RCP Podcast: What Caused the 'Blue-nami'? Is DSA Locked in for 2028? Can Vance Break With Trump?
Last updated 4:13 PM ET
Wednesday on the RealClearPolitics podcast, Carl Cannon, Tom Bevan, and Andrew Walworth analyze the most recent voter data, the new balance of power in Washington, and last night’s big winners and losers. They also discuss Vice President Vance's post this morning about why he thinks Republicans lost the House and Senate, the lessons the Democratic Party will take from this big win, and what the final two years of the Trump administration will look like.
Listen live weekdays at 11:00 a.m. Eastern on SiriusXM's Megyn Kelly Channel 111, or on Apple, Spotify, YouTube, or other platforms.
00:00 — Opening: The Blue-nami
Walworth, Cannon, and Bevan discuss the results of last night's "blue-nami" midterm elections and the catastrophic collapse of the Trump coalition. "Republicans got their asses kicked," Tom Bevan said. "Republicans lost men by three points -- that's a 17-point swing from 2024."
"Republicans lost young men by 18 points; that's a 31-point swing from just two years ago."
RCP's Carl Cannon: The 'Blue-nami'
Watch: Trump: "Congratulations To The Democrats, They Worked Very Hard And Long"
"Can we take a minute for those bedwetters at Reuters and these other news outlets, and these Democratic lawyers?" Cannon said. "They had all these bizarre scenarios they presented with a straight face, and today, not a peep. 'Hey, we were hysterical. Trump didn't do that. We're sorry. We scared the crap out of people. Maybe we scared the crap out of people for partisan purposes. Maybe it worked, but we're a little bit sorry anyway.' Nope."
***
12:27 — Only Issue Republicans Won on is Immigration
The panel turns to the exit polls and what issues voters said they trust each party with and Annie Andrews’ South Carolina victory. Did Republican divisions, candidate quality, or Trump’s intervention cost the GOP the seat?
"In Texas, Republicans spent $200 million dollars talking about Talarico, calling him a vegan-eating sissy who wants to trans the kids, right? Guess what? He tied Paxton among male voters in Texas," Bevan said. "That is a 28-point swing from two years ago. So clearly that messaging did not resonate. Or hundreds of thousands of vegans moved from California to Austin in the last two years."
Watch: Senator-elect Talarico Victory Speech: "People Are Desperate For Change, Now Change Is On The Way"
"The trans issue, which hurt Democrats two years ago, seems to have run its course as an issue," Cannon agreed.
***
23:50 — El-Sayed's "Sore Winner" Speech
The group criticizes Abdul El-Sayed’s victory speech and asks whether his Michigan win will strengthen the Democratic Party’s left wing heading toward 2028.
Watch: Abdul El-Sayed: "Donald, I Know You Struggled With My Name--So After JD Swears Me In, You Can Just Call Me Senator"
"Why do the people who purport to hate Trump the most act the most like him?" Cannon asked. "That's the great riddle of the current era to me."
"I've never heard anything less gracious in my life from a winning candidate. And then I remembered Donald Trump. This is what he does. He did it in an inaugural address, of all things."
Bevan suggested: "Clearly, one of the lessons from last night that the Democrats are going to take away, right or wrong, is that the DSA folks and the sort of radicals are gonna be like, “Hey, we won in Texas, and we won in Michigan. So all you centrists trying to get in our way and slow us down, go stand in the corner. We are off and running and heading toward 2028."
***
29:02 — Can Vance Break With Trump?
The hosts debate whether the damage to the GOP came from starting the Iran war or from the administration’s handling of it, and whether Vice President Vance will be able to distance himself from it for 2028.
"All of that was a disaster for Republicans," Tom Bevan said, "Vance said the reason Republicans lost is the war. The president himself said so last night."
"JD Vance has been a good soldier for Trump, even though reporting had suggested that he advised him against starting the war. Vance, if he does want to run for president and lead Republicans in 2028, is gonna have to break with the president on this issue. But he's gonna have to do it in a way that doesn't anger Trump to the point where they get into some sort of public feud."
***
39:33 — Jeffries: We Won on 'Affordability'
The hosts discuss Hakeem Jeffries’ affordability agenda, his comment that Democrats weren't elected to "get even," and whether pressure for investigations and impeachment can be held back.
"I just don't think Jeffries is going to be able to stop it," Bevan said. "There's just this momentum in the base there."
***
43:32 — Musk Goes One for Three
The group looks at the catastrophic performance of candidates supported by Elon Musk.
"Elon's gonna have to move his headquarters to more safe Republican territories. What's left? Costa Rica?" Walworth joked.
***
45:21 — Newsom Warns About Rising DSA
The episode ends with Gavin Newsom’s recent comments about the left’s growing influence and assesses his position in the potential 2028 presidential field. Bevan predicts Democratic presidential contenders will move left, while Carl Cannon argues that the election results strengthen Newsom’s prospects.
"I think he's back in the front of the line, but it's a long and unruly line filled with people who don't mind throwing elbows," Cannon said about Newsom.
"Nobody's going to accuse Gavin of not knowing which way the wind blows," Bevan added.
Latest Podcasts
Most Watched

RCP Podcast: Second Sullivan Scandal, Generic Ballot Warning Sign for GOP? Nick Paumgarten on Masculinity and Hockey
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: France's Culture War, the Bolsonaros Win Big, Politics vs. Supreme Court
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Livestreaming an Execution? Ilhan Omar Raid, Where Was Talarico? Is Vivek Going to Lose?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Was the Blue Wave Pro-Democrat or Anti-Trump? What Kind of Mandate Do Dems Have?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Will Banning CNN From WH Help Trump? We Got Greenland? Can Congress Save College Football?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Trump vs. Talarico in Texas, What Would Be a Good Night for Dems? Is Polling Broken?
RealClearPodcasts










