RCP Podcast: What Could an Immigration Compromise Look Like, Or Another Government Shutdown?
Last updated 6:30 PM ET
Tuesday on the RealClearPolitics podcast, Tom Bevan, Andrew Walworth, and Carl Cannon zoom out and discuss the wider questions raised by anti-deportation protests, what an immigration compromise might look like, and whether Congress is really prepared to shut down the government again over ICE funding.
After that, the group discusses whether President Trump's trip to Iowa will be a net positive for Republicans running for Congress, and whether testifying against Trump in an impeachment is enough to launch Alexander Vindman's Senate campaign in Florida.
They wind down the show with a conversation about Kanye West's public apology for antisemitism, reports that Donald Trump is not planning to attend the Super Bowl this year, and Neil Young donating access to his entire musical catalogue to the nation of Greenland to make up for the president's "threats."
You can listen to the show live, weekdays at 11:00 a.m. on SiriusXM's Megyn Kelly Channel 111, and then on Apple, Spotify, YouTube, and here on our website.
***
The show opens with the long-term political implications of anti-ICE protests in Minnesota. Will the Trump administration back down? Is the Democratic Party going to fully embrace open borders, or are they just advocating more humane deportations? What could a compromise look like?
Carl Cannon offered some historical perspective. "For the last 40 years, more than a million people a year became Americans. They get in line, fill out the paperwork, take an oath, and it has changed the complexion of the country—demographically and politically," Cannon said. "Do we like this? The two parties don't even discuss it; they just shout slogans. When you say 'abolish ICE,' are you really saying you don’t think we should have any enforcement at the border?"
Bevan got down to brass tacks. "Trump’s mass deportation plan initially had majority support. But we’ve seen public trust erode over time as these incidents pile up—and this last one with Alex Pretti seems to be a tipping point—so now you have the president changing course or retreating," Tom Bevan commented. "The problem is there is no incentive to compromise. Democrats clearly think they've won! They think they’ve got the leverage, and they’re going to keep going until they can’t. If that means abolishing ICE, that's what they're going to do."
***
And then, around minute 13, the discussion moves to how Congress is responding. Are Democrats' calls to "abolish ICE" really about to lead to yet another government shutdown? Is that a winning play for Democrats ahead of the midterm elections?
"Senate Republicans need seven Democrats to vote to keep the government open at the end of this week, and they're not going to get them," Bevan explained. "Previously, 'Abolish ICE' was not a winning issue for them, but they think right now in the current environment, they have the public backing and leverage to do this."
"That suggests both parties are in this kamikaze fight where they're both overplaying their hand until it's no longer a winning hand. That's the opposite of leadership," Cannon commented.
***
After that, at minute 35, the group turns to President Trump's trip today to Iowa. Is another speech on "affordability" a help or a hindrance to Republican candidates at this point?
"The question is whether the president stays on message or s he going to dominate the news cycle for another day with something... else," Walworth said.
"It's going to be hard for him not to mention Minnesota while doing The Weave," Bevan said.
***
Next, at minute 28, a look at former NSC staffer Alexander Vindman running for Senate as a Democrat in Florida. Is being famous for testifying against the president in the first 2019 Trump impeachment enough to catapult him to the Senate?
"I think it tells you that Democrats are way more enthusiastic than Republicans are right now," Bevan said. "If Vindman wins in Florida, that's a blowout nationwide. That's a blue wave, and they would pick up five to seven seats in the Senate."
"Well, that's what Democrats are quietly telling each other—that this is possible now," Cannon adds. "I didn't even know he lived in Florida, or that most Floridians did either."
***
Finally, after minute 33, the panel discusses Kanye West's full-page ad in the Wall Street Journal apologizing for past antisemitic remarks and blaming the outburst on a "brain injury" and bipolar disorder.
They also break down why Donald Trump has chosen not to go to the Super Bowl this year, and reports that Neil Young has donated free access to his entire musical catalogue to the nation of Greenland as an apology for the president's "threats."
***
Don’t miss a single episode of the RealClearPolitics weeknight radio show – subscribe at Apple, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
Latest Podcasts

RCP Podcast: Second Sullivan Scandal, Generic Ballot Warning Sign for GOP? Nick Paumgarten on Masculinity and Hockey
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: France's Culture War, the Bolsonaros Win Big, Politics vs. Supreme Court
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Livestreaming an Execution? Ilhan Omar Raid, Where Was Talarico? Is Vivek Going to Lose?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Was the Blue Wave Pro-Democrat or Anti-Trump? What Kind of Mandate Do Dems Have?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Will Banning CNN From WH Help Trump? We Got Greenland? Can Congress Save College Football?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Trump vs. Talarico in Texas, What Would Be a Good Night for Dems? Is Polling Broken?
RealClearPodcasts











