GOP Must Own Immigration Reform
Published March 27, 2013 • Read time: 4m
It is not enough for the Republican Party to acquiesce in a bipartisan bill for immigration reform. The scars its image bears in the Latino community run too deep for that. Republicans need to get out in front on the issue. Immigration reform needs to be a Republican bill. Only then can we hope to heal the scars left from the party's role in scuttling reform in 2005-2006.
Latinos, remember, were on the verge of voting Republican after 2004, when Bush almost carried them against John Kerry. But then the courtship blew up in their face when their base killed immigration reform. That failure to pass reform in 2005-2006 led directly to the loss of the Senate in 2006 and the election of Obama in 2008. And then to his re-election in 2012. It qualifies as one of the major blunders in Republican history. Now is the time to correct it before our party becomes exiled to a footnote in history.
But how? Here, a strange but important political dynamic takes shape. The only interesting story in Washington as the immigration reform bill goes through Congress will be whether the GOP leadership -- Speaker John Boehner -- will be able to whip his troops into line to pass the bill. Obama, Reid and the Democrats are a sideshow here. The question hanging over the debate is will a grassroots, talk-radio led rebellion beat immigration reform as it did President George W. Bush's attempts to pass the bill in 2005-2006.
But rank and file Republican voters are in a very different place now than they were then. John McLaughlin's February 2013 survey of 500 likely Republican voters shows deep and broad support for immigration reform. He found that 66 percent backed it conceptually and that support swelled to 75 percent when Republicans heard the specifics of the Rubio bill. So, when the sides are drawn for the intra-party debate upon which the bill's fate hinges, we can count on the base to back the bill, not to scuttle it.
Here, the very difficulty of the job of winning Republican votes will serve to focus attention on the changing attitudes of Republicans toward the issue. Now will be the chance for Republican leaders, in Congress and outside, to stand up and persuade their partisans that it is time to pass the bill. And, in the process, they will win a new opportunity to get the Latinos they lost the last time.
It matters less how long the wait is for citizenship or what extra border security is required in the bill, the key to its success in healing the breach between Latinos and Republicans is that it forthrightly will allow those who came here illegally to stay and to work if they have no criminal record.
Remember what happened in 1964. Republican Minority Leader Everett Dirksen commanded center stage as he rounded up the GOP votes for cloture on the Civil Rights Bill. Eventually, he got all but six Republican Senators to vote to end the filibuster. But then, Barry Goldwater -- one of the six -- got the Republican nomination, Johnson made the bill the issue of the campaign, and blacks have voted Democrat ever since.
Mindful of that history, we need Speaker Boehner and RNC Chairman Reince Priebus to stand up loudly and strongly for immigration reform and to become the poster boys for the change in the Republican Party. They need to proclaim that the GOP welcomes immigrants, thanks those who have come here to help build our economy and wants them to reinvigorate our capitalist, free enterprise, individual entrepreneurialism. They need to stress that Democratic policies of debt and handouts threaten to recreate the situations in their former nations that caused them to flee to the land of opportunity -- America.
COPYRIGHT 2013 DICK MORRIS AND EILEEN MCGANN
DISTRIBUTED BY CREATORS.COM
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






