
Sept 11 Remembrance
The 2022 Hoover State of the Union Poll
Published Feb. 27, 2022 • Read time: 8m
The first of two parts
In January 2021 the Hoover Institution launched a new project: an annual survey on the state of the union. The results of that first poll were summarized by the headline “Amid Our Divide Is Unity Possible?” Our conclusion then was that it wouldn’t be easy, but that it was conceivable, given Americans’ natural sensibilities.
“Overall, the results of our poll show that there are major differences between the political parties that will make it difficult for the newly elected president to bring about unity,” we wrote. “On the other hand, majorities of both parties say they prefer representatives who compromise on politics and would prefer to be American rather than citizens of any other country. Future polls will let us know if we are making any progress toward unity.”
Not surprisingly, one year later our poll (based on a national sample of 1,500 individual respondents) finds a nation still divided, and the president has not brought about unity. As in the 2021 survey we explore three major themes: government power and liberty; social and environmental justice; and populism. In this year’s survey we also examine how Democrat and Republican partisans perceive each other and we examine their friendship patterns: To what extent are polarization and partisanship affected by personal relationships?
Power vs. Liberty
A majority of Republicans and Republican-leaning voters believe that government overregulates business – 57 percent compared to less than 10 percent for Democrats. A majority of Republicans oppose increasing the minimum wage to $15 per hour, compared to less than 10 percent of Democrats. On the issues of whether government should raise taxes on those making over $250,000 per year or should limit the amount that CEOs of companies can earn, only 37 percent and 43 percent of Republicans, respectively, favor these policies, while in both instances over 70 percent of Democrats agree with tax increases and limiting pay.
Table 2 shows similar partisan divisions on issues regarding personal freedom. Four of five Democrats agree that assault weapons like AK47s should be banned, contrasted with only 30 percent of Republicans. Also, 86 percent of Democrats think schools and businesses should be allowed to require masks; less than 50 percent of Republicans agree to such limits. Meanwhile, one-third of Republicans say they will not be vaccinated compared to only 5 percent of Democrats. One area where unity appears to be growing is that more Americans now agree that the virus is endemic and we have to live with it. More Republicans agree with this statement, but Democrats and Democratic-leaners are coming to this view even as Democratic governors are starting to lift shutdown orders and loosen masking requirements.
As in the 2021 survey, the exception to freedom of choice comes on the abortion issue, with 82 percent of Democrats agreeing that abortion should always or generally be available. This compares to only about one-third of Republicans. In part, this anomaly can be attributed to differences between the parties on religious practices, with Republicans being both more observant than Democrats and more likely to be members of churches that are anti-abortion. Republicans, by ratios of over 2-1, identify as born-again Christians.
Social and Environmental Justice
The 2022 Hoover poll also asked how Americans feel about racial justice, climate change, migrant laws, removing statues of former icons, affirmative action, and other current issues. They, too, illustrate the country’s partisan divide. Democrats favor affirmative action for college admission, removing statues of Confederate generals, and allowing illegal immigrants to stay in the U.S. and apply for citizenship, and they agree that global warming is a very serious problem. As Table 3 shows, on each of these topics, Republicans are on the other side.
There are some areas regarding the criminal justice system where partisans find common ground. Majorities of both parties agree that statues of slave-owning U.S. presidents such as George Washington and Thomas Jefferson should not be taken down. A majority of both parties (63 percent of Republicans and 89 percent of Democrats) agree that some racial groups in the United States are discriminated against. Moreover, a majority of both parties agree that African Americans, Hispanics, and Asians are discriminated against. The major difference between the parties in this area is that a little over three-fifths of Republicans believe that white people are also discriminated against, while only one-sixth of Democrats think that’s true.
Populism
The poll’s third theme, populism, is not unique to the United States. France, Italy, Spain, Poland, Hungary, Britain, The Netherlands, and Argentina, among other countries, have populist movements and political parties. Populism here is defined as a belief in a “people” that has been ill-served by an influential elite class that has governed badly.
Table 4 shows that Democrats and Republicans share several populist views. Majorities of both parties agree that the federal government is run by a few big interests (although they may disagree on who those interests are), that quite a few of the people running government are crooked, and that nothing they do has any effect on what happens in politics.
The only two populist propositions where there are differences are in the questions regarding whether politicians lie about what they will do if elected and whether they are dissatisfied about how democracy in America works. Even here, in both cases the Democrats are at 47 and 45 percent agreeing with the Republicans, and both numbers for the Democrats are the modal.
Table 4 includes Independents as a separate category, because in many surveys Independents tend to be even more populist than the partisans. A majority agree with each of the five populist assertions and in each case are closer to the Republican position than to the Democratic position, which may give the Republicans a boost in the midterm elections.
Confidence in Institutions
As confirmed in numerous surveys, trust in institutions is low and declining. In the Hoover poll the only American institution which received an overall 60 percent confidence rating (having a lot or some confidence) was the police. The major difference between this year’s survey and last is that in this poll 57 percent of Democrats expressed some or a lot of confidence in the police, while in 2021 they expressed very little confidence.
No other institution reached the 50 percent mark. The judiciary, churches, local and state governments, and public schools and universities were all between 40 and 49 percent confidence levels. Congress, corporations, the media, unions, and the United Nations all have less than 40 percent approval, and the Congress and corporations are below 30 percent.
Yet Table 5 shows that even here there is little common ground between Republicans and Democrats over which institutions they have the least confidence in. One fascinating exception is the police.
The only institution which majorities in both parties believe in is law enforcement, with 57 percent of Democrats and 76 percent of Republicans showing confidence in the police. This is a significant jump in support for the police from the 2021 survey, where less than 50 percent of Democratic respondents had confidence. This shift may well be related to recent increases in violence and, consequently, the fading appeal of the “defund the police” movement.
There are major divides between the parties on confidence in universities (Democrats 69-Republicans 29), unions (62-21), the media (52-11), the United Nations (60-22), public schools (64-30), and churches and organized religion (42-63). Partisan differences over confidence in the judiciary and state and local government are smaller and range from 12 points on the judiciary to less than 10 on state and local government.
These differences in support for institutions raise a serious question: In the long run, how stable can institutions such as universities be if only one political party trusts them? We cannot do in-depth analyses across all institutions in one survey, but in future work we plan to extend the analysis of unipolar support for institutions like universities.
Summary
The divide between the two parties has not subsided over the first year of the Biden presidency. The president has support levels close to the Trump average, and Republicans and Democrats continue to differ on the role of government in everyday Americans’ lives. These differences range from government regulation of business to COVID protocols and issues of social and environmental justice. There is, as was the case in 2021, agreement between the parties that the federal government is not working for the people. However, when the two parties want such different things, getting them done is harder, and thus populist sentiment increases. The defund the police movement seems to have run its course, as more than twice as many Democrats now have confidence in the police as was the case a year ago. In sum, still divided.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






