Don't Ask, Don't Tell: a Cautionary Tale
Published Oct. 21, 2010 • Read time: 6m
Last week, California federal judge Virginia Phillips apparently won the race to overturn the Clinton-era "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" law that prevents homosexuals from serving openly in the military. Her refusal to stay the decision on appeal has already resulted in military recruiters being instructed to accept openly gay enlistees.
But Phillips's decision so broadly extends the military's First Amendment rights and will cause so much collateral damage that it qualifies as judicial mischief. And in it is a cautionary tale for congress needs to study the decision carefully before acting to repeal DADT, which it may do in the December lame duck session.
Phillips's decision came in a case brought by the Log Cabin Republicans, a gay activist group, to have the ban on homosexuals serving openly thrown out on constitutional grounds. They presented several witnesses and anecdotal evidence to support their claim that DADT broadly infringed on gays' First Amendment and Due Process clause rights.
As Judge Phillips notes in her decision -- not once, but twice -- the Justice Department put on no affirmative case, admitted no evidence and produced no witnesses. All it presented was the law itself and its legislative history. That is, there was no evidence the judge could consider to show that the DADT restrictions on First Amendment rights (and the other constitutional questions presented) served a necessary and legitimate military purpose. Nothing to prove that DADT acted to preserve and promote military readiness and unit cohesion.
Charge Against Trump Campaign Manager Eclipses Wisconsin Race
Judge Garland and the Left's Disdain for Truth
Military Has Wide Discretion on Bergdahl Charges
Was Sierra Pacific Victim of Government Shakedown?
Shortly after the decision was rendered, Defense Secretary Robert Gates said that the decision to overturn DADT would have "enormous consequences" for the military. Gates must have some facts behind that statement. Why weren't those facts presented as evidence in the Log Cabin Republicans' case? And why wasn't the evidence of Marine Commandant Gen. James Conway submitted? Conway has strongly opposed repealing DADT. In an October 15 interview - shortly after the Phillips decision was released - Conway said that 90-95% of Marines felt that openly serving gays would cause potential problems with order and discipline. Conway's facts, like Gates's, weren't in evidence because, in boxing terms, the Justice Department took a dive in the case.
It is entirely possible that they did so because the Obama administration is in favor of repealing DADT.
And Judge Phillips - intentionally or in ignorance of military needs - wrote an opinion that goes much too far in apparently extending gays' First Amendment rights in the military. She held that DADT's conflict with the First Amendment actually impeded military readiness and unit cohesion. In writing that, she gave examples that can easily be read to permit gay activism among active-duty military personnel. Among them were that it prevents service members from openly joining activist organizations such as Log Cabin Republicans "...that seek to change the military's policy on gay and lesbian servicemembers; in other words, it prevents them from petitioning the Government for redress of grievances."
Much more solid constitutional reasoning on service members' First Amendment rights is in the 1996 Thomasson v. Perry case in which the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit found DADT constitutional against the same challenges brought in the Log Cabin Republicans case.
"Members of the armed services," the Circuit Court wrote, "have never possessed all the First Amendment rights of the civilian population. Rather, the Supreme Court has made clear that special First Amendment considerations surround the military environment." And they were right: the military has never had the right to the political activism that Judge Phillips has apparently loosed among its members. Judge Phillips noted that case and decided to ignore it.
How far does this ruling go? Military members have never had the right to attend political demonstrations in uniform, but they can do so - off the military base, and in civilian clothes - if off duty. Can they now demonstrate in uniform? Will they be able to proselytize or demonstrate on base? If so, the decision will affect more than homosexual activists. What other political pressure groups will have a safe haven within the military?
The practical effects of holding DADT unconstitutional are enormous. Gen. Conway said last summer that he wouldn't force a Marine to share living quarters with a gay Marine. How will he be able to discriminate in that way?
A retired Navy admiral, one-time skipper of a Nimitz-class aircraft carrier put it this way: "I can barely find room to give privacy to two genders. I can't do it for four." And, he wondered, how he would answer the inevitable letters from parents asking why he forced their son or daughter to bunk next to a gay person.
The underlying issue - approached but not decided by Judge Phillips - is whether there is a constitutional right for gays to serve in the military. She comes close - referring repeatedly to the Supreme Court's Lawrence v. Texas decision, which held a Texas criminal law against homosexual acts unconstitutional - but her decision doesn't overturn the parallel provision in the Uniform Code of Military Justice (Article 125) which makes sodomy a crime.
The courts have yet to decide if there is a constitutional right to serve in the military. But - unless that right is found under another "penumbra" it appears the constitution disposes of that by providing specifically in Article 1, Section 8, that Congress is given exclusive power, "...to make Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and naval forces..."Which means that if congress finds legitimate military necessity for DADT, it would have to be sustained by the courts.
If the Obama administration and congress were breathing a sigh of relief at Phillips's ruling - thinking that they now don't have to be held accountable for the result - they are wrong. Phillips's decision makes congressional action to preserve DADT an urgent necessity.
Congress has a constitutional duty to prescribe the terms under which people can serve in the military. They should - before they act - do what the Justice Department neglected to do: get the evidence they need. What are the facts behind Gen. Conway'sstatement that repeal of DADT will affect Marine order and discipline? Why did Gates say the ruling would have enormous consequences? Congress needs to consider seriously the truth of this matter: the military community is, for good reason, united in opposition to repealing DADT.
This is the cautionary tale congress would be ill-advised to ignore. Even while the Obama Justice Department gives a wink and a nod to the Log Cabin Republicans.

Jon Finer’s Old and Dangerous ‘New Approach’ to Israel
Peter Berkowitz • RealClearPolitics
The President Deserves Better
John Ullyot • RealClearPolitics
Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
