Roundtable on Obama and the Oil Spill
Published June 2, 2010 • Read time: 7m
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
PRESIDENT OBAMA: Right now, stopping this oil spill and containing the damage is necessarily the top priority, not just of my administration, but I think of the entire country. And we're waging this battle every minute of every day.
ALLEN: The cleaner the cut, the tighter the seal we can make on it. Partially through that cut, the saw got stuck, not unlike if you were sawing through a piece of wood and every once in a while it binds up.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
BRET BAIER, "SPECIAL REPORT" HOST: OK, you're looking live in the Gulf. We don't know what we're looking at there, but apparently they're saying that the saw is now freed from that pipe and they're back at it according to a BP spokesman. Don't see it working but we are told it is.
What about all of this? And the president speaking in Pennsylvania today, linking the oil spill to political action on his energy plan and Senate bill for comprehensive energy reform. Let's bring in the panel, Bill Kristol, editor of The Weekly Standard, Mara Liasson, national political correspondent of National Public Radio, and syndicated columnist Charles Krauthammer. Mara, first to you. The speech today in Pittsburgh, he really went after it hard and it was very political at points.
MARA LIASSON, NATIONAL POLITICAL CORRESPONDENT, NATIONAL PUBLIC RADIO: The president is in political mode. The election is only a couple months away. He is trying to draw a contrast between himself and his party and the Republicans.
He did wait until the end to talk about the energy bill. But I do think that is part of the political solution for him with this oil spill. Donald Rumsfeld famously said if you have a problem and it's hard to solve, make it bigger. He needs to make this bigger and link the oil spill to his push for clean energy.
BAIER: Even as he is getting a lot of criticism, Bill, about how he is responding to all of this, and even the images of him acting or not acting throughout this entire thing.
BILL KRISTOL, EDITOR, THE WEEKLY STANDARD: Mara said the election is a couple of months away. It's about five months away.
It was a weird speech today. He is entitled to give a big picture speech on his economic agenda, but I think he spent four sentences on the oil spill. But I do think, honestly, if you are in the middle of the crisis, he called at it catastrophe, the country expects you to take a few paragraphs to update people on where it stands and what you're doing.
Instead he slid over that and attacked Republicans for disagreeing with him on economic policy for a while. And so I think it's odd for him to say it's consuming every minute of every day, it's our number one priority, but I'm not going to talk about at it the major speech at Carnegie Mellon University.
BAIER: Is there a messaging issue coming from the White House on the oil spill?
KRAUTHAMMER: The main problem is any discussion of the spill itself is a loser because the president is helpless. Obviously, we're all watching it and it's out of control. So he wants to distract.
Yesterday we had the criminal investigation, or perhaps it was on Monday, which was a distraction. It actually cost - it took billions of dollars off the value of all the oil companies on the market. It caused a pretty big decline in the markets. But it had the political purpose of distracting attention from what you can't do, which is control the spill to what you can do, which is to make a political propaganda out of prospective trials.
Here what he is trying to do is to distract by going to another issue, a larger issue, and I think it's a real issue, which is what he wants to have as a carbon tax.
Now, he is a little late on the idea of taxing particularly oil and petroleum. I proposed it 30 years ago. Others have been at this for decades, Tom Friedman. It has been around ever since the early 1980s.
The distinction is on the conservative side, we have been advocating an oil tax because oil is a national security issue. It's also an economic issue. We're sending billions of dollars abroad to people like Venezuela, Russia, Saudi Arabia, unsavory ex-allies or adversaries who export all of this oil.
And if you tax it, we'd have less consumption and it would be a national security plus.
He wants to tax carbon, which means they want to include coal, of which we are the Saudi Arabia of the world, we do not import it. We have an abundance of it. And it's not going to help us on global warming. The Chinese have said they are going to be opening a new coal-fired plant every week for the next ten years, so it will be a transfer of wealth out of our treasury into China's.
And that I think is the big distinction on the issue.
BAIER: Is there a sense, Mara, that this is somehow getting him votes in the Senate on this energy legislation?
LIASSON: Look, the energy legislation had a political calculation behind it that was that it's going to include an expansion of offshore drilling. That is going to get you Republican votes. The oil spill put an end to the political equation. Lindsey Graham also dropped off negotiations.
But what Charles brings up is a pretty interesting point about the spill - if you conceive of it as a climate bill, you are going to want to make carbon more expensive. If you conceive of it as an energy bill and freeing the United States from dependence on foreign sources of industry, then you look at it in a different way.
BAIER: Weeks ago this thing was dead.
LIASSON: I think it can be revived. I think the president has to not just say he wants it and say oh, I'm going to look for votes but really make it a high priority.
I don't know what other option he has right now. Talking about the spill, as Charles says, might be a loser, but he can't avoid the spill, he can't distance himself from it. This is a fact of life and it's going to be a fact of life every day on television with those murky photos through August.
KRISTOL: But are they really doing everything? I'm not convinced of that. The liberal criticism of Obama by Maureen Dowd and Frank Rich is kind of idiotic, too. He's supposed to be more empathetic. That's not the point. The point is, is he as president of the United States doing everything he can to protect beaches and clean up the situation, even if he can't shut off the oil pipe down below the ocean.
It's not clear to me that he is. It's not clear to me he is doing what Governor Jindal wants. You know, I think that is the real question.
KRAUTHAMMER: Look, I think he is largely helpless. On the spill itself, he's entirely helpless. I think there has been a lot of inefficiency on the part of the federal government. But it happens in every disaster. It happened in Katrina. The federal government is not all-powerful or all-efficient. There are things that Jindal wants which are hard to do. And it's true, the federal government has delayed the building of the barrier island.
But overall, this is all at the margins. The real issue is at the bottom of the ocean. And my question is why are we at the bottom of the ocean a mile deep? One thing that Obama could do but won't do because he is a liberal is to open up the accessible, easily accessible oil in Alaska and in the Arctic.
The governor of Alaska had an article in The Wall Street Journal today saying we have reserve in Alaska near the Alaska pipeline and feds are shutting, not allowing the retrieval of any oil from there.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






