
Israel Palestinians
The Costs of Cultural Illiteracy: Lessons From the Israel/Hamas War
COMMENTARY
Published Jan. 30, 2025 • Read time: 5m
Two weeks after Israeli President Isaac Herzog approved a ceasefire and hostage release deal with Hamas, a tentative peace appears to be holding in war-torn Gaza. But Israel would have to be naive or suicidal to trust that Hamas will uphold the deal long-term. Luckily, Israel has proven to be neither.
Israel has all but dismantled Hamas and Hezbollah, defending its people and borders in the process and earning the respect of leaders in the Middle East, including friends and foes. However, its aggressive strategies have earned it significant criticism from Western onlookers. This disconnect reveals Western Leadership’s misplaced priorities and naive approach to confronting terrorism in the Middle East. Israel still has far to go to finally end the war with Hamas, and Western allies would do well to ignore their constituents’ outrage and continue supporting Israel’s strategies.
While activists decry Israel’s “genocide” of civilians in Gaza, Hamas itself has earned loathing and dishonor from Palestinians and the broader Middle East. Both the Global Imams Council and even Gaza’s own religious authorities have condemned Hamas for directly causing Palestinian suffering through the Oct. 7 massacre, continued refusal to release hostages (including murdering several of them), and numerous war crimes throughout the conflict. Even the Palestinian Authority – hardly a friend to Israel or Jews – has denounced Hamas for using human shields, brutality against Gazan citizens (including murdering dissident Gazan civilians in the street for “collaborating” with Israel), and serving as an Iranian proxy.
Nuclear Jihad: The Threats Are Inside Our Tent
Israel's "Sorrow of the Left"
Signs of Progress Against Extremists in Syria
The World Is Getting Worse, But This Time America Won't Save It
While Israel has proven itself worthy of respect, an essential element for achieving any lasting peace in the Middle East, Hamas has consistently demonstrated itself cowardly, incompetent, and ineffective. Hamas’ late leader, Yahya Sinwar, epitomized this in his final act: impotently hurling sticks at a drone before being eliminated by Israeli forces. Such failures have lost Hamas the respect of many Palestinians, even if the terrorist organization remains beloved by extremist Western protestors.
Though the current ceasefire focuses on exchanging hostages, this is not a peace deal. The Israeli government has clearly stated that Hamas will not be allowed to regroup and maintain power in Gaza. Given that Hamas broke the last ceasefire deal to commit the Oct. 7 massacre, Israel is right to distrust the terrorist organization, especially as Hamas continues to promise future atrocities. This hawkishness is symptomatic of the broader cultural awareness that has earned Israel the respect, if not the love, of its neighbors.
Yet, when the violence inevitably resumes, Hamas will continue weaponizing Western sentiment against Israel as it has done for the past 18 months, cranking up the victim rhetoric to Western outlets, posting images of suffering Palestinian citizens as though Israel is to blame for their plight. This, in turn, will encourage Western onlookers to resume their protests, double standards, and victim-blaming of Israel.
Western leaders have a heavy temptation to heed the misguided outcries of their constituents – especially given the potential political consequences of not doing so. For example, Michigan congresswoman Rashida Tlaib refused to support Kamala Harris in the 2024 election over Harris’ supposed “Zionism,” helping flip Michigan to Donald Trump.
Although President Trump seems to have come out for the Israeli side, even demanding that Egypt and Jordan take Gazan refugees and suggesting that Gaza be “cleaned out,” He is also far from immune to anti-Israeli protests. Given his history of inflammatory rhetoric and somewhat simplistic approach to geopolitics, and his association with noted antisemites like Marjorie Taylor Greene and failed attorney general nominee Matt Gaetz, Trump might remain vulnerable to social pressures, posing risks not only to Israel’s strategy but also to Western credibility and security. However, heeding such outcries would be the worst decision Western leaders could make, not just for Israel but for their own security and credibility.
Israel’s success comes from upholding honor norms of toughness and retaliation, values central to Middle Eastern cultures, including numerous terrorist organizations. Western leaders who insist on disregarding such cultural realities – such as advocating for “diplomatic” responses to violent terrorist attacks or demanding “restraint” as Israel endures bombings and terror – appear weak, naive, and vulnerable to other potential allies in the region.
Strategic partners like the Kurds, the UAE, and even disaffected Iranians fighting the Ayatollah’s tyranny will neither respect nor rely on nations whose leaders fail to understand and operate within these norms. These allies may ultimately turn elsewhere for support, undermining Western nations’ ability to negotiate peace in the broader Middle East.
Failing to grasp and respect these norms isn’t just poor strategy – it’s an active failure of leadership. A world leader earns trust and respect by standing with allies and demonstrating an understanding of a region’s cultural and geopolitical complexities, not by enforcing their own cultural biases. Leadership is contextual, and culture is a critical context that leaders need to consider. Israel’s strategy against Hamas demonstrates that what works in one cultural framework may fail in another.
The war in Gaza has been marked by widespread cultural illiteracy from Western leaders that has undermined Israel, emboldened both Israel and the West’s enemies, and therefore prolonged the conflict and the suffering it has caused. Rebuilding Gaza and fostering regional peace will demand active, informed engagement from Western leaders, who must shed their cultural biases and embrace a pragmatic understanding of honor norms. Anything less risks further instability, alienated allies, and emboldened enemies.

Democrats Won the Midterms. Common Sense Won, Too
Jordanne Kemper • RealClearPolitics
The 120th Congress Shapes Up
Carolina Lumetta • RealClearPolitics
Flooding GOP Primaries With Democrats
Robert Natelson • RealClearPolitics
Washington Keeps Rewarding Oracle—Veterans Keep Paying the Price
Darin Gaub • RealClearPolitics
The Seeds of Unrestricted Warfare
John Teichert • RealClearPolitics
The Primary System Is Losing the Next Generation
Sean Trende • RealClearPolitics
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000
