
Election 2026 Michigan Senate
In Michigan, Bitter Final Debate Over Trust and Trump
Published Oct. 22, 2026 • Read time: 7m
Less than two weeks before Election Day, Michigan’s two Senate candidates met for the last time in a Southfield television studio just outside Detroit. It’s a race that could decide which party controls the U.S. Senate, and the contest between Democrat Abdul El-Sayed and Republican Mike Rogers has become one of the most personal of the year.
On Wednesday night it came down to two questions: whether El-Sayed, a Michigan-born Muslim, can be trusted, and whether Rogers can keep Donald Trump’s voters while stepping carefully out of the president’s shadow.
For El-Sayed, the first question cuts deep. At the debate’s hottest moment, the child of Egyptian immigrants turned from the moderators to face Rogers directly.
“I am proud of America. I’m proud to be an American,” he said, adding that the Constitution guarantees everyone the right to pray as they choose.
His opponent, former Rep. Mike Rogers, has spent the closing weeks of the race making the opposite case: that El-Sayed has based his campaign on deception about his true nature. Rogers has charged that El-Sayed won’t condemn the Muslim Brotherhood, and that his campaign takes money from people and groups that support the jihadist organization and openly back terrorist organizations including Hamas, Hezbollah, and al-Qaeda.
El-Sayed, who would be the first Muslim member of the U.S. Senate if he wins, denies any ties to the Brotherhood and has condemned Hamas. On Wednesday he told Rogers the attacks were “really quite beneath you, Mike.”
A fight over loyalty
Michigan’s race for the open seat of retiring Democratic Sen. Gary Peters is one of the eight swing state races currently polling within the margin of error. In the RealClearPolitics Poll Average, Rogers trails El-Sayed by 2 percentage points. Republicans have not won a Senate race in the state since 1994, and the campaign is expected to draw some $300 million in spending before it’s over.
Wednesday’s second and final debate, at WXYZ-TV’s studios in suburban Southfield, was tamer than the pair’s Oct. 8 faceoff in Grand Rapids. That session was so combative the two kept arguing through the commercial breaks. But the rematch still turned on the same theme: whether El-Sayed, a Michigan-born Muslim and former Detroit health director, can be trusted.
Rogers, a former FBI agent turned congressman who once chaired the House Intelligence Committee, again tried to tie his opponent to the Muslim Brotherhood. Answering a question on police funding, he cited a 2012 letter, first reported by The Washington Free Beacon, that El-Sayed allegedly signed urging Egypt’s then-president Mohamed Morsi, who was backed by the Muslim Brotherhood, to “purge” Egyptian police and media of those who had been loyal to previous president Hosni Mubarak. Rogers also accused El-Sayed of misleading voters about his medical credentials, calling it a pattern of deception.
El-Sayed has repeatedly denied any personal or family ties to the Muslim Brotherhood. Fact-checkers at Bridge Michigan found no evidence for an earlier Rogers claim that El-Sayed had pledged support to it. In the first debate, Rogers raised El-Sayed’s mother’s past work at a charity the U.S. federal government later shut down as a terrorism supporter; she was never accused of wrongdoing.
On Wednesday, El-Sayed said the attack questioned his loyalty to the Constitution, which he noted he had served under, calling it shameful. Rogers didn’t retreat. El-Sayed could worship however he wished, he said, and that casting himself as a victim was a diversion. The real issue, Rogers argued, was whether El-Sayed was sympathetic to the ideology of the Muslim Brotherhood, which is banned in several countries.
The party machinery quickly took sides. Michigan GOP Chairman Jim Runestad said afterward that Rogers demonstrated that he has the steady hand voters want, while state Democratic Party chairman Curtis Hertel told reporters that Rogers would fight only for President Trump and his donors.
The third candidate on stage
Rogers’ broader task is to win a Democratic-run state while bearing the burden of Trump’s weak job approval ratings. He opened the debate by conceding that Michiganders were hurting, citing lost jobs and the Midwest’s highest utility bills.
On the issue of trade, he split the difference with the administration. Some Trump tariffs, he argued, were bringing jobs home from Mexico and China. But on the trade war with Canada, a sore point for a border state whose auto industry runs on cross-border supply chains, Rogers was reduced to pitching himself as the senator who could get Trump’s ear, presumably to try to talk him out of moves that hurt the state.
“You might want to send the guy back who can actually get the meeting,” Rogers argued.
El-Sayed scoffed at the premise. A candidate elected with Trump’s help, he said, was unlikely to turn around and defy him, given how few Republican senators have successfully done so. The Democratic candidate blamed rising gas and grocery prices on the U.S. war with Iran, said Rogers stood shoulder-to-shoulder with Trump on it, and called for a war powers resolution. Rogers recently ran an ad urging the war to wind down, while maintaining Trump had good reason to target Iran’s nuclear program.
All night, El-Sayed invited viewers to play “MAGA bingo,” marking squares whenever Rogers echoed a Trump talking point. Rogers countered that the better game would be counting how often El-Sayed worked the president’s name into an answer.
Other exchanges showed how far apart the two men remain. On public safety, Rogers revived El-Sayed’s past support for defunding the police, saying the Democrat had been passionate about the cause. El-Sayed countered that police need to be funded when it comes to “retirement, retention, recruitment,” as he tried to put the issue to rest.
Rogers also accused El-Sayed of wanting to raise taxes. In their first debate, he argued that El-Sayed’s support for single-payer health care would cost Michigan families tens of thousands of dollars. El-Sayed kept steering back to the costs he says Rogers ignores: gasoline, groceries, and access to medical services.
The sharpest differences came during a discussion of voter identification requirements and the SAVE Act, the Republican-backed bill requiring proof of citizenship to register. El-Sayed cited a hot-mic remark he attributed to Rogers about wanting retired police officers who could intimidate voters in Detroit, saying he could hardly believe it when he heard it.
The candidates also sparred over Social Security, education, and whether Rogers would campaign alongside Trump in Michigan. El-Sayed argued Rogers was counting on the president to carry him across the finish line. Rogers insisted the race was about Michigan’s future, not Trump.
Sprint to the finish line
Moderators kept a tight clock, moving through health care, immigration, crime, Social Security, voter ID, education, and tariffs, and finishing a couple of minutes early.
Some of the clearest contrasts came on artificial intelligence. Rogers backed a narrow antitrust exemption letting frontier AI companies coordinate on safety, and signaled openness to a so-called human-controlled “kill switch” for systems that turn dangerous. El-Sayed called for pausing frontier research, putting democratically appointed members on AI company boards and drawing bright lines: no AI deciding to fire workers, fire weapons, or deny health coverage.
In rapid-fire questions at the close, El-Sayed said he would support expanding the Supreme Court if done fairly, a concept he did not attempt to define.
Rogers appears to be betting he can hold Trump’s base while convincing swing voters he will push back when it counts. El-Sayed is betting they won’t believe him, and that his pitch on costs, health care, and the Iran war will help him hold onto a Senate seat that Republicans haven’t held for a quarter century.
Voters deliver their verdict Nov. 3.
Support Our Mission
The Internet provides an endless stream of content. Not all of it is worth your time. That's why, every day, RealClearPolitics curates the most essential news and information—from all sides and across mediums. The links, videos, and podcasts curated here are the product of human judgment, not algorithms or AI. Please help power our mission of presenting a thoughtful, balanced public discourse through a tax-deductible donation.
Would you consider supporting us today?
Contributing to RealClear Politics through the RealClear Media Foundation supports essential initiatives that drive meaningful change.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






