
Justice Department Sugar Merger
January 6 and Justice Department Overreach: The Public Rejects Both
COMMENTARY
Published Sept. 30, 2022 • Read time: 6m
The public believes that former President Donald Trump bears significant and perhaps criminal responsibility for what happened at the Capitol on Jan. 6, but also believes that the Justice Department and the FBI are overreaching in their actions against the former president, his aides, and private citizens. The net of all the back and forth so far is that the ratings of Trump seem to have increased and the favorability of the Justice Department and FBI have declined.
Sometimes you have to fight fire with water, not fire. By that I mean when you are up against someone you believe is breaking the rules, strict adherence to the rules in pursuing them is of even greater importance to reestablish the rule of law. That’s not what the public sees happening here.
Take the January 6 Committee – could it have functioned if it had been properly constituted with nearly equal members of both parties and subpoena power for the minority as well as the majority? Of course. It would have been contentious, but all sides would have gotten to present their best arguments, and while Trump would have been held accountable for his actions on Jan. 6, Nancy Pelosi would have also had to explain if and why she rejected additional security. But instead, Pelosi pushed her partisan advantage to the limits. Little surprise then that the committee looks partisan and has no credibility with most Americans, even if the TV networks give it more time than the Super Bowl. In the July Harvard CAPS-Harris Poll run after the committee’s eight televised hearings, 55% of respondents, including 60% of independent voters, thought the committee was conducting its business in an unfair way.
Charge Against Trump Campaign Manager Eclipses Wisconsin Race
Judge Garland and the Left's Disdain for Truth
Military Has Wide Discretion on Bergdahl Charges
Was Sierra Pacific Victim of Government Shakedown?
Let’s look at the actions of the Justice Department. They could have moved in court to enforce the subpoena and asked a judge to demand that Trump turn over his remaining documents. Such a process would be similar to what happened in the fight over the Watergate Tapes or the Clinton historical tapes (that were ruled as personal, not government records). It would have allowed Trump’s lawyers to make their best arguments before a judge and the country. Instead, the Justice Department went to a low-level magistrate judge operating in a one-sided secret process to send dozens of FBI agents to raid the former President’s home. They used their maximum power, given to them to pursue fleeing cartels, against a former president.
The FBI and DOJ’s unprecedented method has split the country. Just over half of voters in the September version of the Harris poll say the Mar-a-Lago raid was a politically motivated use of force rather than the “least invasive” way to retrieve presidential documents. Another half say that the DOJ then exceeded the terms of its warrant by taking too much material from Mar-a-Lago. Americans remain unconvinced that a criminal investigation is even necessary: 52% of voters, including 54% of independents, think the former president’s having documents at home should be handled in non-criminal ways.
Six in 10 think that if the DOJ wanted Trump’s documents, it should have asked a judge and argued for its motion in open court rather than obtaining a warrant through a one-sided, closed proceeding. And 58% of Americans think the appointment of a special master to review the DOJ’s retrieved documents – as a federal judge later ordered – is reasonable.
And the Justice Department didn’t stop with the former president – FBI agents are showing up all over the place seizing people’s phones in front of their families rather than sending out a subpoena that could be contested. Agents went so far as to seize the phone of an ordinary citizen, the “MyPillow Guy”; they better have proof he was connected to violence rather than just exercising his First Amendment rights. They even arrested the former trade representative for the U.S., Peter Navarro, and put him in handcuffs over a congressional subpoena. The public knows that former Attorney General Eric Holder put those congressional subpoenas he received in the wastepaper basket and that Hillary Clinton did the same, even ordering her devices destroyed. As with the January 6 Committee, exactly the voters who need to be convinced of the investigations’ sincerity are the same ones who need to see legal processes scrupulously followed.
Every lawyer for Trump knows that the Justice Department will treat them as though they are mafia lawyers, looking at every turn to secure all their phones, papers, and advice as they already have with almost all of Trump’s attorneys. Of course, this serves to chill any possible representation, undermining another key aspect of our system of justice.
Gone are the days when people, confident of the rightness of their arguments, were willing to run the gauntlets of due process and counterarguments that are at the heart of our legal system and the often-cited rule of law. Instead, every shortcut and technique to squelch the other side is deployed with the idea they are so in the right that the other side should be dispensed without a hearing.
Since the Mar-a-Lago search on Aug. 8, Trump’s popularity has risen in defiance. Trump is now almost even at 46% favorable and 48% unfavorable, with the gap narrowing three points between the July and September Harris polls. Trump’s 2024 prospects are improving too: 59% of GOP voters in the September poll would pick Trump if the Republican presidential primary were held today – up 7 points from July. Even the recent Washington Post-ABC News poll has Trump beating Biden by 2 points while a majority thinks Trump should face possible indictment over Jan. 6.
Meanwhile Biden remains 15 points underwater in the Harris poll. The agencies once seen as unbiased enforcers of the law are losing popularity as well: 53% of Americans view the FBI favorably, and just 48% view the DOJ favorably. Because of their actions, done just on the eve of an election, the DOJ and FBI must, if they care, fight uphill to correct the perception that they are overreaching on Trump for partisan political purposes. Trump’s action on Jan. 6 and the overreach in response? The public rejects them both.

Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
