David Brooks: Hegseth's Push To Livestream Execution Of Fort Hood Shooter Is "Amoral Beyond Reckoning"
Last updated 9:59 PM ET
PBS NEWSHOUR: David Brooks of The Atlantic and Jonathan Capehart of MS NOW join Amna Nawaz to discuss the week in politics, including the battle for control of Congress.
AMNA NAWAZ, PBS NEWSHOUR: Finally, I want to end on something I know we have all been paying attention to this week, and that is the Pentagon's announcement that it's going to publicly livestream the early December firing squad execution of the convicted Fort Hood mass shooter Nidal Malik Hasan. He killed 13 people. He injured over 30 more in that brutal 2009 attack.
I want to play for you what the defense secretary, Pete Hegseth, had to say on why he thinks it should be broadcast live. Take a listen.
PETE HEGSETH, SECRETARY OF DEFENSE: It was a radical Islamist attack in uniform inside the ranks. And so he's going to get a firing squad of soldiers, as it should be. And we will make sure that people are able to watch it, that it's public, because people need to understand that this is -- there's serious consequences for these types of things.
NAWAZ: Jonathan, this would be the first state-sanctioned public execution in the United States since 1936. What do you make of this?
JONATHAN CAPEHART, MS NOW: It is a grim new chapter in our nation's history.
It used to be that just being sentenced to death was supposed to be the deterrent. And now, according to this administration, no, people need to see it, and maybe that will be a part of the deterrent.
But there's another thing here. This administration has cultivated an atmosphere of menace and violence. We see it all around us, and this will just be yet another manifestation of that. And I would hope that more members of Congress -- and I'm happy to see that there's been a bipartisan outcry over this -- that more people will step forward and say, yes, there needs to be accountability, but this isn't the way to do it.
This does not need to be livestreamed.
DAVID BROOKS, THE ATLANTIC: Saint Augustine was a fifth century, I guess, scholar, theologian, bishop of Hippo.
And he had a friend who went to the Roman Colosseum and could not resist watching the blood of human suffering. And the point of this story, which Augustine tells in I think "The Confessions," is that it is seductive and dehumanizing and degrading to have to watch this.
And so, over the course of Western history, of course, over centuries, people watched people getting drawn and quartered. People watched getting people getting burned to the stake. People watched people getting hung. And they finally discovered that we can make some moral progress by not turning the death of a human being into a something that's degrading for the spectators.
It has a perverse, dehumanizing effect on how they see people ever since. Seeing someone die is a vicious thing. I don't care what the cause is. And you do not walk away from that without having been affected in some really brutal way.
And so the reason we stopped having public executions was this effect, and then it created this perverse circus atmosphere where you got all the flotsam and jetsam of humanity watching this stuff. And so what Hegseth is doing is just -- is amoral beyond -- beyond reckoning.
We make moral progress in this world, and we no longer torture people in public. Yet we seem to be going back to something. So we make moral regression, as well as moral progress.
Latest Videos
In The News

Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Musk: Zelensky Is Asking To Use Starlink Commercial Satellite System For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Hakeem Jeffries: Musk And Others Behind Trump Administration "Carnage" Will Answer For Their Actions
MSNBC
Rubio to Press on 'Dirty Bomb' Threat: "Some Of Your Intelligence Sources Are Liars, Others Are Liars And Criminals"
Campaign Ads
Bezos: Trump Is The "Most Accessible" President; None Of His Predecessors Were Half As Communicative
World News
Most Watched

Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Victor Davis Hanson: "Bitterness" That Trump "Has To Be Perfect To Be Good" Hurt Republicans In Midterms
Hannity
Camille Paglia on Frat Parties and Consent: "He Is Right to Think You Have Consented"
World News
Musk: Zelensky Is Asking To Use Starlink Commercial Satellite System For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Trump to Xi: As Long As You And I Are In Charge Of Things, We Will Never Have A Problem
White House
Jennifer Welch: I Want Barron and Tiffany Trump Investigated, "I Want Them To Have Trials"
White House






