChoice advocates raised. The essence of the opinion is short, however, and I believe, irrefutable. Oldham writes:
HB 20 prohibits large social media platforms from censoring speech based on the viewpoint of its speaker...But the platforms argue that buried somewhere in the person's enumerated right to free speech lies a corporation's unenumeratedright to muzzle speech....The implication of the platform's argument are staggering. On the platforms' view, email providers, mobile phone companies, and banks could cancel the accounts of anyone who sends an email, makes a phone call, or spends money in support of a disfavored political party, candidate or business. What's worse, the platforms argue that a business can acquire a dominant market position by holding itself open to everyone... then having cemented itself as the monopolist of “the modern public square”, Packingham v. North Carolina, ... it could turn around and ban all of a specific viewpoint of speech for no other reason than its employees want to pick on members of that community, Oral Arg....
He continues:
In enacting HB 20, the Texas legislature found that the Platforms "function as common carriers, are affected with a public interest, are central public forums for public debates, and have enjoyed governmental support in the United States... HB 20 expressly permits the platform to censor any unlawful expression and certain speech that "incites criminal activity or consists of specific threats" - not to mention any content the Platforms are authorized to censor by federal law... In short, Section 7 chills no speech whatsoever. To the extent it chills anything, it chills CENSORSHIP.
The Court points out that there are no monetary or other damages levied on the platforms that violate HB20; the content users, or Texas attorney general, merely have a chance to go to court and end the censorship. The platform need not endorse any speech; it is free to declare it disagrees with any or all of it.
Oldham goes through the history of the common carrier doctrine at some length, explaining that "This principle has been part of Anglo-American law for more than half a millennium. For early English courts, this principle meant that private enterprises providing essential public services must serve the public, do so without discrimination, and charge a reasonable rate."
The common carrier concept was first applied to ferries centuries ago, and then barges, stagecoaches, gristmills, innkeepers, and wharves. Common carrier doctrine rose to prominence in the U.S. in the late 1800s when the government began to regulate privately owned railroads, grain elevators, and then the telegraph and telephone companies.
The Fifth Circuit draws a strong analogy between the dominant social media sites today and Western Union, when it dominated the telegraph and communications space over a century ago. At that time, Western Union, a private company, refused to carry (or overcharged) for messages from journalists that worked with its competitor, the Associated Press. The company limited certain types of political speech, such as strike-related telegraphs. It was believed to influence elections by misreporting or delaying key transmissions.
In response to these abuses, states, beginning with New York, enacted common carrier laws to limit discrimination in the transmission of telegraph messages. Then, Congress, in the Telegraph Act of 1888, passed a law requiring that telegraph companies "operate their respective telegraph lines as to afford equal facilities to all, without discrimination in favor of or against any person, company, or corporation whatever." There were also laws, similar to HB20 section 2, that set operating policies for telegraph companies, such as requiring them to transmit messages in the order in which they were received.
NetChoice and the giant social media platforms have tried to draw a different analogy. They portray themselves as akin to newspaper editors, choosing which stories to publish, so that their acts of censorship are themselves a form of protected speech.
The telegraph company is clearly the more accurate analogy, however. Both social media sites and the telegraph are carrying millions or billions of user-generated messages, while a traditional newspaper editor has a limited number of pages to fill and carefully chooses each article within that limited newshole. Even an all-digital newspaper limits its articles to the attention span of a hypothetical reader, while the Internet – like the telephone system, telegraph system, or post office – is a pipe for an ocean of messages from one user to another. If a telephone company employee or telegraph company employee intervenes to arbitrarily block the flow, there is less free speech, not more. In addition, the social platforms have spent years arguing that they are notpublishers or speakers, as they seek to avoid liability for the messages they carry.
Ultimately, the key underlying fact of the matter is the level of importance that the giant social media sites play in the state of political speech today. This is the "public square" issue, either in the form of Marsh and Pruneyard case law, or in the form of the common carrier appellation.
Judge Oldham opens his opinion by citing the Supreme Court case of Packingham v. North Carolina which emphatically described the importance of social media to political speech now (just as my past op-eds all cited Packingham for the same reason). The common carrier label hinges on whether a company has become "affected with public interest" in light of its market share and relevant market dynamics. In Packingham, the Supreme Court found that the Internet is the public square of our day, and as Judge Oldham points out it has only grown stronger since then. A political speaker shut out of the giant sites has no equivalent alternative.
The Fifth Circuit opinion is likely to rise to the Supreme Court, and it deserves to win there. If anything, one can argue that HB20 does not go far enough. It appears that all a censored speaker can do under HB20 is to sue in court to be reinstated as a speaker, which will take time. If a story like the Hunter Biden computer story was again unfairly banned in the days before the election, would there be enough time under HB20 for a remedy? And how many speakers have the strength and energy to defend themselves, even if their attorney's fees are ultimately reimbursed? As a matter of free speech, it would seem better to leave a non-violent and non-criminal political post online until the site can go to court and have it removed.
Also, the whole question of social media is not a two-way switch of “on” or “off” ; it is a three-way switch. A site can host a message, so that listeners can seek it out and find it, and followers receive it. It can amplify a message, taking that message and placing it into the news feeds or threads of potentially billions of people who never requested it. It can limit or "de-amplify" that message in whole or in part, so that – for example – the message does not go automatically to a speaker’s followers, or goes only to a slice of them, or is unavailable to all.
The Fifth Circuit’s logic applies well for “hosting” and “censoring/limiting” situations. However, if a site itself chooses to “amplify” a message – say, to take a message and send it to millions or billions of listeners who never asked for it – then, I believe, the site should be considered a publisher of this speech. The site’s right to amplify should be protected by the First Amendment, and the site should be liable for that message that it chooses to amplify (e.g. if it was maliciously defamatory) just like any other publisher.

Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
