Warm Porridge at West Point
Published May 29, 2014 • Read time: 4m
In a much-heralded address at West Point on Wednesday, Obama set out to rebut recent criticism of his international policy approach.
Characteristically, he framed the nation's current foreign policy debate as one involving insensible extremes - isolationists on the one hand, and super-hawkish interventionists on the other - with himself in the prudent, reasonable middle.
The interventionists, he suggested, leave the foreign policy porridge too hot. The isolationists leave the porridge too cold. While he, Obama, leaves your porridge just right.
For this, the President's speech was celebrated by supporters such as E.J. Dionne as a triumph of realism and balanced restraint.
To an unusual extent, Obama has always operated on the assumption that if only he can get the rhetorical framework right, major national and international problems will be solved.
If you hadn't been paying close attention to the actual consequences and implementation of Obama's foreign policy and defense decisions over the past five years, you might think the speech sounded pretty good. A realistic, balanced, and prudent American internationalism - what's not to like?
The trouble is, Obama has implemented no such policy.
In one case after another internationally, President Obama has issued verbal declarations or rhetorical statements and then simply refused to back them up in a serious way. The pattern has become so striking as to draw widespread notice internationally.
In Ukraine, Obama warned of dire consequences for Russian aggression, then imposed none, beyond some extremely limited economic sanctions and rhetorical condemnations.
In Syria, the President said that Assad must go, and then drew the famous 'red line' against chemical weapons use, only to enforce neither demand. Now Obama says he will help what is left of Assad's non-jihadist opposition. He has made similar declarations repeatedly over a period several years, and has never truly implemented them.
In Iran, Obama has suggested that all options including U.S. airstrikes remain on the table, but the Iranians have taken his measure and do not believe it. Instead, Iran's President Rouhani is counting on Obama to offer formal U.S. approval of Tehran's nascent nuclear program while dismantling international sanctions against the regime.
In Afghanistan, just the other day Obama correctly warned of the terrible consequences of a Taliban takeover, then announced simultaneously that all U.S. combat troops will be gone from that country by the end of 2016 - a decision very likely to empower the Taliban. The contradiction did not go unnoticed in Afghanistan.
In Iraq, Obama rightly declared the importance of a minimally responsible U.S. presence, then walked away at the end of 2011 with little regret.
Even in the South and East China Seas - part of a region to which America is supposed to have pivoted - local powers wonder if Obama will really support U.S. allies and partners against Chinese intrusions at the end of the day, amidst a flurry of mixed messages from Washington.
Obama's foreign policy isn't just right, and it isn't deliciously warm either - it's lukewarm. It is also like porridge in another way: it's mushy.
When there is little connection between words and actions, or commitments and capabilities, that is neither moderate nor prudent. It's not a balanced reconciliation of opposing extremes. It's just a mess, and one that really does invite international contempt, humiliation and aggression.
The President regularly suggests that the only alternative to his chosen path in any of the above cases is either open warfare involving the United States on the one hand, or isolationism on the other. That is simply not true. A better and more genuinely prudent alternative in addressing every single case just mentioned would be a U.S. President who either backs up their words along with American commitments in a meaningful fashion, or makes no ill-considered declarations they do not intend to keep. This is not completely beyond human capacity, whatever the White House may suggest. But it is just not Obama's style, and it is not his priority. So that will have to wait until 2017.
In the meantime, when it comes to U.S. foreign policy, expect lukewarm porridge for breakfast.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






