
Iran US Israel
The Death of 'America First' Must Not Be In Vain
COMMENTARY
Published March 9, 2026 • Read time: 10m
President Trump won the 2024 election on the promise that he’d end foreign entanglements and put America first. His winning coalition brought in anti-war leftists such as Tulsi Gabbard, who would become Director of National Intelligence, and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Presumptive MAGA heir JD Vance carried with him a track record of vociferously opposing war, too, particularly on Ukraine. And just before Election Day 2024, the vice president said it “very much” would not be in the Trump administration’s interest to go to war with Iran.
For me and other disenchanted leftists, concerned mostly about material conditions as opposed to defending the excesses of progressive cultural orthodoxy, supporting Trump over Harris no longer appeared as insane as it might have in the immediate aftermath of Jan. 6, 2021. (I was 17 when the 2024 election happened and thus couldn’t vote. I probably wouldn’t have voted either way. But if hypothetically forced, I would have voted for the current president over Harris.)
The post-leftist looked at a Democratic Party clearly incapable of doing much, having squandered its populist, economically focused wing represented by Bernie Sanders for pro-corporate wokeism, and at least saw in Trump the potential for much-needed change, protectionist and populist economics, and a rejection of the Washington Swamp and the neoconservatism it has long espoused. Trump’s “America First,” after all, is an idea that transcends the convenient left-right binary of U.S. political culture dating to the 1980s. There are a few notable people who, in some form or another, fall within this post-left category as well: Intercept founder and independent journalist Glenn Greenwald, the transgressive Red Scare ladies of Dimes Square, NewsNation host Batya Ungar-Sargon.
However, once Trump returned to power, it quickly became clear that more neoconservative elements still lingered in his orbit. Secretary of State Marco Rubio is no dove. Lindsey Graham, a Trump ally, and other Republicans on Capitol Hill, still appear gleefully obsessed with bombing campaigns. A quick scroll through Fox News host Mark Levin’s tweets reveals a similar euphoric penchant for military conflict.
The “revolution” of the populist New Right, it would turn out, did not happen as quickly or broadly as it may have needed to. In fact, despite a new generation of staffers and a New Right takeover of key conservative institutions such as Heritage, Claremont, and others, a supposedly more unconstrained Trump has been more hawkish in his second term than in his first.
Even with new and differently minded people in the movement, pro-war interests have not easily subsided. This “neoconservatism 2.0,” espoused by Graham, Levin, and others, rejects liberal internationalism for a hawkish nationalism, cleverly making the same interests of the past sound appealing to the MAGA brain (and perhaps even Trump’s own). And a push for war from close allies and Trump’s personal friends – Netanyahu’s Israel and Bin Salman’s Saudi Arabia – did little to help avoid the current conflict.
With today’s ongoing attack on Iran, two things can be true at once.
For one, Iran is not in America’s sphere of influence, and the White House did not make a compelling case as to why attacking Iran is in our immediate national interest. It’s also not clear whether with the Islamic Republic gone, Iran – a complex, diverse country of over 90 million – might descend into inter-ethnic conflict, competing military factions, and total anarchy of a piece with post-Soviet Russia in the 1990s. (The latest U.S. initiative to arm the Kurds is far from promising, and immediately conjures the memory of a similar initiative to arm the Kurds during the Iraq War.)
Moreover, Iran is not the same as Venezuela – the type of quick and successful military exchange the president heralds as a definitive sign of “winning” – and as we’ve just witnessed, attacking the regime and killing the Ayatollah has resulted in widespread calamity across the region, including unprecedented attacks on Gulf States. Debris set ablaze Dubai’s Burj-al-Arab, the over-$1,000-a-head hotel and renowned symbol of Emirati wealth, opulence, and soft power. At least 10 people were killed attempting to storm the U.S. Consulate in Karachi (at least 22 in total in anti-American demonstrations across Pakistan) over the death of the Ayatollah. Former Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett has found it wise to suggest Israel should also fight against Turkey, a NATO member state he claims is “the new Iran.” A missile apparently hit near (or in) Isfahan’s Naqsh-e-Jahan square, one of the most breathtaking places I’ve ever visited. And Israel, over Saturday night, struck oil refineries in and around Tehran, engulfing the capital in a hellish, almost apocalyptic landscape.
Remember that only a few weeks ago, the suggestion that Riyadh, Abu Dhabi, or Manama might be unsafe, and that the U.S. would be encouraging citizens to leave, was rather outlandish. (And the Qataris, attempting to cast their nation as Switzerland 2.0, now have the privilege of having been attacked by both Israel and Iran in the past year.)
Yet, it is also true that urbanized, secular Iranians who probably make up a bulk of the population (nearly 80% of the population lives in cities, contrasted with 50% at the time of the 1979 revolution) seem, at least from my vantage point, generally exuberant at the idea of a U.S.-Israel invasion to defeat the Islamic Republic. Many – domestic and especially diasporic – appear rather oblivious to the real damage done to normal Iranians: As of Sunday, Mar. 8, the official count shows at least 1,230 civilians killed, and a tragic photo shows a girls’ elementary school struck in the midst of the day (a U.S. military investigation points to American responsibility). And still, contrary to the neocon imagination – despite anti-regime protests earlier this year – there is no organized movement on the ground, no popular uprising.
