Why the Wisconsin Recall Sets a Bad Precedent
Published June 1, 2012 • Read time: 4m
Next Tuesday, voters in Wisconsin decide whether to recall their governor -- Republican Scott Walker. A successful recall petition earlier this year gives them a choice between the incumbent and Democrat Tom Barrett, a former congressman, Wisconsin state legislator, and the current mayor of Milwaukee. Walker is, of course, best known for pushing through a package of public sector reforms eliminating various collective bargaining rules in Wisconsin. In the process he bitterly divided his state and poisoned the well for a vital national conversation about public sector reform by viscerally pitting public sector workers against other citizens. Barrett seems, as evidenced by his political career, likely to be a better and more moderate governor. Despite that, count me among those who disapprove of Walker but who also don’t think he should be recalled.
Most of the commentary about the recall (aside from the abundance of passionate feelings about Walker himself) focuses on its political wisdom. Was it a good decision by organized labor and Democrats to pursue it? What will it mean for the presidential race in the swing state of Wisconsin? Politically pertinent questions, sure, but the bigger picture matters more. In the long run what should concern us is the governmental wisdom of this kind of recall. Are recalls based on policy choices even a good idea? Barring corruption or incapacity to govern, shouldn’t elections at least settle who holds an office for a fixed period of time? In our already poisonous politics, are recalls poised to become one more weapon in our ongoing total political war?
Recall provisions for elected officials have been on the books for more than a century. Los Angeles enacted the first one in 1903 and the first states adopted them in 1908 (Wisconsin’s was put in place in 1926). Today, provisions allowing for recalls are neither ubiquitous nor rare -- but they are being used more often. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, 19 states allow for the recall of state officials and in most (including Wisconsin) specific grounds are not required. At least 29 states allow for the recall of local officials. They remain unusual for governors -- Scott Walker would become only the third to be recalled from office if his opponents are successful next week. But recalls are being employed more frequently for state legislators. There have been more recall elections for these officials since 1990 than there were between 1908 and 1989. At the local level they’re happening for all manner of reasons. An article last year in Governing magazine noted recall efforts against mayors for issues as trivial as the design of parking spaces and layoffs of lifeguards.
If the Walker recall succeeds, it will energize efforts elsewhere -- and create an incentive for a partisan tit for tat response. That’s no small problem given how dysfunctional our politics already are. At the state level, recalls require organization and money. So although they were initially enacted by progressive reformers, today recalls are more a tool for special interest groups that can muster the resources to pull one off. And although the Wisconsin election is focusing attention on unions, in practice other interest groups can play this game as well. If you think our politicians are paralyzed by special interests and lack courage to take on the big problems facing the country now, imagine their timidity when they start paying attention to the threat of real-time responses to any controversial actions they take.
Nor are recalls a panacea. In a fit of pique, California voters recalled Gov. Gray Davis in 2003. They got Arnold Schwarzenegger, who at this point seems as likely to be remembered for the drama of his personal life as for putting a dent in California’s many problems. At the local level, recall campaigns can start as soon as the election (or the last recall) ends, consuming time, money and, most importantly, the attention of those who are supposed to be governing.
Elected officials who violate the law or otherwise abuse their office should obviously be removed by recall or impeachment. But that’s not the issue in Wisconsin. The argument there is about policy issues -- public sector collective bargaining and benefits -- about which reasonable people can disagree. But as is clear from our increasingly broken politics, we’ve lost the ability to work with those with whom we disagree, or to respect elections and the process of governance enough to let it run its course.
Besides, we have regularly scheduled recalls: They’re called elections. And for our democracy to work, they have to mean something. So after the recall vote next week, the citizens of Wisconsin may find themselves with a better governor. But they shouldn’t confuse that with having struck a blow for better governance.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






