Reps. Sanchez & Bilbray, Rep. Sestak on "Hardball"
Published April 21, 2010 • Read time: 18m
MATTHEWS: Democratic Congresswoman Loretta Sanchez of California sits on the Homeland Security Committee. And Republican Congressman Brian Bilbray of California is a member of the House Immigration Reform Caucus.
I want to get to this issue of birthing-or birthers, because there‘s part of this legislation out there that are basically going to say future presidential candidates, they have got to have birth certificates.
But let‘s start this general issue.
Congresswoman Sanchez, what‘s wrong with a state trying to enforce a law the federal government never seems to get around to enforcing? They have half-a-million illegal immigrants in Arizona. The federal government has dropped the ball. Why shouldn‘t the state of Arizona pick it up and do the job?
REP. LORETTA SANCHEZ (D), CALIFORNIA: Well, actually, the federal government has put more resources.
Many of the law enforcement agencies in Arizona are under 287(g). But what we find is that they‘re not very well-trained about what the rights are of people. So, the problem with a law like this is that, for example, I‘m Hispanic. So, if I go to Arizona, does that mean I have to carry a copy of my birth certificate and an affidavit and 14 signatures of witnesses to say that I‘m an American citizen?
How do you suspect someone looks like something? That is the problem with a law like that.
MATTHEWS: Well, what is the law-what would be a way that we could avoid all this and stop illegal immigration? Do you support the idea of a biometric I.D. card that‘s actually checkable, or not have a checkable I.D. card? Do you want a checkable I.D. card?
The Rise and Fall of Marco Rubio
An Invasion of Artificial Outrage
Obama Administration Tells Agents to ID Which Immigrants Not to Deport
Green Shoots of Sanity?
SANCHEZ: Well, I actually am one of those people that like the freedoms of being in the United States. And one of the things that we have always argued for was that we wouldn‘t have a national I.D. card.
But, again, I‘m also a person who lives under an I.D. card here in the Congress. I live under a driver‘s license that‘s under the biometric I.D. for the future for California. So, I mean, I‘m already using that...
MATTHEWS: Yes.
SANCHEZ: ... if I want to drive. I‘m already using that if I want to come into the Capitol.
So, personally, I don‘t have a problem with it.
MATTHEWS: Yes.
SANCHEZ: But there are a lot of conservatives who do.
MATTHEWS: Well, that‘s their problem.
The fact is, you and I have to get on airplanes and show an honest I.D. card. And if it‘s not an honest I.D. card, it‘s fraud. OK, and if we go to the bank and try to get money out and it‘s not us, it‘s fraud. If we try to check into a hotel and use a phony name, it‘s fraud.
OK, let‘s go the other congressman.
What about Arizona? Why do states try to get into the business the federal government is into, which is protecting us from illegal immigration?
REP. BRIAN BILBRAY (R-CALIFORNIA): Well, I think the same reason they‘re involved in the drug war, too, Chris, is that this is a community problem. It‘s not just a Washington, D.C., concern or just a border problem.
This is something across the board. You could imagine how successful we would be in fighting the scourge of drug dealers if we just said, well, local government‘s not going to be involved, we‘re not going to allow the counties and the cities involved, we‘re going to do this all just the federal government.
And you know that it has to be a coordinated community effort across the board in any kind of enforcement effort. This is the basis of community enforcements.
MATTHEWS: Yes, OK.
BILBRAY: You know, it‘s a given.
MATTHEWS: Let me ask you a problem. Suppose you are a second-generation Mexican-American or from Colombia or somewhere, and you have an Hispanic look, dark complexion, whatever. You may have something about you that indicates you from that part of the country or that part of the world originally, your parents were.
And a cop stops you and says, well, you have a mustache, or something that makes me think that you‘re Mexican-American or something, and he starts bothering you. Don‘t you think we are going to have a problem here with cops bothering people just because they seem to be Hispanic, even though they‘re citizens or they have a green card?
