
Election 2024 Republicans Iowa
Trump Challengers Meet in Iowa for Thanksgiving Dinner Forum
Published Nov. 18, 2023 • Read time: 8m
DES MOINES, IOWA — The field is shrinking and the stakes are rising, but there were no knives out as three GOP presidential candidates defied the Republican National Committee to attend a Thanksgiving forum with Christian conservatives here Friday.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, former South Carolina governor and U.N. ambassador Nikki Haley, and 38-year-old entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy appeared on stage with Bob Vander Plaats, head of a conservative Christian group called The Family Leader, to discuss issues important to the state’s highly influential evangelical voters — some 800 of whom were in attendance.
The “Bob Vander Plaats primary,” as it is known here, was conducted not behind podiums, but instead around a table — a distinction of apparent importance to RNC officials trying to control the primary season debate schedule. Both the format and the moderator’s demeanor fostered a more cordial exchange between the candidates than has been evidenced in the first three debates.
Still, like any dysfunctional family’s Thanksgiving get-together, there was drama leading up to Friday night’s forum. For a while, it seemed unlikely to come off at all. Earlier this week, the forum was thrust into a standoff with party leaders in Washington, following a report by RealClearPolitics that the RNC would classify the event as an unsanctioned debate and punish the participants.
Haley, DeSantis, and Ramaswamy called the RNC’s bluff. With the closest challengers (Haley and DeSantis) trailing former President Donald Trump by 30 percentage points in the latest Iowa polls — and by even greater margins nationally — these candidates apparently figured the Vander Plaats primary was more important to them than the imprimatur of party chieftains. Trump himself was a no-show, as he has been in all three GOP primary debates thus far.
Lies, Assault and Cover-ups Don't Stop Donald Trump
Trump Stands by His Man; Obama on a Health Scourge; Hayden Interview; Reagan's Courage
Analysis: For Trump, Few Limits to Win-At-Any-Cost Approach
What If Clinton Isn't Indicted?
Vander Plaats himself took note of Trump’s absence in a matter-of-fact comment that neither condemned the former president nor excused his nonattendance. “You guys know that goes with Thanksgiving, right? And sometimes some guests don’t show up.”
Aside from a few jabs at the frontrunner, the three candidates were on their best behavior. This didn’t happen by accident. Vander Plaats informed the audience that the candidates had been instructed to keep things civil, and specifically asked not to attack each other. “We took all the sharp objects off the table,” he quipped, adding that the candidates were encouraged to say nice things about one another, provided the compliments were “genuine.”
The most poignant moments of the session came when both DeSantis and Ramaswamy discussed their wives’ miscarriages. It’s something neither had done publicly before. Ramaswamy said his wife Apoorva was three months pregnant when she miscarried.
“We lost our first child and that was the loss of a life,” he said. “It was our family’s loss and you know, Apoorva, she was probably one of the most upbeat, strong, positive people you will meet. She went into a state of depression after that, and our faith is what got us through it, actually. Our faith teaches us that, you know, our child joined his Creator, and one day, we will, too.”
As the audience listened raptly, Ramaswamy said the couple also experienced a scare during her second pregnancy, but that this child survived. Karthik Ramaswamy, now 4 years old, joined his father on stage, sitting in his father's lap as he concluded the story. "When you bring life into this world, you protect all life, born and unborn. And that's where our commitment comes from."
DeSantis also discussed the difficulties he and his wife Casey DeSantis faced after her miscarriage. “We wanted to have a family, and it didn't happen at first,” DeSantis said. “We just kept praying. We knew that there would be a path that God would lead us on, and lo and behold, in a short time, we did it, and we had our first baby girl.”
An hour into the forum, Vander Plaats announced that he would challenge the candidates with their “biggest hurdle” — one he’d identified through conversations with Iowa voters. Those hurdles may not be the same height, at least in Vander Plaats' mind. Put another way, if one listened closely to the questions, the host might have seemed to have been playing favorites.
