April Ryan: "Legitimate Question" If Trump Believes Slavery Was Wrong
Last updated 10:03 PM ET
At Wednesday's White House briefing, 'American Urban Radio Network's correspondent April Ryan asked press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders if President Trump believes slavery was wrong. Sanders responded, "I think it is disgusting and absurd to suggest that anyone inside of this building would support slavery."
Ryan appeared on CNN Tonight with host Don Lemon to talk more of her stance that the administration supports slavery, calling it a "legitimate question."
"She issue is the Civil War -- one of the main reasons why the Civil War was fought because of slavery. She just kept on going down this line and I never heard an answer to the definition of compromise," Ryan said of a controversial answer Chief of Staff John Kelly gave in an interview earlier this week.
"So that's why I said -- and then you have all this other stuff going on when the administration is supporting those who are supporting the Confederate statues, et cetera," she further explained.
Ryan said this is what led her to believe it is a "legitimate question" to ask what the Trump White House thinks of slavery.
"So there was still confusion. So I asked a simple question. As they're supporting the confederacy and these statues and Robert E. Lee, that General Kelly saying Robert E. Lee, do you think slavery was wrong. That's a legitimate question," Ryan said.
"I was asking a legitimate question," she said once more.
"Of course it's a legitimate question," CNN host Don Lemon agreed. "And it's very simple answer. She could have said yes, absolutely we believe that slavery is wrong. But she can't. She's in a tough spot because she has to defend someone who says that Robert E. Lee put the state over the country at that time. "
"I think that's a definition of treason of there," Lemon added.
Transcript, via CNN:
LEMON: The White House Chief of Staff John Kelly leaving a lot of historians in an uproar and other people as well after saying this about the Civil War.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
JOHN KELLY, WHITE HOUSE CHIEF OF STAFF: I will tell you that Robert E. Lee was an honorable man. He was a man that gave up -- gave up his country to fight for his state, which in 150 years ago was more important than country. It was always loyalty to state first back in those days. Now it's different today.
But the lack of an ability to compromise led to the Civil War, and men and women of good faith on both sides made their stand with their conscience had them make their stand.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
LEMON: The White House Press Secretary Sarah Sanders refusing for two days in a row to clarify Kelly's remarks.
So joining me now CNN political analyst April Ryan, White House correspondent for the American Urban Radio Networks, and Tim Wise, the author of "White Like Me." Welcome to the program. Wow. A lot to discuss. So, Tim.
TIM WISE, AUTHOR, WHITE LIKE ME: Yes.
LEMON: You say that General John Kelly is either ignorant or he knows he is wrong and he is pandering to President Trump's base. I have to ask you, which is it? Which is worse, though?
WISE: Well, it could be either, and they're both horrible. I mean, he's either ignorant or he's pandering. The ignorance is very clear. No historian would believe his argument that somehow a lack of compromise is why there was a Civil War. The folks who seceded from the union and decided to launch that war made it very clear why they were doing it and they said that it was to preserve white supremacy.
The vice president of the Confederacy, Alexander Stevens said that the cornerstone of the new government was the great truth that the, quote, "Negro is not equal of the white man." So they went to war and seceded to preserve a system of white supremacy. They said so.
And I have to assume John Kelly knows that, which makes me believe that what he's doing is pandering to a subset of Donald Russia's base that ravels in neo confederacy and literally takes a bath in the politics of white rage and grievance. And that's why you saw that Confederate flag at Trump rallies all during the campaign, even outside of the south. There is a part of his base that loves this.
So I have to assume that John Kelly is not the adult we were told he was when he was brought into the White House because he is saying absurd, fundamentally ridiculous things, pandering to a group of people who are very much bought into the politics of white racial grievance and love that stuff.
LEMON: The White House is standing by General Kelly's comments, denying that they were offensive. April, you tried to ask Sarah Sanders about this and she was -- as she was leaving the briefing room yesterday. Watch this.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
SANDERS: Thanks so much, guys. Hope you have a happy and safe Halloween. Thanks, guys.
UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: Sarah, was slavery wrong?
(END VIDEO CLIP)
LEMON: Wow. And then here is your exchange with Sarah Sanders earlier today.
(BEGIN VIDEOTAPE)
APRIL RYAN, SENIOR POLITICAL ANALYST, CNN: What is the definition of compromise as it relates to slavery and the Civil War?
SANDERS: Look, I'm not going to get in and relitigate the Civil War. Just like I told you yesterday, I think I've addressed the concerns that a lot of people had and the questions that you had.
RYAN: The question is does this administration believe, does this president believe slavery was wrong?
And before you answer, Mary Frances Berry, a historian said in 1860 there was a compromise, a compromise was to have southern states keep slavery, but the confederacy fired put something to it that cause the Civil War. And because of the Civil War what happened, the north won.
SANDERS: I think it is disgusting and absurd to suggest that anyone inside of this building would support slavery.
(END VIDEOTAPE)
LEMON: So she didn't really answer -- so what they're doing is discussing -- what is she saying?
RYAN: It was disgusting for me to even raise the question.
