
Trump
Trump vs. Trump
COMMENTARY
Published Oct. 19, 2026 • Read time: 7m
Donald Trump and Democrats agree on one thing: The midterm elections are about Donald Trump. The president seems to think this will work for Republicans – he keeps urging voters to pretend he is on the ballot. But this may be a serious miscalculation that will damage the GOP, Trump’s legacy, and ultimately our country.
The polls suggest the midterms will be a Democratic rout. Republicans respond by pointing to flawed polls during this year’s primaries and observing that Trump always outperforms polls. They note that even modest errors could mean Republicans will fend off a meltdown. But spending decisions being made by national political action committees, Trump’s campaign schedule, and his weak job approval ratings (38% approval vs. 60% disapproval in the RCP averages) tell a different story.
Conversely, gerrymandering and court decisions have reduced the number of contested congressional districts, and there are some signs of improvement in the GOP‘s Senate prospects as voters focus on the candidates. Most Democratic advantages are within the margin of error.
At a minimum, Republicans are having a rough go of it, and it didn’t have to be this way. For Republicans to prevail, the election will have to be about performance, not personality.
The Trump administration has done an exemplary job implementing its campaign promises: restoring free speech, freedom of religion, and individual liberties; closing the border and deporting illegal aliens; deregulating business; curtailing the green agenda and challenging transgender delusions; supporting law and order; boosting U.S. manufacturing, energy production and jobs; strong-arming Europe to contribute to its defense; backing Israel, containing Iran, pursuing fair international trade; uncovering nearly $230 billion of government fraud; and reducing the size of government.
The administration contained inflation bequeathed by the Biden presidency, while presiding over a reduction of the nation’s poverty rate to the lowest since recordkeeping began in 1959 – including for children and Hispanics – and the steepest decline in violent crime ever recorded. Trump made good on his promise to extend the 2017 tax cuts, instituted no tax on tips or overtime for qualifying workers, increased the standard tax deduction, and fostered record high U.S. energy production.
Contrast all that with increasingly radical Democrat candidates and goals that seldom receive majority support from Americans, including Democrats. These include open borders, defunding or reducing policing, cashless bail, censorship, opposition to voter ID and citizenship requirements, transwomen (men) in girls’ and women’s sports, sex-reassignment surgery for minors – hidden from their parents, pervasive DEI, larger government, and aggressive climate mandates that raise costs.
The growing far left includes self-avowed communists who want to dismantle our Constitution; eliminate borders, the Pentagon, most prisons and private industry; support Iran; and replace Israel with a Palestinian state. For the most part, they are joined by Islamists, who also advocate Sharia law. In other countries these ideologies have led to the abolition of civil rights, and caused mass imprisonments and death.
So, how did we get here?
First, Trump Derangement Syndrome. Democrats, and even some Republicans, misunderstand or intentionally mischaracterize Trump’s wit, forceful speech, and goals. And to be sure, Trump has given grist to his detractors. He is disloyal, often caustic, and a world-class narcissist.
He threatened the survival of the Kennedy Center because he was unable to add his name to the institution or its building. The courts correctly ruled that only Congress could authorize that vanity plate.
It is only marginally less odious that he renamed a State Department agency the Donald J. Trump Institute of Peace, and that he refers to new tax-advantaged investment accounts as Trump Accounts, the government’s website for discount drugs as TrumpRx, a Treasury website as TrumpIRA.gov, fast-track immigration visas as Trump Gold Cards, a proposed (unnecessary) class of battleships as Trump-class, and the transit corridor between Armenia and Azerbaijan as the Trump Route for International Peace.
Trump caused the government to issue coins, passports, and National Park Service passes with his image, and he will be the first president whose signature will be on paper currency. Renaming the Gulf of Mexico and Lake Ontario, or potentially the Atlantic or Pacific oceans, is only somewhat less obnoxious because he hasn’t included his name – yet.
Taking Maria Corina’s Machado’s Nobel prize was infantile. Building the new ballroom is a good idea, but 90,000 square feet that dwarfs the White House is not. Adding gold gilding throughout the White House is beyond gaudy. We don’t need a Trump Arch.
I favor military action to contain Iran’s nuclear threat, offensive weapons, and terror network. But the podium of the United Nations General Assembly is not the place to threaten the annihilation of a member state. Likewise, despite being correct on the merits, starting a spat with a popular pope was malpractice.
Incessantly trolling Canada about becoming the 51st state contributed to the defeat of a pro-American candidate for prime minister, and threatening to seize Greenland achieved nothing we couldn’t have achieved by just asking.
This president’s vitriol, vanity, and immaturity makes most Americans shudder. A chief executive with Trump’s tremendous achievements should not be so concerned with recognition. Unless the polls are very wrong or voters change course, we will all pay the price for his lack of impulse control.
Second, many Americans (wrongly) oppose Trump’s attack on Iran, and are (rightly) confused by, or oppose, his puzzling tactics since ending major combat operations.
Many Americans also fret about increases in oil and fertilizer prices resulting from that conflict, and the knock-on effect on inflation. Trump has spent little time talking about affordability. Blasting Joe Biden – again – is not the same as describing the progress his administration has made and will continue to make, despite the Iran situation.
Third, funded in significant part by the Chinese Communist Party, Democrats successfully demonized ICE’s deportation mission.
Finally, about 40% of voters generally disagree with GOP policies. That is the core Democratic constituency baked into every election.
Pollsters used to ask which candidate voters would want to have a beer with. The question was about relatability. Compared to “the Squad,” the new crop of radical left candidates avoids theatrics. They appear more mainstream. They might be fun to hang out with.
But it’s reckless to choose a direction for the nation based on a popularity contest, to accept Democrat or media (redundant, I know) characterizations, or to punish Trump’s sarcasm. Trump is not on the ballot and regardless of the outcome, he will continue to govern by executive order. The real issue is what happens after Trump.
If Democrats take control of the House of Representatives, they will impeach Trump and ensure his policies remain easily reversed executive orders. If they take the Senate, they will block confirmation of judges who believe in the Constitution, and treaties that improve trade and security. Acting in concert with blue state governments, they will prepare for another round of lawfare.
If the next president is a Democrat, the party will use unified control to re-open our borders, create two new Democrat-majority states, change the Supreme Court’s jurisdiction, pack the court, and end the Senate filibuster, thereby threatening a grand experiment that has advanced personal liberty, economic opportunity, and multiculturalism like no other society in history. American Exceptionalism will be replaced by an ideology that has ossified Europe, and spectacularly failed every time it has attained power.
To avoid that outcome, conservatives and moderates have to vote. And they must vote based on policies and ideology, not personalities.
Support Our Mission
The Internet provides an endless stream of content. Not all of it is worth your time. That's why, every day, RealClearPolitics curates the most essential news and information—from all sides and across mediums. The links, videos, and podcasts curated here are the product of human judgment, not algorithms or AI. Please help power our mission of presenting a thoughtful, balanced public discourse through a tax-deductible donation.
Would you consider supporting us today?
Contributing to RealClear Politics through the RealClear Media Foundation supports essential initiatives that drive meaningful change.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