In a first on the 2024 campaign trail, Ramaswamy was asked, point blank, to square his Hindu upbringing with the desires of Christian conservatives in Iowa. The first-time candidate responded by drawing numerous comparisons between the values of Hinduism and Christianity, but not before acknowledging that the question was “a bit of an elephant in the room."
“Can I be a president who promotes Christianity across this county?” he said. “I can’t, for a number of reasons. I’m not Christian. But I don’t think that’s what we should want the U.S. president exactly doing, either. That’s a job for pastors and others.”
“But will I stand for those shared values?” he continued. “Will I promote them in the example we set, and revive them in the next generation of Americans? You’re darn right I will.”
When it was her turn in the barrel, Haley was pressed on her commitment to compromise with Democrats on abortion. A stance popular with moderates, but highly problematic among the staunch pro-lifers who will be well-represented in Iowa’s Jan. 15 caucuses, this issue had become a defining characteristic of her campaign. Haley defended her record as a “pro-life” governor in South Carolina, but reiterated that the goal of Republicans should be “to save as many babies as we can,” adding that they may have to compromise to do it.
“I am unapologetically pro-life,” Haley said, as she has in the previous candidate forums in explaining that a national abortion ban isn’t feasible for the simple reason that it won’t pass Congress.
“If you're going to pass a federal law, you have to have a majority of the House, you have to have 60 Senate votes, you have to have the signature of a president,” Haley explained. “And we haven’t had 60 Republicans in over a hundred years.”
Pressed by Vander Plaats on whether she would have signed a six-week ban as governor of South Carolina — as DeSantis did in Florida — Haley said that she would.
Perhaps tipping his hand like the father at Thanksgiving dinner who calls on a favored child to recite his latest exploits in school, Vander Plaats’ question to DeSantis about his “hurdle” was one the Florida governor has been answering cheerfully since the day he announced in February: With Donald Trump in the running, why doesn’t DeSantis “just wait his turn”?
The practiced answer was a slam dunk, delivered to loud applause.
“We’re a republic, it’s not about waiting your turn,” DeSantis told the crowd. “You have a right as a citizen to put your name out there and to fight for the country that you believe in.”
DeSantis then embarked on a critique of the former president, as well as of President Biden, on issues ranging from policy failures to basic competence. DeSantis also questioned Trump’s electability and said that not being able to succeed himself would instantly make Trump an ineffectual lame duck.
“As a lame duck with poor personnel, and the distractions, it’s going to be hard for him to get this done,” DeSantis said. “My candidacy is lower risk, because we’ll run Biden ragged around this country, but high reward because you get a two-term conservative president who’s going to stand for your values and deliver for you for eight full years.”
Afterward, away from the “Thanksgiving table,” conspiracy theories were whispered. As DeSantis fans gathered outside a nearby hotel restaurant for his post-forum reception, some attendees found it hard to square the number of supporters in line with his standing in the polls. Does this mean the forum was deliberately packed with DeSantis voters? Or that the polls are not to be believed? Several supporters of the Florida governor who spoke to RCP suggested the latter.
“The polls absolutely can be skewed,” Matthew Haynie, a business owner from Des Moines, told RCP. “I’m not an expert, but you can’t hide what you see. I’ve yet to meet a rural person who has been polled.”
Haynie believes DeSantis has far greater reach there than current polls estimate. “I’m seeing extremely strong pro-Trump farmers and country folk taking off their MAGA hats and trading them in for DeSantis merch,” he added.
Dave Howe, a 70-year-old farmer from outside Des Moines, doesn’t fit the profile of “strongly pro-Trump.” But as a strongly undecided voter, he was impressed with DeSantis’ showing at the forum and shared the same misgivings about current polling.
“I mean, we all remember, right?” he said. “Hillary had all the polls, too.”

Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
The Primary System Is Losing the Next Generation
Sean Trende • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