LEMON: I thought she was referring to them by that because she's doing exactly what she said. What does she mean relitigating the Civil War? I mean, all you have to do is pick up a history book.
WISE: Right.
LEMON: You know, everyone knows what the Civil War is about. There's no relitigating.
RYAN: Slavery. And yesterday -- yesterday -- and this is why I asked, because she didn't call on me yesterday and she was picking all around me. But the issue is when she did give answers to the reporters, there were answers like, you know, many of the presidents are flawed. All of the presidents have flaws. All of them. So let's go there in one way or the other and there are regrets afterwards. You know, we've heard that from many presidents. OK, so all the presidents have flaws. She never answered.
(CROSSTALK)
LEMON: And she said our leaders are flawed, right?
RYAN: She called out presidents as well.
LEMON: OK.
RYAN: She named some. Now, yes. So then, you know, she was asked, she was continually asked. She didn't want to get into it. But then she said she blamed us as the media saying that we're trying to make this racial.
The issue is the Civil War -- one of the main reasons why the Civil War was fought because of slavery. She just kept on going down this line and I never heard an answer to the definition of compromise.
WISE: Right.
RYAN: So that's why I said -- and then you have all this other stuff going on when the administration is supporting those who are supporting the Confederate statues, et cetera.
WISE: Right.
RYAN: So there was still confusion. So I asked a simple question. As they're supporting the confederacy and these statues and Robert E. Lee, that General Kelly saying Robert E. Lee, do you think slavery was wrong. That's a legitimate question.
WISE: Right.
RYAN: It wasn't to be smart or anything. I wasn't -- I wasn't trying to attack her or make any assertions.
(CROSSTALK)
LEMON: April, we get that.
RYAN: I was asking a legitimate question.
LEMON: Of course it's a legitimate question. And it's very simple answer. She could have said yes, absolutely we believe that slavery is wrong. But she can't.
WISE: Right.
LEMON: She's in a tough spot because she has to defend someone who says that Robert E. Lee put the state over the country at that time.
WISE: Right.
LEMON: I think that's a definition of treason of there.
WISE: Well, it is.
LEMON: Compromise on what? And on both sides. Tim, I know you want to jump in here. But let mow just give you this quote and then you can take it away.
WISE: Right.
LEMON: Historian Frank Curnow writes for the Washington Post "the White House loves a both sides narrative especially one that conceals the vial racism of one side's ideology." Is that the problem here? WISE: That is that the problem. But what's really ironic is you have
John Kelly actually making excuses for a bunch of people who fired and -- fired on and killed hundreds of thousands of men who wore the uniform that he wears now.
It is unbelievably pathetic that a four-star general would make that and to say that the reason we ought not criticize them is because we're using today's moral standards. Excuse me. We have a moral standard going back to the Ten Commandments, it says "Thou shall not steal."
Well, slavery was rooted in kidnapping and the theft of black bodies and black labor. That's not a new moral standard. That's been around since God handed the tablets to Moses. So I think probably John Kelly went to catechism class as a good Catholic boy in Boston. Maybe he needs to refresh his not historical but biblical memory.
LEMON: Why are they trying to whitewash history here?
WISE: Well, I think because they know...
(CROSSTALK)
RYAN: They want history...
WISE: ... that there are people -- there are people in that subset of his support who have always supported that reactionary narrative. And they're pandering to them. I think it is very much about race. It is about playing to that group.
RYAN: Yes.
LEMON: April, I'll give you the last word.
RYAN: Yes. Bottom line, it's about, as Tim said, it's about pandering to that group. But you have to remember, when they pander to that group, there are people that are upset. The NAACP is upset, saying you can't take principals and change them.
You can't -- you can't deal with issues of slavery and talk about a compromise when the compromise, like Mary Frances Berry said, who is a historian and the former head of the U.S. Commission of Civil Rights, she said that in 1860 the compromise was to let southern states have slavery. That was the compromise.
But the south, the confederacy fired on Fort Sumter which started the Civil War.
LEMON: Yes.
RYAN: And we know what happened.
LEMON: Yes.
RYAN: So that was the compromise and the question is does General Kelly realize that was what happened? And if so, what side of history does he really stand on?
Latest Videos

Obama to Jeffries: "You've Got To Figure Out How To Actually Get Sh*t Done With Your Colleagues"
White House
Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Musk: Zelensky Asking To Use Starlink For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Hakeem Jeffries: Musk And Others Behind Trump Administration "Carnage" Will Answer For Their Actions
MSNBC
Bezos: Trump Is The "Most Accessible" President; None Of His Predecessors Were Half As Communicative
World News

Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Victor Davis Hanson: "Bitterness" That Trump "Has To Be Perfect To Be Good" Hurt Republicans In Midterms
Hannity
Camille Paglia on Frat Parties and Consent: "He Is Right to Think You Have Consented"
World News
Musk: Zelensky Asking To Use Starlink For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Trump to Xi: As Long As You And I Are In Charge Of Things, We Will Never Have A Problem
White House
Jennifer Welch: I Want Barron and Tiffany Trump Investigated, "I Want Them To Have Trials"
White House











