Open to Debate: Should We Stop Trusting AI Agents with Our Information?
Last updated 1:44 PM ET
Join the Conversation
0Would you hand a stranger your bank account passwords, access to your private messages, and control over your personal information? What if that stranger were an AI agent like Meta Muse, Claude Duet, or OpenAI Dots?
Unlike a chatbot, AI agents move beyond answering questions to acting independently on our behalf, from managing schedules and making purchases to handling sensitive personal and financial information. But is there such a case as giving over too much control, or are these fears overblown?
Those who believe the privacy issues can be managed argue that AI agents could transform productivity, simplify everyday life, and unlock enormous benefits. Rather than treating AI agents as inherently dangerous, existing laws, competition, and targeted safeguards can address risks without stifling innovation. However, others counter that while convenience can be nice in the short term, it comes at the cost of our privacy, since AI agents require sweeping access to sensitive information. This could potentially undermine account encryption, lead to personal data breaches or exposures, and create new vulnerabilities for hackers.
In partnership with the Masters of Scale Summit, Open to Debate asks: Should We Stop Trusting AI Agents with Our Information?
This debate was recorded live at the Masters of Scale Summit in San Francisco, CA on October 22, 2026, and is followed by a post-debate debrief with Open to Debate’s Moderator-in-Chief, John Donvan.
Featured debaters:
Arguing YES:
Meredith Whittaker, President of Signal
Arguing NO:
Neil Chilson, Head of AI Policy at the Abundance Institute
Jeff Berman, CEO of WaitWhat and Co-Host of Masters of Scale, guest moderates.
Followed by a post-debate debrief with Open to Debate’s Moderator-in-Chief, John Donvan.
Latest Videos

Musk: Zelensky Is Asking To Use Starlink Commercial Satellite System For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Warner: "These Are Not Coordinated Cyber Attacks"--AI Improving Existing Systems Faster Than They Can Handle
MSNBC
Rubio to Press on 'Dirty Bomb' Threat: "Some Of Your Intelligence Sources Are Liars, Others Are Liars And Criminals"
Campaign Ads
Halperin: Government's Cyberattack Response Is A "Dress Rehearsal And A Failure"
Special Report
Bezos: Trump Is The "Most Accessible" President; None Of His Predecessors Were Half As Communicative
World News
Megyn Kelly Reacts To Vance's Iran War Timeline: "They Don't Know How To Get Us Out Of There"
World News

Camille Paglia on Frat Parties and Consent: "He Is Right to Think You Have Consented"
World News
Jennifer Welch: I Want Barron and Tiffany Trump Investigated, "I Want Them To Have Trials"
White House
Megyn Kelly: Republicans Are "No Longer Interested In The Trump Show" And Are "Over The Grift"
World News
Bill Maher To Critics Of Trump Dinner: "I Did It Again, B*tches. You Know What? F*ck You. I Like These Dinners"
Real Time
NC Mom Challenges School Board on LGBTQ Issues: Schools Are "Not a Counseling Session"
Campaign Ads
Gov. Sherrill: Get Rid Of The Electoral College, One Vote In New Jersey Is Worth 1/5 Of A Wyoming Vote
World News