BILBRAY: Chris, that‘s why we have-we have the policies that there are things that you indicate that even go beyond the color of your skin, the hair, that looks at the fact-the way you dress.
My mother is an immigrant. I‘m first-generation-I mean second-generation on that. She speaks a little funny. But the fact is that the law enforcement is trained. In this law, it specifically says you will have a pattern of activity or a pattern of indications that give you a justification to think there‘s reasonable doubt, not just the fact of somebody‘s ethnicity.
So, this one has in there-it‘s something that federal government does with local government right now. We have programs so that they are using these systems right now.
The difference is, the-the people of Arizona are doing this across the board, rather than piecemeal, in their state. And that‘s why it‘s being implemented.
MATTHEWS: OK.
BILBRAY: And it-it really isn‘t that big of a leap, and it shouldn‘t be.
MATTHEWS: Let me go to the president.
SANCHEZ: Brian, that-Brian...
MATTHEWS: Go ahead, Congresswoman.
SANCHEZ: ... that‘s just not-that‘s just not true.
In fact, one of the sheriffs there in Arizona is under FBI investigation because he hasn‘t followed the rules and his deputies have not followed the rules. They haven‘t gotten the type of training that we get-give to our ICE or our federal agencies-agents that are-that do this immigration issue.
So, there are quite a few-in fact, sitting as the border chairwoman for over four years, one of the things that I saw was, you know, discussion after discussion from law enforcement officers about how this wasn‘t followed, about how people were being pulled over without, you know-and the law, the language that could be signed into law by this Arizona government says you suspect them of being an illegal.
What does that mean, you suspect them of being an illegal?
SANCHEZ: What does that mean, you suspect them of being an illegal?
BILBRAY: Chris, look, as someone who was born and raised on the border, I‘ve seen this my entire life. There is indications (ph) between legal residents and those who can be identified as being highly suspectable.
MATTHEWS: Like what? Give me a non-ethnic. Give me a non-ethnic aspect that would tell you to pick up somebody.
BILBRAY: I‘ll give you an example of the-they will look at the kind of dress you wear. There‘s different type of attire. There‘s different type of-you-right down to the shoes, right down to the clothes, but mostly by behavior. It‘s mostly behavior, just as the law enforcement people here in Washington, D.C., does it based on certain criminal activities.
MATTHEWS: OK.
BILBRAY: There is behavior things that professionals are trained in across the board.
MATTHEWS: OK.
BILBRAY: And this group shouldn‘t be exempt from those observations as much as anybody else.
MATTHEWS: Here‘s John McCain with a new look. He was Mr. Immigration, but here he is on Bill O‘Reilly. He has a different look right now. Here he is. Let‘s listen to John McCain.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
SEN. JOHN MCCAIN ®, ARIZONA: The state of Arizona is acting and doing what they feel they need to do in light of the fact that the federal government is not fulfilling its fundamental responsibility to secure our borders. Our borders...
BILL O‘REILLY, "THE O‘REILLY FACTOR": But what about the racial profiling?
MCCAIN: ... must be secure.
O‘REILLY: You know that‘s going to happen. It has to happen.
MCCAIN: I hope-I would be very sorry that-if some of that happens and I-I regret it.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MATTHEWS: OK, Congresswoman, what do you think of John McCain, the new John McCain?
SANCHEZ: Well, I think-he‘s obviously trying to win a primary where he‘s got a very conservative, you know, person who‘s very, very-got some very strange ideas. I know. I served with that person here in the Congress. I hope that John does beat him and then John comes back as a senator and gets back to the issue of-of really being middle-of-the-road here and helping us to push real and good immigration reform because that‘s what we need.
We don‘t need to be profiling people. We don‘t need to be going after people. We don‘t need to have local agencies deciding to take people off the street for whatever reason because they look like a suspect. We need good immigration reform here from the Capitol.
