
APTOPIX Salman Rushdie Assault
Rushdie Attack Births New Anti-Israel Conspiracy Theory
COMMENTARY
Published Oct. 1, 2022 • Read time: 7m
Anti-Jewish conspiracy theories never die; they simply assume new forms and content. From the murder of Little St. Hugh in medieval England to the Tsarist prosecution of Mendel Beilis for killing a Christian child, Jews have been ritually accused of heinous crimes, based on flimsy or nonexistent evidence, often with the support of respectable authorities. A surprising iteration of this phenomenon recently surfaced when a prominent university professor suggested that the life-threatening attack on the novelist Salman Rushdie was part of an Israeli intrigue. More surprisingly, the professor continued to push his conspiracy theory even after its implications were pointed out to him.
When Rushdie was viciously stabbed at New York’s Chautauqua Institution, there was little doubt in most quarters about the motive behind the attack. Rushdie had been under death sentence since 1989, following a fatwa from Iran’s then-supreme leader Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, as retribution for the perceived blasphemy in his book “The Satanic Verses.” After it was learned that the alleged assailant was a Lebanese American named Hadi Matar, who had been in contact with Iran’s revolutionary guard, Iranian responsibility seemed quite certain. But not to everyone.
Prof. Nader Hashemi, director of Denver University’s Center for Middle East Studies, fancied another explanation. In an interview on the Iran Podcast, Hashemi speculated about several ways Matar might have been prompted to attack Rushdie, before opining it was “much more likely” that Matar had been “lured” into action by a “Mossad operative” posing as someone “affiliated with the Islamic Republic of Iran.”
Over Here: Competence Amid Repulsive Politics
We're Not a Poor Country, Donald
What America Should Learn from the Attack in Brussels
Anti-Muslim Rhetoric Profits the Enemy
Why would the Mossad want to kill Rushdie, who has never been hostile to Israel or Jews? According to Hashemi, it could have been part of a plot to undermine President Biden’s renewal of the Iran nuclear negotiations. “Israel has taken a very strong position against reviving the Iran nuclear agreement [which] could explain the timing of this at this moment during these sensitive political discussions related to Iran’s nuclear program.”
To Jewish organizations in Colorado, Hashemi’s accusation sounded like a new version of age-old antisemitic conspiracy theories – not as bad as the black plague or the attack on the World Trade Center, but still like something out of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. “Hashemi’s perverse supposition is yet another example in a long history of falsely blaming and scapegoating Jews for intervening in international affairs in manipulative and violent ways.”
That should have been Hashemi’s cue to apologize, perhaps explaining that he hadn’t realized the historical resonance of his speculation. A fair-minded person would have recognized the harm implicit in spreading conspiracy theories, even unintentionally, and retracted the unfounded Mossad connection as insensitive and uncalled for.
Hashemi did the opposite, insisting on the virtue of unsupported surmises. “I get paid to theorize,” he told the Denver Post, as though his faculty position justified introducing baseless assertions not too far removed from claims about the Rothschild family’s responsibility for depressions and wildfires.
In a strained attempt at respectability, Hashemi expanded on his theory in a subsequent essay, explaining his “basic political science impulse” to ask, “Who stands to benefit?” Hashemi noted that he’d proposed several scenarios implicating Iran, before adding that Israeli responsibility was also “worth pondering.” He disingenuously omitted his original observation that the Mossad connection was “much more likely” than the others.
Hashemi then expounded on purportedly “corroborating evidence [of] an Israeli link.” He began with Israel’s “long history of covert activity across the Middle East, including false flag operations” such as the “Lavon Affair in Egypt in 1954.” He pointed out that “Israel has assassinated more people than any other country in the Western world,” and noted the Mossad’s many “covert action[s] against important nuclear and economic sites within Iran.”
None of Hashemi’s professed evidence – conflating covert and false flag operations, the latter having occurred almost 70 years ago – is remotely connected to the Rushdie stabbing in time, location, or modus operandi.
Hashemi also imagined a motive that “lends credence to my speculation.” “Israel’s fervent opposition to diplomacy between Iran and United States” could have inspired the plot against Rushdie, he said, in the hope that it “might galvanize Western public opinion, at a critical moment, to halt nuclear talks with Iran, perhaps ending them forever.”
In fact, Hashemi’s invented story follows the format of a classic conspiracy theory, stitching together a few random facts, tying them to a fantasized plot, and insisting that the “corroborating evidence” makes logical sense.
Thus, the temporary mishandling of some ballots in Antrim County, Michigan, was used to support Rudy Giuliani’s theory that the entire 2020 election had been stolen by Democrats, who had a motive to commit fraud.
Likewise, Dr. Anthony Fauci’s misstatement about U.S. funding for gain-of-function research at China’s Wuhan Virus Institute became fodder for the theory that he was behind the intentional release of the COVID-19 virus.
And Louis Farrakhan often seizes upon the presence of both Jews and LGBT+ people in the film industry to advance his own brand of conspiracy theorizing: “These false Jews promote the filth of Hollywood … It’s the wicked Jews, the false Jews, that are promoting lesbianism, homosexuality.”
Hashemi also sees himself as the focus of a conspiracy. When six Colorado Jewish organizations condemned his initial statement as “yet another example in a long history of falsely blaming and scapegoating Jews,” Hashemi declared himself a “political target” and accused his critics of “attempt[ing] to silence public debate.”
Unable to reckon with the idea that Colorado’s Jewish community might understand something about antisemitism that eludes him, Hashemi instead insists that they have combined to “police the debate on Israel” by suppressing his theories, which are “within the boundaries of reasonable debate.” He amplifies this point by arguing that nobody was accused of bigotry when it was suspected that Ukrainian special forces were responsible for the assassination in Moscow of the Russian nationalist Darya Dugina. The comparison is silly. Ukraine and Russia are at war, and there is no centuries-long history of falsely blaming Ukrainians for murders and other crimes. If there is such a thing as anti-Ukrainianism, it is unknown in the Western media.
A better analogy is the deadly 1995 bombing of the Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City, perpetrated by right-wing militia members Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols. Immediately after the bombing, it was reported that investigators were seeking “men of Middle Eastern appearance” – a description fitting neither McVeigh nor Nichols – who had supposedly been seen driving away from the site. The chairman of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee quite rightly condemned the speculation as “harassment of Muslims and Arabs.” Nobody defended it as “within the boundaries of reasonable debate.”
In an earlier article, I wrote that Hashemi was no doubt a person of good will, with no ill intentions. I hope I was not wrong. To his credit, Hashemi appears truly saddened to be associated with antisemitism. On the other hand, he does not even try to understand why so many Jews were offended by his baseless speculation. Instead, he assails “orchestrated campaigns of defamation, slander, and intimidation for offering an opinion.”
Hashemi does not believe he is a conspiracist, but what other word is there for someone who imagines “orchestrated campaigns” with ulterior motives behind every reproach? Of course, he offers no proof, but evidence is never needed in conspiracy land.

Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
The Primary System Is Losing the Next Generation
Sean Trende • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
