Interview with Secretary Sebelius
Published Feb. 18, 2010 • Read time: 7m
MADDOW: Joining us now is Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius. Madame Secretary, thank you so much for your time. It‘s nice to have you here.
KATHLEEN SEBELIUS, SECRETARY OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES: It‘s nice to be with you. Welcome to D.C.
MADDOW: Thank you. I‘m having a good time. Specifically on the Anthem plan hike in California, you have asked the company to try to justify that hike. They have made some responses to your request and state officials‘ request. Have you felt like you‘ve received a satisfying answer?
SEBELIUS: Well, I think for a company that posted a huge profit in the fourth quarter of 2009, $2.7 billion to be exact, to turn around and then say to 800,000 Californians the following week, "We desperately need to increase your rates by an average of 39 percent," doesn‘t seem to make a whole lot of sense.
And we‘re talking about people, Rachel, in the non-group markets that don‘t have the protection of being able to negotiate in a bigger pool. They don‘t have the opportunity to get discounts.
Most of these folks are locked out of the group market because the employers don‘t offer coverage or they may have a pre-existing condition. So they really have no options. And they‘re looking at coming up with thousands of dollars more or not having coverage at all.
MADDOW: Sounds like you‘re not satisfied with that explanation.
SEBELIUS: Not so much.
MADDOW: You said today that the president plans to put out a proposal for health reform before this big bipartisan summit that‘s due to happen next week. What should we expect the plan to look like? Is it a combination of the House and Senate bills?
John McCain, Patrick Leahy & Ray LaHood on "State of the Union"
Team of Loyalists
Dismal Indeed: Why Dick Cheney Disdains The 'Second-Rate' Obama Team
Obama Nominates Sally Jewell For Interior Secretary
SEBELIUS: Well, I think he‘s likely to get a lot of the best ideas. As you know, the House and Senate have worked for over a year on really comprehensive health reform to lower costs, premium costs to individuals and families. And the CBO says both bills do that to lower the long-term rise in health care costs so that we don‘t face increases year after year after year.
The Congressional Budget Office again says both bills do that to cover a lot more Americans. I mean both these bills address - 30 million to 35 million additional Americans would have affordable coverage and finally, to go after the insurance companies for the kinds of practices that we see here.
And not only the kinds of rate increases but the kinds of restrictions and benefits, kicking people out of the market, locking people out of the market. Those rules would change once and for all.
MADDOW: Between the two bills that have passed - one passed in the House, one passed in the Senate. The Senate is rather more conservative bill. If that ends up being the basis for what is finally signed, would that bill actually prevent the kinds of rate hikes that I described in this introduction that your department did this report on today?
SEBELIUS: Well, what it would do in both the House and Senate bill is it wouldn‘t take over insurance regulation away from the states. It would assume that the states are the first line of defense, but it would do a couple of things. One is require a huge spotlight on any rate increases. Companies would have to basically file online. Anybody anyplace would get to figure out what‘s going on. Just a spot light on Anthem has made them delay for two months what‘s going on.
MADDOW: Yes.
SEBELIUS: And I think, you know, we‘ll see what happens there. It also would have a requirement for a medical loss ratio at about 85 percent. So the money that comes in the door, about 85 percent of it would have to be spent on paying for health cost, not for CEO salaries, not for advertisement, not for overhead cost, but health cost.
That‘s very different than it is today. And we require that, if that doesn‘t happen, the money would have to be rebated to customers. So you‘d make sure that you couldn‘t have this dramatic increase in rates and not a dramatic increase in health cost and some choice and competition, which is huge.
MADDOW: On the matter of choice and competition - when I heard about the Anthem/Blue Cross hike and actually - the people in my personal life who are affected by that directly.
And my feeling about that is, you know, while I wish that the insurance companies were regulated so that couldn‘t happen in a way - I sort of feel that way.
But more than anything, I feel like, wow, insurance companies have been really awful and they‘ve - we‘ve left - entrusted essentially creating an American health care system. They‘ve done a really bad job of it.
I don‘t know of anybody who loves their insurance company. I know a lot of people like their doctor. And looking at those rate hikes - yes, I want regulation.
But really, I want people to have an option to get something other than private health insurance because I think private health insurance has not been great for American people. It just really hasn‘t.
There are some things that are nice but the overall system really hasn‘t worked. And it‘s made me the want the public option maybe more than I‘ve ever wanted it, looking at these hikes again. Do you guys in the administration understand the visceral reason that the public option still polls so well? We really don‘t trust the insurance companies to have our best interests at heart in this country.
SEBELIUS: Well, I think that the essential piece is some competition. In most of these cases and across the country, about 94 percent of the market, companies have a monopoly. There‘s no one to compete with.
And particularly, if you are the mom who wrote me from California looking at a 38 percent rate increase which translates for her into $7,000 a year more for her family. Her son has Type 1 diabetes.
She‘s a single mom. She has no options at all. She can‘t drop coverage because it could be a life-or-death situation for her kid. She doesn‘t know where she‘s going to come up with $7,000 and there‘s no other company to go to.
So what she needs desperately is an option and an affordable option to help pay the premium. But some competition - you know, let‘s go back to just market principles. Let‘s compete.
Insurance companies should not have a monopoly. They should not
be able to, you know, have profits that so far exceed any health care costs
that -
MADDOW: But in the competitive market - we have a more-or-less competitive market that we have now. Nobody thinks - looks at one insurer and says, "Now, they‘re doing an awesome job serving all of their customers."
The private insurance writ large hasn‘t done a great job, that‘s why we want a public option to compete with them. These 18 Democratic senators want to bring that back into the fold. If that happened, would the administration fight for it?
SEBELIUS: Well, I think, certainly. If it‘s part of a decision of the Senate leadership to move forward, absolutely. And the president said from the outset he thought that was a great way to provide cost reduction and competition. But if that is not the choice of the majority moving forward, I think there are other ways to get there.
But the competition and choice for consumers are the essential features. And we‘ve got to give people a way to afford coverage and also make sure that companies can‘t write their own rules. And that‘s what‘s happening all over the country.
MADDOW: Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, I‘m really thank you for your time. It‘s nice to have you on the show.
SEBELIUS: Great to be with you.
MADDOW: Thank you. Good luck.
SEBELIUS: Thanks.

Jon Finer’s Old and Dangerous ‘New Approach’ to Israel
Peter Berkowitz • RealClearPolitics
The President Deserves Better
John Ullyot • RealClearPolitics
Congress Doesn’t Need Another Blame Game. It Needs To Find What’s Broken
Jarrod Bernstein • RealClearPolitics
Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
