
This Tuesday, Nov. 15, 2016 image shows a portion of the home page of the Sierra Club website. Following the election of Donald Trump as president of the United States, the leading environmental organization moved swiftly to feature him in its fundraising appeals. It depicted Trump as an
Election Could Reverse Decades-Long Environmental Trend
Published Nov. 18, 2016 • Read time: 7m
The last in a 10-part series
Only four miles north of the famed environmentalist Rachel Carson’s birthplace in western Pennsylvania, tucked behind a suburban shopping mall and hidden by a low ridge, are six natural gas wells that slowly drain the massive Marcellus Shale formation several thousand feet beneath the ground. The first well, drilled by Range Resources in 2009, was joined by the five others within the next two years and all are now part of more than 10,000 gas-producing wells in Pennsylvania and Ohio.
In the eight years that President Obama has been in office, natural gas production from the Marcellus has increased 16-fold, helping pull the U.S. out of a deep recession and improving its energy future, perhaps for decades. This is a major change, not just in the economic strength of the country but one that’s altering the political direction of areas where the energy revolution is playing out, as last week’s election results demonstrated.
This is because many rural counties in states such as Ohio and Pennsylvania have been transformed since 2009 as the hydraulic fracturing industry began learning the secrets of coercing natural gas out of rock.
The fact that Carson – whose 1962 book, “Silent Spring,” launched the modern environmentalist movement – was born and raised atop the massive Marcellus Shale rock formation carried no historical irony until the rise of fracking, which has caused a rebirth in the U.S. natural gas and oil industry that had been undergoing a slow but steady decline. The resulting economic shift in parts of the U.S. that had not seen energy development in decades could also be shifting political alliances in ways previously unforeseeable. Though Obama’s “all of the above” energy strategy helped fuel these economic benefits, whatever political dividends he might have received were not transferable to the Democrat who campaigned to succeed him.
Indeed, the 2016 election offered a stark policy divide between Hillary Clinton, who was forced to move to the political left on environment, and Donald Trump, perhaps the world’s most significant global warming skeptic/denier.
The likely influence of energy production on the election was spotlighted back in August at the National Press Club in Washington, D.C., by Newt Gingrich, who is now a member of Trump’s transition team.
“There are still states like Ohio, Pennsylvania and Michigan that still think in manufacturing terms,” said the former House speaker during an energy debate with former Democratic National Committee Chairman Howard Dean. “The residual thought in these places is that we should go back to becoming manufacturing centers. If you can sell natural gas in the U.S. for radically less than Japan, you are in a position to rebuild American manufacturing on a scale that is very competitive. I think that gives Trump a psychological advantage.”
In addition to energy production in western Pennsylvania, another hydro-carbon rich formation, the Utica, has boosted local economies in southeastern Ohio and West Virginia, while rural counties in western Wisconsin supply nearly 50 percent of the silica sand that is an integral component of fracking fluid used in hydraulic fracturing.
So while it is difficult to unwind the most salient economic messages that resonated with voters in these rural counties, the influx of energy-related investment and jobs, both direct and indirect, throughout the Midwest is well established. The history of coal mining and coal-generated power plants in many parts of the region were likely also key to voters there, who helped push Trump past the 270 electoral votes needed to win the presidency.
“There is no question that these industries are pumping money into these regions,” said Tyson Slocum, director of the Energy Program at Public Citizen, a consumer rights advocacy group. “You’re faring pretty well if you own land there and mineral rights; if you have a family member employed by the industry, you’re doing fairly well.” However, he added, “there are also costs [from] these industries to residents there. There are also losers in these areas from fracking.”
But the latter weren’t a factor on Election Day. A quick look at the voting data in northeastern and southwestern Pennsylvania -- from the 10 most important counties to natural gas production – shows a median shift of more than 20 percentage points toward Trump compared to the 2012 contest between President Obama and Mitt Romney.
The shift was even more pronounced in western Wisconsin bordering the upper Mississippi River, which in the past five years has seen industrial sand production grow many times over as demand for this fracking component in North Dakota and Texas has skyrocketed. Vote totals for all of the 15 rural Wisconsin counties with the most “frac sand” mining operations moved Republican on Nov. 8, with vote totals in six counties shifting 25 points or more toward Trump compared to Romney’s tally in the 2012 race. In 2012, Obama won eight of the counties; in 2016 Trump won 14 out of 15.
For many political observers, it wasn’t supposed to be this way. Many of these post-industrial communities were longtime Democratic Party bastions, and therefore were not anticipated to shift so dramatically.
“I think environmentalism, in a crucial way, worked against the Democratic Party this year,” said Washington Post columnist Charles Lane, speaking on “Fox News Sunday.” “Of the 25 most coal-dependent states, 20 of them Trump carried. He carried Ohio, Michigan and Wisconsin, which are the three most coal-dependent. The focus on global warming that Obama pushed with a relatively thin legal basis might have contributed a small margin to [Clinton’s] defeat.”
Many environmentalists will dispute Lane’s opinion, instead arguing that Clinton’s inability to connect with voters or the re-introduction of an FBI investigation in the weeks before the election doomed her campaign.
In the shorter term, however, environmentalists have to worry about the potential reversal of a trend toward tighter and more stringent environmental regulation that dates to the 1970s (with a limited interruption during the Reagan years). After all, Trump promised during the campaign to undo Obama’s climate change policies, and this week he appointed EPA foe Myron Ebell to his transition team.
According to comments from Trump’s transition team, many of the environmental community’s most prized policies regarding coal-fired power plant emissions, the Paris Agreement on climate change, and the 2009 EPA endangerment finding concerning greenhouse gases are all possible targets for a new Trump administration. In addition, Trump could use a president’s hitherto untested power to withdraw federal lands from protected status via the Antiquities Act.
Such a turn of events would clearly sadden the environmental community, but opponents will not be taking the Trump presidency lying down.
“Make no mistake – the election of Donald Trump could be devastating for our climate and our future,” said Sierra Club Executive Director Michael Brune. “Donald Trump now has the unflattering distinction of being the only head of state in the entire world to reject the scientific consensus that mankind is driving climate change.”
Since the election, the Sierra Club has used Trump's victory as a fundraising tool, urging visitors to its website to donate and "Fight Back Against Trump Every Day for the Next 4 Years."
Many others environmental organizations, from the Natural Resources Defense Council to Greenpeace and the Environmental Defense Fund, have also announced their strong opposition to Trump’s environmental stance.
“The climate movement is a global one,” said Annie Leonard, executive director of Greenpeace USA. “If we join together, we can make our plans for a just transition to a renewable energy society possible even with a man who actively opposed progress for the human race in the White House.”
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