MATTHEWS: OK. I love the way you give John McCain a ride. You figure he‘s just faking it, so you don‘t mind. Let‘s take a look-just so he beats J.D. Hayworth, that‘s all that you care. Let me go to Congressman Bilbray first. You‘re a Republican. What do you make of the state Arizona saying you have to have-you have to have a birth certificate to get on the ballot next time? Do you think this is ad hominem? Is this a bill of attainder, as we used to say in Constitution classes? Is this aimed directly at the president of the United States himself, Barack Obama?
BILBRAY: No, Chris. Actually, this is Arizona. This is really aimed at McCain because McCain was-there‘s been an issue with the fact that he wasn‘t born in the United States. Now, it‘s interesting, the fact that he‘s qualified to be citizen-president. You don‘t have to be born in the United States, but a lot of people look at that. But because he was born in Panama...
MATTHEWS: Yes.
BILBRAY: ... and the Panama Canal is not-was not U.S. territory,
it was U.S. area to be treated as if it‘s territory by treaty with Panama -
so McCain‘s actually went through a lot of same thing in Arizona...
MATTHEWS: But they‘re doing it now.
BILBRAY: ... when the issue was raised by his presidency.
MATTHEWS: But Congressman, they‘re doing it now. John McCain‘s not running for president anymore. He doesn‘t have to be native-born anymore. He‘s an American, obviously. So the question is-the question is, Why are they aiming it at the president of the United States now? Do you think it‘s personal? One more try.
BILBRAY: No. I think that-I think it‘s a way to avoid-I think all of us, Chris, everybody in electative (SIC) office should be showing that we are a citizen and that we are-I think...
MATTHEWS: OK...
BILBRAY: ... the problem with this bill is that it should be universal to all elected officials. But I don‘t know if McCain is running again. Remember, he‘s been running every election since I‘ve-I‘ve been a child.
MATTHEWS: OK.
BILBRAY: So I‘m not so sure you can say he‘s not running.
MATTHEWS: OK. Well, I can‘t, either, but I‘ll tell you this. Barack Obama has shown his birth certificate to the world. He has shown documentation of his birth twice now from two different newspaper accounts, which were only written with the authorities participating in those announcements. They weren‘t just somebody putting out Christmas cards. These were announcements of somebody being born. We have all the records available from anybody who comes out of Hawaii. He has shown the record. And the birthers are crazy and they keep raising this crazy issue, and now the assembly of Arizona has joined the birther wagon and are behaving just as zanily as the birthers.
Anyway, thank you, Congressman Sanchez-Congresswoman Sanchez and Congressman Bilbray.
SANCHEZ: Thank you, Chris.
MATTHEWS: Up next...
BILBRAY: Thank you, Chris.
MATTHEWS: ... I‘m in Pennsylvania tonight, where the Senate primary race is getting a little nasty. Arlen Specter‘s getting a little nasty.
Joe Sestak‘s going to talk to us about the latest Arlen ad against him. It says he was relieved of duty. We‘re going to see what he thinks about that when he was a Naval admiral.
But first, during the commercial coming up, the District of Columbia‘s never had a voting member of Congress. Will it have one in now? We‘re going to tell you. The verdict‘s in, at least for now.
This is HARDBALL on MSNBC.
(COMMERCIAL BREAK)
MATTHEWS: Washington, D.C., has never had a voting member of Congress. It‘s not likely to have one soon. The long-anticipated D.C. voting rights bill was scuttled by a controversy over a Republican provision that would have stripped the District of Columbia of its strict gun control laws. Many Democrats said they could no longer support the bill now, and so taxation without representation continues for Washington‘s 600,000 residents.
