
Election 2024 Trump Ye
Grappling With the Groyper Problem: Insight From Columbia University
COMMENTARY
Published Dec. 7, 2025 • Read time: 9m
Last month, Tucker Carlson interviewed the openly racist, misogynistic, and antisemitic streamer Nick Fuentes – the leader of a cult-like and growing online community devoted to him and his ultra-right-wing beliefs, known as the Groypers.
The weeks succeeding Carlson’s interview with Fuentes have caused an absolute maelstrom on the right. The president of the Heritage Foundation, Kevin Roberts, initially defended the exchange. But following intense pressure from within the conservative establishment and various resignation letters from within Heritage, he ultimately revised his original stance.
But those condemning Carlson and his interview of Fuentes do not address the problem. The crisis of Groyperism, omnipresent in my generation – Gen Z – is one that we now need to seriously grapple with. A search for Fuentes-following students on my own campus, Columbia University, offered insight.
“In America, we’re not allowed to express our traditional values without being called a Nazi or racist. Nick Fuentes is giving people who have traditional values someone to look [up to].” “He does edgy stuff just to be edgy, just to be fun,” and not necessarily because he’s a bigot. And Israel clearly “has too much influence over the United States,” said a self-described libertarian undergraduate.
“The radical cancel culture of the left and the flinching orthodoxy of the right has produced the need for an outspoken anti-establishment, new media figure like Nick Fuentes,” a devoutly religious Christian student articulated. “Some of his views are so vehemently wrong,” she continued, but “in order for a transformation to occur, you need dialectic. And right now, Fuentes is the antithesis, and we’re going to produce something closer to the truth coming out of this period.” She added that Zionism is uniquely violent and destructive amongst nationalisms, and that “if America is to be a ‘national’ state … then obviously, that entails that other ‘national’ countries are bad.”
These are only two students whose views fall beyond mainstream conservatism, what we might lump together as the alt-right. None of them identify as Groypers – in that they do not consider themselves the cult followers of Fuentes – but are all adjacent to this movement in more ways than one, all of them finding Fuentes appealing in some form. It is easy to imagine them being among the people Rod Dreher described – perhaps somewhat liberally, as UnHerd’s Emily Jashinsky noted – as the 30% to 40% of Republican D.C. staffers who are Groypers.
Yet these kids are not disenfranchised, certainly not in the traditional sense: They are students at one of the nation’s elite universities, far from dwelling in their mother’s basement (as Ben Shapiro, increasingly irrelevant, would like to characterize anyone who listens to Fuentes). These Columbia students are involved in conservative organizing, politics, and campus debates. (Though it is worth mentioning that there has also been some significant pushback from more center-right figures on campus, some of whom have expressed to me their fear that people they perceive as Groypers are “infiltrating.”)
Nonetheless, this has been a seismic shift. When I arrived at Columbia last year, it was immediately clear to me not only that campus conservatives were incredibly tame – in the image of the East Coast epitomical “country club Republican” – but that many even vehemently and explicitly rejected President Trump and MAGA.
The crucial thing to understand, then, is that the Groyper problem is not exclusive to Groypers. Amongst Gen Zers (and not only right-wingers), there is also a reflexive desire to simply blame Israel for any and all of America’s faults. Banter takes the form of sharing Nick Fuentes’ most provocative comments in our Instagram DMs. McDonald’s and cable TV are branded as “goyslop” – minimum wage employees as “goycattle.” Anti-establishment thought lands too frequently not on class consciousness, but on blaming “the Jews,” as if they were a cohesive group sharing a single mind and agenda. What is so troublesome is when I hear acquaintances, many who wouldn’t ever identify as Groypers, perpetuating some of this rhetoric unironically. It happens often.
My hunch is that you could get AIPAC to register under the Foreign Agents Registration Act, eliminate foreign aid to Israel, halt the forever wars, remove corporate money from politics, and substantively improve life for young Americans. We are still far from much of this happening, but address these populist concerns, and you would likely “solve the problem” with those who are Groyper-adjacent – drawn to Fuentes solely because of grievances related to Israel, affordability, and American decline. Fuentes’ cult-like followers, however, are much harder to get to. They have been radicalized. De-radicalization is no small feat.
Days before Charlie Kirk’s tragic assassination, Fuentes said on his livestream: “My ideas are already there, I’ve already impregnated your organization. I took Turning Point USA, and I f**cked it … And that’s why it’s filled with Groypers. That’s why your whole crew, that’s why the people around you, that’s why your chapter presidents, that’s why your attendees – they’re all Groypers.” After Kirk’s death, Vice President JD Vance spoke in his place at a TPUSA event at Ole Miss on Oct. 29. Fuentes celebrated how there, Vance was asked by attendees whether Trump was controlled by Israel, and why the vice president was married to a Hindu. “The Groypers have taken over,” Fuentes declared. “We run this.”
