RCP Podcast: Second Sullivan Scandal, Generic Ballot Warning Sign for GOP? Nick Paumgarten on Masculinity and Hockey
Last updated 4:56 PM ET
Thursday on the RealClearPolitics podcast, Carl Cannon, Tom Bevan, and Andrew Walworth discuss the bombshell claim that Democrat Mary Peltola intentionally recruited the second Dan Sullivan. Will President Trump's visit to South Carolina put Republican Senate candidate Darline Graham over the top? And RCP co-founder John McIntyre writes that Democrats are poised for "the largest generic ballot win since Obama’s 2008 blowout."
New Yorker staff writer Nick Paumgarten joins the show to discuss his new book "The Intangibles," which deals with growing up, masculinity and hockey.
Plus, the group considers investigative journalist James O'Keefe being charged with voter fraud and identity theft in Minnesota over an undercover video investigating the state’s "voter-vouching law," which permits someone to "vouch" for as many as eight other people on Election Day. And former President Barack Obama picks up the "Cheesecake Factory" feud with President Trump.
Listen live weekdays at 11:00 a.m. Eastern on SiriusXM's Megyn Kelly Channel 111, or on Apple, Spotify, YouTube, or other platforms.
00:00 — Opening: Second-Sullivan Scandal
Walworth, Cannon, and Bevan discuss the New York Times report that the second Dan Sullivan running for Senate in Alaska really was a sort of "plant" recruited by the Democrat to spoil the incumbent's campaign, and whether ranked-choice voting mitigates the confusion.
NY Times: "Inside Democrats’ Secret Effort to Stack Alaska’s Ballot"
Sean Trende: Why the Mary Peltola NYT Story Might Actually Matter
"It might be a dirty trick, but I think it is legal," Tom Bevan said. The problem for Mary Peltola is that she swore she had nothing to do with it, and this New York Times report says otherwise. That calls into question her honesty and character."
Watch: Peltola Reacts To NYT's Dan Sullivan Story: "This Is All Stuff To Sell Newspapers
Watch: Sen. Dan Sullivan: Mary Peltola Has Been "Cheating And Lying To Alaskans For Over A Year," She Needs To "Come Clean"
"Saying the Times is just trying to sell newspapers makes her sound worse," Cannon agreed. "She's just attacking the messenger and trying to change the subject!"
Watch: Trump: Peltola and "The Fake Dan Sullivan" Should Be Taken Off The Ballot And Prosecuted
RCP Average: 2026 Alaska Senate - Sullivan vs. Peltola | Peltola +1.3
***
08:10 — South Carolina Is Tied?
The panel turns to the Senate race in South Carolina, where Darline Graham is running almost even with her Democratic challenger -- inside the margin of error -- way behind how her brother Lindsey Graham performed. Is the short campaign responsible, or is she just not a good candidate?
Watch: Trump Rallies For Darline Graham in South Carolina
"This is a ruby-red state that should not be contested," Bevan said.
"Donald Trump ran in that state just two years ago and won by more than 450,000 votes!" Cannon added. "That it is that close shows what's going on in this country right now. It's a referendum on Donald Trump."
***
13:38 — The Generic Ballot
RCP co-founder John McIntyre writes that Democrats are poised for "the largest generic ballot win since Obama’s 2008 blowout."
"No one should be surprised if the Democrats have a massive generic ballot win next week, with a wave that sweeps out unexpected Republicans particularly in states that aren’t activated with intense statewide races flooded with millions of dollars," he wrote.
Watch: Democrats Poised for Largest Generic Ballot Win Since Obama’s 2008 Blowout
"There doesn't appear to be any tightening of the generic ballot as we approach the end of this campaign," Bevan added. "If Republicans were going to make up ground they would be making it up right now -- and they're not."
***
16:46 — Senate Still in Play?
The group reviews new CNN polls showing Democratic leads in Kansas, Texas, Maine, and Michigan.
"Take CNN's polls for what they're worth. But when you plug them into the averages, if you look at our overall averages, they still show that Democrats are ahead in a majority of these key races, but by pretty slim margins," he said.
RCP Average: Battle For The Senate 2026
***
19:34 — Nick Paumgarten on Hockey, Beer Leagues & Masculinity
New Yorker writer Nick Paumgarten discusses his memoir about hockey, family, and growing up. He explores the appeal of male camaraderie and competition, including the challenge of balancing roughhousing with humility.
Paumgarten's Book: The Intangibles: Friendship, Fatherhood, and the Love of the Game
***
33:09 — James O'Keefe Charged
The panel discusses charges against James O’Keefe following an undercover investigation of Minnesota’s voter-vouching process. The hosts argue that the video exposes a vulnerability in the law, while distinguishing that claim from evidence that fraudulent votes were actually cast.
Watch:
James O’Keefe on Felony Charges for Exposing Fraud in Minnesota
"The government and the establishment fight back, not against the absurd laws or the fraud or whatever, but against the person or people who are uncovering it. It is Orwellian. It's ridiculous," Tom Bevan said. "Why don't they fix the law instead of this guy who highlights the absurd law?"
"This is such an abuse of the law, it is appalling," Cannon added. "I think this is an acceptable investigative journalist tactic and Minnesota authorities should be embarrassed they filed charges."
***
42:30 — 24 More Hours of Cheesecake Factory Battle
The episode ends with another day of the current and former president arguing over a joke about the Cheesecake Factory.
"This is actually a breath of fresh air compared to the usual mud," Carl Cannon quipped.
"Cheesecake Factory's stock is up over 100% for the year!" Andrew Walworth added. "The company has a market cap of $4.6 billion! The founder still owns it, based on his mother's cheesecake recipe. This is a great American success story."
Watch: Obama: Trump Launched An All-Of-Government Response To My Cheesecake Factory Joke
Watch: Trump to Obama: To Say The White House Is A Cheesecake Factory, "That Just Shows Why You Were A Lousy President"
Watch: Scott Bessent Knocks Obama: This Is The Man Who Built A Museum That Looks Like Darth Vader's Tomb
Watch: Obama Trashes Trump: "He's Got The White House Looking Like Saddam Hussein Opened Up A Cheesecake Factory"
Latest Podcasts

RCP Podcast: Second Sullivan Scandal, Generic Ballot Warning Sign for GOP? Nick Paumgarten on Masculinity and Hockey
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: France's Culture War, the Bolsonaros Win Big, Politics vs. Supreme Court
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Livestreaming an Execution? Ilhan Omar Raid, Where Was Talarico? Is Vivek Going to Lose?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Was the Blue Wave Pro-Democrat or Anti-Trump? What Kind of Mandate Do Dems Have?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Will Banning CNN From WH Help Trump? We Got Greenland? Can Congress Save College Football?
RealClearPodcasts
RCP Podcast: Trump vs. Talarico in Texas, What Would Be a Good Night for Dems? Is Polling Broken?
RealClearPodcasts











