So, Rolling Stone Got it Wrong -- Now What?
Published April 16, 2015 • Read time: 7m
The Rolling Stone story about rape at the University of Virginia has been dissected and retracted, but its targets, like other scandal figures, remain bloody, muddy and desperately in search of vindication.
I have spent my career with individuals and organizations whose lives and businesses have been destroyed by the allegations made against them. I am hired strictly to defuse reputational crises.
Even if a story implodes, as Rolling Stone's did, the wrongly accused -- the Phi Kappa Psi fraternity and Associate Dean of Students Nicole Eramo come to mind -- feel an unyielding need for complete vindication, something that retractions and apologies don't achieve.
I will address how one tries to achieve vindication, but first we have to understand the diagnosis.
People Believe What They Hear
The absence of vindication is not problematic due to mere vanity or insecurity -- although my experience has been that even the most despised scandal figures lack thick skin. It is because most people who hear terrible allegations about a person, organization or product still believe them even after the story has been debunked.
The science in this area is more experiential than empirical, but in my 30-plus years in crisis management, I have found that it is nearly impossible to dislodge a negative perception, even if it is based on faulty grounds. The public does not have the time, energy, motivation, or equipment to undertake the hard work of un-believing a poetic truth. They often default to a vague but unshakeable "Well, I heard something bad about that guy." People passively feel they know enough to determine the difference between good guys and bad guys.
Indeed, a friend who was one of the "good guys" associated with a notorious scandal has told me that he is sometimes mistaken for one of the "bad guys" largely because his name had proximity to some ugly stuff.
I've queried audiences about names like Kleindienst, Kalmbach, Ruckelshaus, Butterfield, Dahlberg, and Richardson. The usual response is, "They were involved with Watergate," even though some of these players were the good guys, others were essentially witnesses, and some did some bad stuff. If you want to know who was who, take the time to do some research. But will you?
The Villain Stands Alone
Every reputational crisis begins with a meeting where someone states the need to "get the facts out." But in these situations, we are not dealing with facts; we are dealing with narrative cascades, powerful stories the public and media need to believe as pattern-seeking creatures. This confirmation bias allows an allegation against such an archetype to be accepted without question.
In his book about cultural villains, “I Wear the Black Hat,” Chuck Klosterman defines a villain as "the person who knows the most but cares the least." Among his examples is former Penn State football coach Joe Paterno. The problem with this example, as we have learned in the three years since the Jerry Sandusky child molestation scandal broke, is that the convenient villains at Penn State were not told the very thing they would have needed to know in order to take the requisite corrective action. Now, the scandal's Inspector Javert, former FBI Louis Freeh, faces multiple lawsuits for defamation surrounding his "Freeh Report" and other investigations.
When evidence against purported villains fails, critics can always fall back on a number of convenient arguments: they "created a culture" that permitted bad behavior; they suffered from a "failure of imagination" by not knowing certain details; or the simple platitude "ignorance is no excuse." While legitimate considerations, no one could survive being held to such a standard. But very few of us are in such positions of authority, so who cares if scandal "villains" get skinned alive?
Complicating matters is something that even highly sophisticated people cannot begin to understand: Scandal principals often cannot say anything in their own defense because of statutory "privacy" laws and the effect their statements may have on pending litigation. Martha Stewart, who faced such criticism when she was accused of securities fraud, was not convicted of insider trading, but rather of making false statements to the authorities. In other words, she got nailed for opening her mouth.
What Can You Actually DO?
To figure out how to manage a reputational crisis, we must first dispense with the misuse of the word "manage." As I say in my book “Glass Jaw: A Manifesto for Defending Fragile Reputations in an Age of Instant Scandal,” you don't really manage your reputation as much as you negotiate to save it, as you would with a kidnapper who has taken someone you love hostage. A public statement filled with buzzwords about being "defamed" by "spurious" charges and "innuendo" cannot dislodge a powerful story.
There are four things any scandal target needs to think about in an environment where narrative cascades can destroy them before they can even get a word in.
1. Defamation lawsuits, once the province of thin-skinned celebrities, are increasingly becoming legitimate tools.
It is hard to win defamation suits because the plaintiff, not the defendant, is the one on trial. It is very hard to prove, as the plaintiff must, that the media defendant acted with "actual malice" -- conspired to destroy someone independent of facts they knew to be false. Nevertheless, reporting such as the Rolling Stone/U-Va. case can be so egregious and so damaging that those who believe they have been vilified are increasingly taking the risk of suing.
U-Va. fraternity Phi Kappa Psi will likely sue Rolling Stone, as may Associate Dean Eramo, accused by the magazine of knowing the most and caring the least.
Apologies and retractions are rarely good enough for the aggrieved since their lives have been ruined and their communities still associate their names with something ugly. Accordingly, radioactive parties search for a verdict or settlement, a legal certification of having been wronged.
2. Seek vindication in alternative media.
As destructive as the Internet has been for reputation management, it also presents an opportunity to leverage alternative media to hedge against mainstream news reports.
In recent years, some of the most resonant stories have been broken by online media and bloggers, including Little Green Footballs exposing CBS's poorly sourced 2004 report on President George W. Bush's alleged attempt to dodge his Vietnam War responsibilities, and KrebsOnSecurity's report on the cyber-breach at Target Stores.
Having had media organizations as clients, I have seen that the once-invincible "mainstream media" are very much concerned about being embarrassed by their putative inferiors in the blogosphere.
3. Mobilize investors in your defense.
One of the first questions I ask a client under siege is to list their natural enemies and allies. Their enemies, I explain, don't want to be educated; they want to attack. They're not viable audiences. If the client is fortunate enough to have allies, put them in the game.
I remain convinced that one of the reasons why Toyota recovered so quickly from the recalls in 2010 is that Toyota customers are deeply loyal to their brand. In addition to the dubious nature of the "sudden acceleration" claims about their vehicles, Toyota drivers fundamentally didn't want Toyota to have a sustained crisis. Accordingly, rather than trying to please the unpleasable pundit class, Toyota fixed their vehicles and offered loyal customers incentive to stick with the brand.
4. Truth takes time and money.
Regrettably, effective crisis management is an unfair discipline. Damage control takes a lot more time and money than most targets have. A company such as Toyota or Target has the resources to invest in recalls and improved cyber-security.
The families of the Duke Lacrosse players wrongly accused of rape in 2006 were wealthy enough to hire attorneys and consultants to fight an overzealous district attorney. Consider your resources before launching a counteroffensive because, sadly, there is a correlation between resources and success.
It's a lot easier to light a forest fire than it is to put one out. That's the bad news about today's reputational crises. One sign of hope is that the proliferation of potential watchdog venues, mostly online, creates opportunities that scandal figures of yesteryear didn't have. Patience, natural allies, and the resources to fight back are key.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