Normal, non-bigoted individuals don’t see why a Catholic being married to a Hindu is a problem. Fuentes, however, considers Vance a “fat race-mixer who’s married to a jeet” because of it.
So, now would be the right time to ask: How did we get here? The reflexive desire amongst establishmentarian conservatives and liberals alike is to blame Carlson. In this reading, perhaps best summarized in Ezra Klein’s interview with John Ganz, “You have the antisemitism of the gutter, Fuentes, and you have the antisemitism of a declining aristocracy … Tucker comes from this kind of preppy background.” According to this predominant view, Carlson has spent years pushing the Overton window of conservatism further and further to the right. By conversing with Fuentes, he was thus legitimizing him and implicitly endorsing him.
This ignores a few relevant facts. First, since his departure from Fox News, Carlson has become less strictly right-wing. He has now hosted, on more than one occasion, ardent leftists such as the economist Jeffrey Sachs, “The Young Turks” co-host Ana Kasparian, and independent journalist Glenn Greenwald. This transition is far better described as populist than it is far-right. None of this is to whitewash the fact that Carlson does entertain the conspiratorial likes of Alex Jones and Candace Owens, gives a platform to the revisionist historian Darryl Cooper, and flirts with wacky conspiracy theories himself on a regular basis. This is no defense of Carlson. But it is important to understand the ways he is significantly different from Fuentes, and even other conservatives who appear to have real hate for specific ethnic groups in their heart.
Second, in their conversation, Carlson explicitly rebuked Fuentes and his obsession with race. He told Fuentes, “It’s the defense of universal values that will hold the country together and the emphasis on parochial group values that will break it apart.” In the tone of a concerned father, he emphasized to Fuentes that if he was a good-faith actor and his enemy was truly the neocons and their disastrous foreign policy, ranting about “the Jews” does not help. And he expressed bewilderment at Fuentes’ assertion that he was a “fan” of Stalin, the Soviet premier who killed millions.
More than anything else, Carlson appeared to want to understand Fuentes, a necessary task at this time. That does not mean that he conducted the interview perfectly. As he later admitted to Megyn Kelly, he could have done more to hold Fuentes to account for his utterly derogatory remarks about Vance’s wife. And Carlson told Shawn Ryan that, in hindsight, he should have pushed for Fuentes to actually explain his admiration for Stalin rather than letting him get away with it as a cheeky comment.
Coleman Hughes convincingly argued on the pages of The Free Press this Monday that Fuentes is clever enough to present two different versions of himself. More moderate and Catholic “Podcast Nick” on shows like Carlson’s; vile “Rumble Nick” for his devotees. He has also been moderating to an extent, even on Rumble. But Nick Fuentes is still Nick Fuentes, and Carlson’s fundamentally universalist worldview seems wholly incompatible with the streamer’s ideological antisemitism and racism.
I do not have all the answers as to how we may begin to de-radicalize the Groypers and to combat racial and antisemitic animus in Gen Z and the right broadly. But I do know that a rejection of universalism, such as that of the leader of National Conservatism, Yoram Hazony (something that New York Times conservative writer Ross Douthat cleverly interrogated him on), can only lead to this ugliness. It is the very same universalism we see Fuentes rejecting in blaming “the Jews,” and that which his followers – whether fully Groyper or Groyper-adjacent – also tend to reject.
This is a wholly different breed of thought from simply rejecting mass migration, advocating for a muscular nationalism, and the like. For Fuentes, the two do go hand in hand. For Carlson, fundamentally, only the latter appears to be true. That is a good thing, and I hope Carlson does not stray away from that.
In this regard, Carlson, with his universalist, populist nationalism, is in many ways the single best answer to Fuentes – particularly for chronically online Gen Z, many of whom listen to both avidly. To quote the former Fox News pundit: “You can tell exactly where this is going. It’s going toward violence. Tribal warfare. That’s the last thing you want. That’s why this is a great country. That’s why it’s exceptional … We have self-consciously and out loud said, ‘these are universal principles that apply to every human being because every human being was created by God, in God’s image.’”
Support Our Mission
The Internet provides an endless stream of content. Not all of it is worth your time. That's why, every day, RealClearPolitics curates the most essential news and information—from all sides and across mediums. The links, videos, and podcasts curated here are the product of human judgment, not algorithms or AI. Please help power our mission of presenting a thoughtful, balanced public discourse through a tax-deductible donation.
Would you consider supporting us today?
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