(COMMERCIAL BREAK)
MATTHEWS: We‘re back. The Democratic primary up here in Philadelphia and Pennsylvania pits the incumbent, Senator Arlen Specter, who was a Republican for 30 years-he‘s now a Democrat-against Joe Sestak, who‘s always been a Democrat. This week, Specter went negative. It wasn‘t a surprise, but it‘s pretty tough stuff. Let‘s watch this ad. Pay attention. Here‘s the ad.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Joe Sestak, relieved of duty in the Navy for creating a poor command climate. Joe Sestak, the worst attendance of any Pennsylvania congressman and near the bottom of the entire Congress. Last year alone, Sestak missed 127 votes. Sestak says the missed votes weren‘t important. He went campaigning instead. Let‘s say no to no-show Joe.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MATTHEWS: I don‘t know where they find those creepy announcers, but that‘s a pretty creepy ad. That‘s Congressman Joe Sestak. And I have to congratulation you, sir, for keeping your sanity during this race. But you must have known going up against Arlen Specter-now you‘ve got four weeks to -- (INAUDIBLE) going to come. He did it to Jim Hoeffel. He‘s done it to Lynn Yakel (ph). Everyone who‘s ever ran against him he has destroyed. He doesn‘t just run against, he prosecutes you. He makes you the bad guy. You are evil at the end of these races. You must have known this was coming. What‘s your reaction?
REP. JOE SESTAK (D-PA), SENATE CANDIDATE: Well, I‘m going to find it hard to believe that the leaders of my Democratic Party aren‘t already on the phone to Arlen Specter. I mean, remember what Joe Biden said-I support Barack Obama because he doesn‘t try to perfect the politics of Swift Boating, he seeks to end them. And I think that everybody‘s pretty obvious that what Arlen Specter has done is reverted to old Republican-style politics, but now he‘s in the Democratic Party.
You know, let me give you a quote. I still remember when Barack Obama as a candidate said, I love this country too much to let him steal another election by lies, like this one, outrageous, phony assertions, Swift Boating. And you know, they did this to Max Cleland, who lost his limbs in Vietnam. They did it to John Kerry. No, all veterans aren‘t going to stand for this absolute false assertion that he has made. You don‘t get to be a three-star admiral, get to lead the Navy‘s anti-terrorism unit, get to command an aircraft carrier battle group without having a distinguished career.
Arlen Specter-you know, it is time without a question for the change in politics...
MATTHEWS: OK...
SESTAK: ... of a Republican who‘s a Democrat in name only. I don‘t think my party leadership is going to tacitly...
MATTHEWS: Well, you‘re optimistic. Let me ask you this. Do you think some of the people watching that ad we just watched think you were section 8, that you had a problem, that you were relieved of duty for some personal reason? That‘s what he‘s saying, that you had a problem.
SESTAK: That‘s what he...
MATTHEWS: Section 8, whatever you want to call it. What‘s "relieved of duty" mean to you?
SESTAK: I don‘t know!
MATTHEWS: To me, it means you couldn‘t do the job. You had a problem, mental, emotional, whatever, and you couldn‘t do the job, so they took it away from you. That‘s what Arlen‘s saying about you.
SESTAK: Well, I think it‘s pretty-pretty obvious right now that the verdict on Arlen Specter is he‘s not fit to be the United States senator. And that‘s why he‘s going to be relieved of command. Look, Arlen Specter‘s verdict has already been made, and you know it. You‘ve seen the Rasmussen poll. We‘re in a dead heat. You‘ve seen other polls where many, many are undecided.
I can respect Arlen Specter for his service but not for these outrageous lies and the things he‘s saying now. No, you know Pennsylvanians, Chris. It‘s time has come to change politics. And you saw Massachusetts say it. Pox on both your houses down there! If we don‘t change politics-we‘re in this for principle, and there‘s too many principles in our Democrat Party to welcome Arlen Specter‘s negative tactics.
MATTHEWS: Well, look, I‘m not going to take sides, but let me just tell you what I know about politics. If you‘re in office 45 years, like Arlen, and you‘ve been a senator for 30 years with a good record that you want to defend-you think it‘s a good record, but yet you got to run ads about your opponent, saying he was relieved of duty and he‘s a skunk, basically, a Section 8, there must be something showing up in your polling that‘s telling you you have to do this.
Now, you‘ve got the Rasmussen poll. That‘s a poll (INAUDIBLE) only one-all the other polls have got you 15 points out. Do you think you‘re going to win this one, when he‘s running this negative stuff?
