
What Obama Must Do in Syria
Published Nov. 22, 2015 • Read time: 5m
Syria has become Barack Obama’s Iraq—a foreign policy debacle rooted in faulty assumptions about the utility of American power. Where George W. Bush overstated what U.S. military intervention could achieve in Iraq, Obama has underestimated the risks and costs of non-intervention in Syria.
The analogy will rankle many progressives, as well as conservative “realists” who have praised Obama’s doctrine of U.S. restraint. But any administration’s policies must be judged by their results, not the elegance of their conceptual underpinnings. And the results of Obama’s decision to stand aloof from the Syrian crisis have gone from bad to worse.
Despite declaring early on that Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad must go, Obama in 2012 overruled his national security team -- including then-Secretary of State Hillary Clinton -- which urged him to train and equip moderate Syrian rebels not allied with jihadists groups. Having decided the previous year to pull all U.S. troops out of Iraq, Obama was not about to get sucked into Syria.
But power vacuums invite trouble, especially in the combustible Middle East. The Syrian caldron soon boiled over, morphing into a regional conflict as Iran and Hezbollah rushed to Assad’s rescue, while Saudi Arabia and Arab states came to the aid of Sunni rebels. Then came the hard-core Islamists of al-Qaeda and the even more fanatical spinoff, the Islamic State (commonly called Daesh), which proclaimed a new caliphate centered in Raqqa.
The romantic allure of a resurgent Islam has drawn as many as 30,000 foreign fighters, mostly young Muslim men from the region, Europe and America. And with U.S. troops having gone home, there was little to prevent Daesh from rolling across the border and seizing large chunks of Iraq. Only when Obama ordered airstrikes to halt incursions into Kurdish territory and genocidal attacks on the Yazidi minority did Daesh’s stunning expansion grind to a halt.
Over Here: Competence Amid Repulsive Politics
We're Not a Poor Country, Donald
What America Should Learn from the Attack in Brussels
Anti-Muslim Rhetoric Profits the Enemy
Amid all this bloody chaos, the opportunistic Vladimir Putin has jumped into the fray, ostensibly to fight the ISIS menace but mainly to prop up Assad and mark Russia’s return to power politics in the Middle East. Putin’s move, which effectively aligns Moscow with Iran, vastly complicates Obama’s hopes of brokering a political settlement of the Syrian conflict predicated on Assad’s ouster.
Syria’s fracturing is a humanitarian crisis of epic proportions. More than 200,000 Syrians have been killed, more than perished in the Iraq War. Millions of refugees have fled the fighting, putting enormous strains on Jordan, Lebanon and Turkey, and sparking a fierce backlash against Europe’s open borders policy. And the ripple effects have reached our shores, as fear-mongering Republicans whip up hysteria about admitting just 10,000 Syrian refugees.
The Paris massacre shows the Syria crisis has entered a new phase. Hemmed in by airstrikes and besieged by Kurdish and other forces on the ground, the caliphate is shrinking. So Daesh is demonstrating its potency by unleashing psychopathic violence against outside enemies—bombing a Shia neighborhood in Beirut, blowing up a Russian airliner, and most spectacularly, organizing the slaughter in Paris. Now Daesh warns that Washington and New York will be next.
Might more vigorous U.S. action three years ago have prevented Syria’s nightmarish descent into the maelstrom? We can’t be certain about that; Americans have good reasons to be humble about our ability to shape events in the Middle East. But this much at least is painfully clear: A rigidly anti-interventionist doctrine informed by the supposed “lessons of Iraq” is no guarantee of America’s safety. U.S. interventions in foreign crises always carry risks—but so does U.S. inaction.
President Obama now seems to recognize, albeit grudgingly, that his minimalist approach to Syria and Daesh is no longer tenable. Daesh’s shift to mass-casualty terror attacks and threats against Americans demand a more vigorous response. Jihadists can’t be allowed to plot terrorist attacks against Washington or other U.S. targets from the statelet they have carved out of Syria and Iraq. Their control of territory gives them access to economic resources—oil and “taxes” extracted from the caliphate’s unfortunate subjects—to pay recruits and finance global operations. Our national security requires destroying Daesh’s base of operations, just as we drove al-Qaeda from its havens in Afghanistan.
This does not require a massive U.S. invasion force. Here Obama is right: The lessons of Iraq do apply. Anything that smacks of an attempt by “crusaders” to impose imperial rule on the Levant will reinforce Daesh’s narrative of an apocalyptic clash between Muslims and unbelievers. (So will the incredibly stupid demands by Republican presidential candidates that Washington name “Islam” as the taproot of terrorism and extremism.)
But instead of trotting out the boogeyman of U.S. boots on the ground to justify its half-measure, the White House should join with France (and possibly Russia, if Putin is willing to abandon Assad) to wage a more aggressive counterterrorism campaign against Daesh. Our options include easing restrictions on the air campaign against Daesh; putting more fire controllers on the ground; dispatching additional special forces to conduct raids and support allied fighters; arming Kurdish forces and Iraqi Sunnis willing to fight Daesh; and, creating safe zones on the Turkish and Jordanian borders to stem the exodus of Syrian refugees.
Dismantling the caliphate is imperative, but it won’t extinguish jihadist fanaticism. That won’t happen until Daesh’s nihilistic ideology burns itself out. Driving the group back underground, however, will undercut its allure to alienated Muslim youths as well as its ability to plan sophisticated terror attacks against the United States and others.
Instead of telling Americans that the “the tide of war” is receding, and that U.S. military intervention can only make things worse, Obama should be preparing the nation to wage—and win—a long struggle with jihadism.

Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
The Primary System Is Losing the Next Generation
Sean Trende • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
