RCP Podcast: Does 2026 Set Up Newsom vs. DeSantis? Did Redistricting Break the GOP? Midterm Winners and Losers
Last updated 1:41 PM ET
Thursday on the RealClearPolitics podcast, Carl Cannon, Tom Bevan, and Andrew Walworth break down the results of Tuesday's midterm elections and what it means for the future of the Democratic and Republican Parties and possible 2028 candidates.
RCP senior elections analyst Sean Trende joins the program to discuss whether redistricting backfired on the GOP and what the numbers say about the Republican midterm rout.
The group also discusses how Bernie Sanders changed American politics, and then takes a few minutes to name their winners and losers from the midterm elections and invites the audience to weigh in too.
Listen live weekdays at 11:00 a.m. Eastern on SiriusXM's Megyn Kelly Channel 111, or on Apple, Spotify, YouTube, or other platforms.
00:00 — Opening: Can DeSantis Lead the Post-Trump GOP?
Walworth, Cannon, and Bevan discuss where the catastrophic Republican midterm results stand and whether Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis can position himself as the leader of the post-Trump Republican Party.
Watch: DeSantis Rips GOP Over Immigration: "So Many Things That Could Have Been Done"
"He was dismissed unceremoniously from the field in 2024, but now he's saying, 'You should have listened to me, because what I was talking about is what we're doing in Florida. And if the Republican Party has a future, we're going to have to do nationally what we did here.' That's a pretty salient argument. It's based on the merits. It's based on the facts, and I think he's going to continue to make it," Carl Cannon said. "It's clear to me he's running for president."
"He did lose the first time; he thought there was room in the Republican Party for an anti-Trump force. There wasn't; there may be now," Tom Bevan added.
***
11:23 — Schumer's Revenge
The panel turns to how Democrats’ Senate victory changes Chuck Schumer’s standing after months of criticism from within his own party.
WSJ: Chuck Schumer Was Democrats’ Punching Bag. Now He’s Riding High
Chuck Schumer: "54 seats and counting... These burgers and dogs are fully cooked"
"If AOC was thinking about running for Senate instead of running for president, I think she might want to look at this now and think, maybe Schumer is not such an easy takedown," Tom Bevan said.
***
17:24 — Did Bernie Win?
The group considers Bernie Sanders’ rise from an overlooked Senate backbencher to a major influence on Democratic politics and leader of a new generation of progressives.
Politico: Bernie Sanders Lost the Fight in 2016, A Decade Later, He Won the War
"He has changed American politics. He's changed the Democratic Party. And whether we think it's for good or bad is not the point," Cannon said. "He went from being this guy that nobody thought about to somebody you can't ignore. It's pretty extraordinary."
***
21:12 — Did Redistricting Backfire on Republicans?
RCP senior elections analyst Sean Trende joins the show to discuss whether Republicans' new congressional maps helped or hurt them on Tuesday.
Sean Trende, The Poll Vault: Did Re-Redistricting Actually Hurt Republicans?
"The problem is that none of these analyses compare it to the alternative," Trende said. This was a wave election, and it was going to wash up on every map that was drawn."
"And remember, these are three-cycle seats. We haven't seen how they perform in '28 and '30 yet.”
Sean Trende, ~24:38: “This wasn't just a wave in North Carolina and Texas. This was a wave across the country.”
***
28:04 — 'Total Collapse' of the GOP Coalition?
Sean Trende assesses the damage to the Republican coalition and the challenge of rebuilding suburban support without alienating the MAGA base. Which issues did the most damage? Iran, gas prices, tariffs, ICE, and more. Trende describes a cumulative backlash and Tom Bevan emphasizes affordability.
"It was a death by a thousand cuts," he said. "I think normal suburbanites didn't like the constant chaos."
"Republicans have to figure out how to maneuver between keeping enough support in the suburbs while also doing stuff that'll please their MAGA base," he said.
"But the knock-on effects of the war played into affordability. There's just no getting around that," Bevan added.
***
34:47 — Midterm Winners and Losers?
The episode ends with election winners and losers, as the hosts debate the future prospects of AOC, Ken Martin, Gavin Newsom, John Fetterman, Elon Musk, and JD Vance.
Latest Podcasts

RCP Podcast: Second Sullivan Scandal, Generic Ballot Warning Sign for GOP? Nick Paumgarten on Masculinity and Hockey
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: France's Culture War, the Bolsonaros Win Big, Politics vs. Supreme Court
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Livestreaming an Execution? Ilhan Omar Raid, Where Was Talarico? Is Vivek Going to Lose?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Was the Blue Wave Pro-Democrat or Anti-Trump? What Kind of Mandate Do Dems Have?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Will Banning CNN From WH Help Trump? We Got Greenland? Can Congress Save College Football?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Trump vs. Talarico in Texas, What Would Be a Good Night for Dems? Is Polling Broken?
RealClearPodcasts