Another element becomes clear: Many Iranians – whether in Tehran or Westwood, Los Angeles – await a mythical American savior and the return of the Pahlavi dynasty. Reza Pahlavi, the Shah’s son and the supposed “crown prince” in waiting, doesn’t have any real political experience, hasn’t lived in Iran for the past five decades (residing in a $3.1 million mansion in Maryland instead), and would in all likelihood be a catastrophic choice, even as a supposed “transition leader.” As with Venezuela – where Trump has seemingly snubbed María Corina Machado for Nicolás Maduro’s vice president Delcy Rodríguez – it might be wiser to put people already within the government apparatus in charge, who are willing to work with America and whose inclinations are more nationalist as opposed to Islamist.
One of the few good signs we have in this military offensive is that Trump proclaims to seek this as well. As for monarchist Iranians and their anti-left, anti-Muslim, anti-Arab fanaticism – a quick scroll through the X profiles of Goldie Ghamari, Nioh Berg, “Warren McCommon” will reveal this – who knows whether they’ll ever accept something other than the restoration of the Pahlavi dynasty? Will they ever admit to the Shah’s atrocities and the neglect of the working class that contributed to the Marxist-Islamist upheaval, or be happy with Pahlavi speaking at CPAC and not doing much more? Tragically, for the monarchists, it does not compute that one may be against the Islamic Republic’s tyranny and also criticize the Pahlavi family, be skeptical of U.S. intervention, and recognize that the 1979 revolution happened because of legitimate socio-economic grievances.
But let’s not get ahead of ourselves: A triumphant American victory and resultant regime change (even a “regime shakeup” from within the existing one) is still only a distant possibility. There are certainly elements of the Islamic Republic who, like Khamenei, are all but happy to die martyrs in the final great battle against the U.S. and Israel: The “Big Satan” and “Little Satan.” And, for the grievances of many Iranians – including my own family there – the dominant Western narrative that every single Iranian opposes the regime is also exaggerated. As the poignant Ben Burgis recently pointed out in Jacobin, Iranians do not share a “hive mind,” and we do not know whether relentless attacks may unify some, even those with their gripes, in the regime’s resistance. After all, for reasons ideological or material, there was a mass rally mourning the Ayatollah the weekend of his passing, in none other than supposedly “fully secular” and easy to re-Westernize Tehran.
Lastly, from an American perspective, this was ultimately a war of choice. (Ted Cruz himself now suggests that Iran was not “anywhere close to getting nuclear weapons,” the only half-compelling rationale for invading Iran aside from full-neocon “spreading democracy.”) The reputational damage America suffers every time we act as “world police” is tremendous. How China and Russia, which is now supplying Iran with intelligence according to U.S. officials, might perceive a potential U.S. client state of Iran should elicit concern for broader global peace and balance of power. We cannot forget, either, the long history of American destabilization in Iran, starting with the 1953 CIA coup against the democratically elected nationalist-socialist prime minister Mohammed Mosaddegh, providing justifiable ammunition for the anti-American, Marxist-Islamist revolution two decades later. And for all Trump’s talk of delivering “freedom” for the Iranian people, it runs contra his own National Security Strategy, which rejects “pro-democracy” justifications for intervention.
I’m far less optimistic than the editorial pages of The Wall Street Journal and will not pretend to know what may come out of the tremendous chaos and calamity, and I sincerely hope I and others opposed to this war are all wrong. One thing, however, is certain. If the war, already on its ninth day, ends quickly and Iran somehow ends up stable with a deal with America and Israel, and a transition away from the regime’s current unpopular Islamist dogmatism – a long shot, indeed – it will be very difficult not to always simply and unquestioningly “Trust in Trump.” True, nothing will cleanse the sin of needless death: not only Iranians, but also seven American service members as of Mar. 8. The president, however, despite abandoning his anti-war mandate and the overwhelming majority of Americans who opposed war with Iran, will have accomplished the impossible.
But the “impossible” is called such for a reason. If Iran becomes another Iraq, and the window for an off-ramp is tight, it will be very difficult to forgive the death of America First. And the name “Trump” will cause the same reflexive revulsion that the name “Bush” does. (Trump rode a similar revulsion at Bush’s and even Obama’s adventurism to political prominence in 2015 and 2016.) For now, the president’s comments demanding “unconditional surrender” and suggesting Iran’s map won’t look the same after the war do little to ease the worry that Iran may end up like the similarly-sounding country it is often confused with. Meanwhile, at home, the price of oil is rising rapidly.
The dealmaker-in-chief – admittedly, a man more remarkable than Bush – should pray that the biggest gamble he’s ever taken will work. And we can only pray that Trump is considering the fate of Tehran more judiciously than he did his bygone Taj Mahal.
Support Our Mission
The Internet provides an endless stream of content. Not all of it is worth your time. That's why, every day, RealClearPolitics curates the most essential news and information—from all sides and across mediums. The links, videos, and podcasts curated here are the product of human judgment, not algorithms or AI. Please help power our mission of presenting a thoughtful, balanced public discourse through a tax-deductible donation.
Would you consider supporting us today?
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






