Jeb Bush's Life Story: Can It Connect With Voters?
Published March 28, 2015 • Read time: 5m
One of the wisest and funniest men I’ve ever known, Vic Gold, shrewdly observed in 1988 that Dan Quayle was all wrong as a running mate for George Bush because the Indiana senator had no real life story to tell—that he’d never fully grown up. The same could not be said of the veteran Republicans passed over by Bush, mostly notably Jack Kemp and Bob Dole.
Longtime Bush aide James A. Baker was asked by a snarky reporter if Bush had taken Quayle because he could not pick one of his own sons. Baker, grinning, merely shrugged his shoulders. Baker had been against Quayle all along, but had lost this round to advisers who convinced the vice president that Quayle represented some kind of generational Holy Grail.
That calculation did not pan out, but Bush won anyway—in spite of Dan Quayle, not because of him. Vic Gold did not intend for his judgment of the callow Quayle to sound cruel. He just believed that little in Quayle’s life’s experiences would resonate with other Americans. For one thing, his story lacked the hardships, sadness, and even tragedies that most people know.
Quayle, as of 1988, still had both parents, grew up rich, and had never seen war or poverty or disease. He’d never lost a business or a child. He’d never gone through that experience which instantaneously changed him from boy to man.
Ronald Reagan had the Great Depression and his own father’s alcoholism; Carter was tested in the Naval Academy, his military service, life on a farm. John F. Kennedy had serious health issues, and near-death combat exploits in the Pacific, as did Jeb’s father, a daring bomber pilot in the Navy who, when he returned, set out for fame and fortune in the wildcat oil fields of West Texas. John McCain was another naval aviator and POW—a real American hero. Bill Clinton’s story of a broken home and a struggling but loving mother touched millions.
Cruz's Path to Nomination
Trump Stands by His Manager
With Tweets on Heidi Cruz, Trump Sinks to New Depths
A Vote for Kasich Is a Vote for Trump
As of Dan Quayle, much the same can be said of Jeb Bush. At 62, this lucky man still has both his parents. He’s never served in the military, lost a business, lost a child. There was a tragedy in his family, but he was a baby when it happened: In October 1953 his older sister died but he was only six months old. Significantly, his older brother, George W. Bush, remembers his parents’ grief well and he too was deeply affected.
Many of Jeb Bush’s Republican rivals, including Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker, grew up poor. Ted Cruz just told Americans his story of poverty and his father finding a faith that saved their family. Rand Paul does ophthalmological charity work in the Third World and Bobby Jindal’s is a story of struggle and success overcoming prejudice.
Suffering is not only good for the soul and for Southern writers (including yours truly) it also turns out to be good for presidential candidates.
Political consultants like a candidate who has a story to tell because it makes it easier to write the feel-good bio ads that help them connect candidates with voters—and vice versa.. But I’m talking about something else. Jeb Bush seems like a good man with natural empathy for other people. But that’s not always enough. John Kerry was a decorated veteran of the Vietnam War, but he never demonstrated the compassion necessary to win. Still, it’s better to have suffered adversity and overcome it than never to have faced it at all.
Generally, these challenges aren’t as dramatic as the searing decision by McCain—the son of a ranking U.S. Navy admiral—to remain in his Hanoi hellhole rather than give the North Vietnamese a propaganda victory by accepting an early release. The problems faced by candidates can be as mundane as Mike Huckabee’s struggle with his weight or as deeply personal as Sarah Palin and Rick Santorum balancing the demands of the campaign trail with those of a special-needs child.
One point of these examples is that almost all people face some tribulations is life, even if these demons are kept private. So we can’t presume Jeb Bush’s life is as charmed as it seems from the outside. But as the 2016 campaign season arrives, it’s certainly fair to ask whether Bush has enough real-life experience to truly understand what everyday Americans want and need. Does his easy path through life give him the maturity and depth necessary to do the job wisely? The question was also relevant to Mitt Romney, who also led an insular existence and also missed out on military service, though both he and Jeb were of Vietnam-era draft age.
Franklin Roosevelt had a charmed life, too—for a while. He hid the effects of polio from the public, just as he glossed over the strains in his marriage. But these trials helped him connect with his countrymen.
The American presidency has never been only about the American president. It is about the American people and what the individual who occupies the Oval Office is going to do for the citizenry—even if that is only to appeal to the better angels of their nature, as Lincoln did. Or simply to get government off their backs, which was Reagan’s mission.
Most of us can point to that pivotal moment when they grew up. For me, it was the phone call while in college, informing me that my father had died. With others, it was war or divorce or an unwelcome midnight call or knock on the door with heart-stopping news. But whatever the seminal event, it changed their character and made them sturdier individuals.

Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
The Primary System Is Losing the Next Generation
Sean Trende • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