SESTAK: Without question-you know, you also saw there was another poll, I‘ve forgotten the name, just after Rasmussen, where I closed 14 points from three weeks before. No, you know as well as I do, he said he wasn‘t going to go up on TV until I did. And then those two polls came up. He started a week ago. He‘s running scared. He ran from Pat Toomey. It‘s the only thing he can do because he has no accomplishments other than supporting George Bush four out of five times.
MATTHEWS: Yes.
SESTAK: And let me-don‘t get me wrong. He‘s done some things like NAH funding. But he‘s-he-what‘s he going to do, say, I‘m a Democrat, and argue with me on policy? No way. Look, Arlen Specter-let‘s thank him for his service, but this negativity-and Chris, we know it‘s tough in politics. Think about the seven of eight people who thought they would get in to run against him and never did for various reasons, including they knew this is what Arlen did.
I got in this race, though, despite all that because I honestly do believe it‘s time for a change where people can trust somebody. Here he is, giving Rick Santorum his vote...
MATTHEWS: OK, let me ask you...
SESTAK: ... saying, I‘ll support-I‘ll support George Bush‘s nominees for the Supreme Court Justice if Rick Santorum will give me his endorsement. What a shame to give away one‘s...
(CROSSTALK)
MATTHEWS: Do you think Pennsylvanians would rather have a really nasty customer, like that ad shows Arlen to be, or they‘d rather have somebody like you, that‘s sort of St. Francis, a nice guy? Do you think the public doesn‘t want some real tough customer down (ph) like Arlen? Arlen‘s been called "snarlin‘ Arlen" because he‘s very tough. But the fact is, there he is. And you‘re saying nice things about him. So if you say some nice things about him, he won‘t say anything nice about you.
SESTAK: It doesn‘t matter.
MATTHEWS: Do you know the uneven nature of this battle?
SESTAK: Look, when I was on the ground in Afghanistan as head of the Navy‘s antiterrorism unit for a short period, with my aircraft carrier command, and we were doing retaliatory strikes over Afghanistan...
MATTHEWS: OK...
SESTAK: ... or strikes-there‘s-there‘s no one who‘s not going to call me tough. But do (SIC) my results oriented? Have I increased the small business contracts in my district threefold in three years?
MATTHEWS: OK...
SESTAK: Do we keep our-do we take care of people, move money (ph) (INAUDIBLE) Absolutely. But the results of Arlen Specter is Pennsylvania‘s job creation has been half...
MATTHEWS: OK, we‘ve got...
(CROSSTALK)
SESTAK: ... the national average of 30 years.
MATTHEWS: Here we go...
SESTAK: Toughness, no, yes.
MATTHEWS: OK, you...
SESTAK: But results also, Chris. Results.
MATTHEWS: OK. Senator Specter, I have to offer you-Senator Specter, if you want to come on and defend the charge that this fellow was relieved of command, the very words you used-if you want to back them up on the air because I think it does imply a real problem and I don‘t think the evidence supports it. But if you want to make the case, Senator, come on and blast the guy personally, not just do a paid ad. Anyway, thank you very much Senator Joe Sestak...
SESTAK: Chris...
MATTHEWS: Congressman!
SESTAK: ... thank you.
MATTHEWS: There‘s a Freudian slip!
SESTAK: No, I appreciated "senator" and...
(CROSSTALK)
MATTHEWS: When we return-that was an accident. When we return-it must be the Rasmussen poll in my head. Anyway, we‘ll have you back. And anyway, we‘re going to talk in a minute about Teddy Roosevelt, the Republican who ended up on Mt. Rushmore by being a trust buster, by cleaning up the bad guys on Wall Street.
We‘ll be right back.

Jon Finer’s Old and Dangerous ‘New Approach’ to Israel
Peter Berkowitz • RealClearPolitics
The President Deserves Better
John Ullyot • RealClearPolitics
Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
