
Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump rallies supporters at the Cambria County War Memorial Arena in Johnstown, Pa. Friday, Oct. 21, 2016. (Thomas Slusser /The Tribune-Democrat via AP)
What Dems and the GOP Learned in Pennsylvania
Published Dec. 2, 2016 • Read time: 5m
Join the Conversation
0The conventional wisdom to win Pennsylvania in a presidential election went like this: carry the four “collar” counties surrounding Philadelphia, run up the score among your base—and for the Democrats that means in the cities, particularly Philly—while adding a few key counties where your message resonates. Do all that and the state’s 20 electoral votes are yours.
Donald Trump’s formula was much simpler. His victory showcased the new trend coming out of Election 2016: how rural voters asserted themselves in opposition to urban voters.
“It was small-town rural America vs. urban America,” G. Terry Madonna, director of the Center for Politics and Public Affairs at Franklin & Marshall College, told RealClearPolitics. “It’s pretty much a consensus here that what we ended up with was a neglected white working-class base. It’s a question in all these states [of whether] we appreciated the degree of angst and concern that these voters had, that in a change environment favored Trump. And they were willing to look past his foibles.”
It was a pattern that played out across the Rust Belt, notably in Michigan and Wisconsin, turning blue states red and handing the New York business mogul the White House.
How to respond to this unexpectedly potent voting bloc is the challenge facing the Democratic Party as it attempts to regroup. Barack Obama won the White House without these voters, and he did it twice. Their rise this year took the party by surprise and became a factor in the attempt – albeit one that failed -- to oust Nancy Pelosi as leader of House Democrats.
Lies, Assault and Cover-ups Don't Stop Donald Trump
Trump Stands by His Man; Obama on a Health Scourge; Hayden Interview; Reagan's Courage
Analysis: For Trump, Few Limits to Win-At-Any-Cost Approach
What If Clinton Isn't Indicted?
Experts attribute the rise of the rural voter to many factors, most of them having to do with a disenchantment with the way the country is being run: the feeling that they’re not getting their share of power and resources and that urban dwellers don’t understand the challenges they face.
Mike McCabe, founder and president of the working-class advocacy group Blue Jean Nation, described the results in Wisconsin as a basic reaction to what people are feeling. "If people from communities like that make a trip to Madison to go to a [University of Wisconsin] Badger game or they go to Milwaukee to take in a Brewers game, they see all these new traffic circles and cloverleafs and these massive highway expansions, and they can't fill their own potholes," he said in an interview on Wisconsin public radio.
In Wisconsin, which Trump won by less than one percentage point, 22 counties switched from Obama in 2012 to Trump; of those, 18 were rural. In Michigan, another state Trump won by less than a percentage point, the president-elect took 12 of the counties Obama won in 2012, including Macomb, a large, mostly white area outside of Detroit, which had been an important Democratic stronghold in recent elections.
The dynamic was tighter in Pennsylvania, where Obama won 12 counties in 2012 and Clinton won 11 this year. But on Election Day, Trump won the state by fewer than 75,000 votes. And it was rural voters who put him over the top.
Trump campaign officials who worked in the Keystone State said that was always the plan, to focus on rural areas instead of the traditional campaign strategy of courting the four counties surrounding Philadelphia. Their approach to the state: Look at it like the shape of an L – with Pittsburgh at the left bottom of the letter and then extending eastward to Philadelphia; that was the area Trump concentrated on, along with the northeastern quadrant.
The strategy paid off. Clinton carried the four Philadelphia collar counties -- Bucks, Chester, Montgomery, and Delaware -- along with the city itself, where she ran up a huge margin. In those places, she slightly outperformed Obama (who lost Chester County in 2012). She also won Pittsburgh, she won Harrisburg, she won Scranton, which should have given her the state.
Instead she lost. Trump beat her by winning all the counties Mitt Romney won four years earlier – but doing so much more decisively. In six of those counties, he outperformed Romney by double digits. Trump also did better than Romney in some key Democratic strongholds. In Lackawanna County, which houses Scranton, Obama won by more than 30,000 votes in 2012 while Clinton won it by a mere 3,000 votes this year.
Overall, Clinton did well in the state, gaining about 60,000 more votes than Obama. But Trump got almost 300,000 more votes than Romney did.
“Secretary Clinton did not underperform. Her campaign performed well. Donald Trump performed better,” David Urban, who ran Trump’s Pennsylvania campaign, told RCP. Clinton and her many surrogates who swarmed the state – including Obama, Michelle Obama, Vice President Biden, Bill Clinton and Chelsea Clinton – focused on the urban areas and Philadelphia suburbs, which she won.
But it just wasn’t enough.
“In the end, I think it was her neglect of the economic issues and paying attention to the white working class that made the biggest difference in the outcome,” Madonna said. Ironically, that’s a stark contrast to her 2008 primary campaign against Obama. Her victory in Pennsylvania during that rivalry gave new life to her campaign and dragged out the race for the Democratic nomination. In that contest, the supporters who put Clinton over the top were white high-school-educated voters. David Urban noted the conventional wisdom of winning the Keystone State has now been flipped on its head.
The old thinking was that “all you have to do is win those five, six, seven counties and you’d win Pennsylvania. You didn’t have to worry about the rest of the state. Well, this election proved that’s wrong. You do need to worry about the rest of the state,” he said. “President-elect Trump redefined how you’ll run elections in Pennsylvania.”
Does this mean the Rust Belt states are lost to Democrats in future elections?
“That’s obviously the challenge to the party, in not just Pennsylvania, but all the blue states that flipped red,” Urban said.

Jon Finer’s Old and Dangerous ‘New Approach’ to Israel
Peter Berkowitz • RealClearPolitics
The President Deserves Better
John Ullyot • RealClearPolitics
Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
