Philosopher Michael Sandel: The Real AI Threat Is Changing What It Means To Be Human
Last updated 11:30 PM ET
Harvard philosophy professor Michael Sandel says the bigger question about AI is deeper than taking your job or destroying humanity, in this report from Chrystia Freeland in Bloomberg:
MICHAEL SANDEL: We have lots of good reasons to be worried, but the real question is not whether AI will destroy humanity, but whether it will change what it means to be human — whether it will change the way we live together, relate to one another, understand ourselves.
...
Forgetting and losing contact with actual human connection and community, presence, authenticity, being there, not being “Everything Everywhere All at Once.”
The brilliant title of that movie spoke to this utopian aspiration that the power of the virtual will enable us to transcend place and presence and authentic human connection, and will enable us to be everywhere all at once.
I find that a dark vision, not a hopeful utopia, because it leads us away from cultivating the conditions for the human relations that situate us in the world — being present to one another, exploring and challenging our authenticity, engaging in true friendships, not ones generated by bots.
This, I think, is how AI will call into question what it means to be human. And even though we haven’t had a broad public debate about this, I think people sense that this is what’s at stake.
Vanderbilt Chancellor Daniel Diermeier has been spending a lot of time thinking about how AI impacts the way we communicate and learn:
DANIEL DIERMEIER: The goal here is always that the students understand and are able to use technology responsibly, as appropriate for the specific class.
But our goal is to help them develop their own mind, their habits of mind, their ability to think for themselves. And that’s front and center.
The technology needs to be part of that, but that is always the purpose of a transformative education.
But wasn’t Socrates a little bit worried that the written word would wreck our thinking skills and wreck our memory?
DIERMEIER: That’s the perfect example. I think when we see any type of transformative technology happening — like the creation of books through Gutenberg and so forth — the Bible had a transformative impact on society. That’s not the first time. The Industrial Revolution had a transformative impact on society.
And humans will not stop innovating and creating new things, and they will have a transformative impact. Our role as educators and university leaders, and leaders in a broader aspect of society, is to be thoughtful and intentional about that and to combine or integrate technological progress with human flourishing.
...
SANDEL: Well, I would turn the question around.
I think those early worries were not mere superstition, atavistic concerns that were obviously false.
Socrates, who began philosophy in the Western tradition — if he lived at a time of publish or perish, he would have perished, as in fact he did, for corrupting the youth of Athens.
Or take the invention of the printing press. People felt that printing the Bible and making it widely accessible would have theological consequences.
No longer would the hierarchy of the church be able to interpret the meaning of sacred texts.
Now, we say, well, it’s a good thing. Everyone can read for themselves the sacred texts and Scripture. And that is a good thing.
But were they entirely wrong? Or was there a theological transformation that resulted from direct person-to-person access with texts, unmediated by various theological authorities and religious authorities?
So I think we underestimate the insight that those earlier philosophers had who worried about the impact of technology on our humanity if we forget that these technologies did transform the way we understand ourselves, meaning, purpose, even questions of theology.
Notre Dame philosophy professor Meghan Sullivan says we should start thinking about who will take responsibility for the impacts, positive or negative:
MEGHAN SULLIVAN: Capitalism and ethics have always had a complicated relationship, to put it mildly. On the scary side, these companies and our U.S. economy have made massive bets on artificial intelligence.
Some reports say that 2% of our country’s GDP is now invested in building data centers and training powerful AIs. That is a much bigger economic bet on one single piece of technology than we have ever made in the history of our country.
And so we have this feeling that we have to make sure that that bet pays off, which means we had better figure out a way to develop this technology and get it out there in the economy as broadly as possible.
And that might mean that engineers and companies are under so much pressure to respond to the market and investors that they do not have the time to do appropriate ethical discernment and safety. So that’s the scary scenario.
Now, the more optimistic scenario is we have a series of companies who are in this incredibly intense race with one another to be the top dog at the end of this economic transformation. And that means that they have to address a global market of users who are now pretty ethically skeptical of the intentions of tech companies and are pretty discerning.
And so I have some hope that market forces and the consciences of users en masse are going to be able to pressure the tech companies to make decisions, hopefully in enough time to avoid a really major safety incident or a really bad disruption that hurts people’s lives.
All three agree that no matter how it works out, we need to start preparing to understand how AI will change society.
SULLIVAN: There is a widespread feeling that only a very small number of people have ethical responsibility for artificial intelligence right now.
It’s either the handful of corporate executives at big tech companies who are building these products or maybe a handful of regulators in Washington, D.C., who could decide to put laws constraining them.
I think that this is a far too narrow approach to AI ethics.
In fact, a lot of us have agency and decision-making about what kinds of AI we’re going to allow into our workplaces, into our families and social lives, into our schools.
And realizing that you have a lot of say at the moment about how AI affects your day-to-day life is going to be a really important realization for trying to exercise some of our ethical agency about what kind of world we’re going to build with this technology.
It’s in the interests of political powers and corporate powers to make you feel like you’re just along for the ride. You just have to accept whatever decision they make.
That is the wrong mindset.
...
DIERMEIER: Our students, when they graduate, need to be bilingual. This is the task.
They need to be able to have facility with the technologies that are reshaping our lives, and they need to be able to think on their own — to be able to embrace these things, but also understand the limitations, have a critical but not dogmatic point of view on technology, and really the great questions that are confronting our lives.
...
SANDEL: Technology is not just a tool. It’s not an innocent tool. It’s a tool we invent that doubles back on us. Technology is when we invent tools that reshape us.
Latest Videos

Texas Gov.-Elect Hinojosa: I'm An "Economic Populist," "Corporate Interests Have Corrupted Both Parties"
Special Report
Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Musk: Zelensky Is Asking To Use Starlink Commercial Satellite System For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Hakeem Jeffries: Musk And Others Behind Trump Administration "Carnage" Will Answer For Their Actions
MSNBC
Rubio to Press on 'Dirty Bomb' Threat: "Some Of Your Intelligence Sources Are Liars, Others Are Liars And Criminals"
Campaign Ads
Bezos: Trump Is The "Most Accessible" President; None Of His Predecessors Were Half As Communicative
World News

Hemingway: Dems Are Being Transparent About Plans For "Political Payback" Against Trump Allies
FOX News Channel
Victor Davis Hanson: "Bitterness" That Trump "Has To Be Perfect To Be Good" Hurt Republicans In Midterms
Hannity
Camille Paglia on Frat Parties and Consent: "He Is Right to Think You Have Consented"
World News
Musk: Zelensky Is Asking To Use Starlink Commercial Satellite System For Offensive Military Actions
World News
Trump to Xi: As Long As You And I Are In Charge Of Things, We Will Never Have A Problem
White House
Jennifer Welch: I Want Barron and Tiffany Trump Investigated, "I Want Them To Have Trials"
White House






