
Will Romney's Strengths Prove Moot Against Obama?
Published Jan. 31, 2012 • Read time: 5m
Join the Conversation
0Mitt Romney is winning the GOP race for two reasons: big money and weak competition. That should distress Republicans. Romney cannot rely on either advantage if he faces Barack Obama.
Winning early primaries should frame front-runners as winners. They should convey an aura of inevitability and electability. Romney is likely to blow away the competition in Florida tonight. But even that victory will provide scant evidence he can do the same to Obama.
Romney is not winning the GOP primary. The opposition is losing it.
Romney is not courting voters with a winning message. He’s overwhelming the airwaves with his message.
And what’s the message Romney will leave Floridians with? It’s not why Romney is good. It’s why his competition is bad. Over the past week, from Monday to Monday, Kantar Media estimates that more than nine-in-10 political television ads on the air in the Sunshine State were negative.
Romney has carpet-bombed the early primary states with advertising. In Florida alone, pro-Romney groups outspent pro-Gingrich groups by a nearly 5-to-1 ratio. Some estimate more. Kantar reports Romney and his allies spent $12 million on Florida ads compared to $1.8 million, spent by Gingrich and his allies, as of Sunday. Fox News’ “Special Report” cited a ratio nearer to 3-to-1, $17.8 million compared to $5.4 million. Regardless of the precise figures, Romney is overwhelming Gingrich on the airwaves. He would be lucky to match Obama dollar-for-dollar in a general election.
Romney’s recovery in the GOP race is, however, owed to more than money. Gingrich briefly led in Florida after South Carolina. Yet Romney owned the airwaves then too. Pro-Romney groups aired ads almost 13,000 times on broadcast television across the state compared to about 200 times by pro-Gingrich groups, as of Wednesday, according to the Wesleyan Media Project. But Gingrich was still then in contention.
The Florida difference was dollars and Gingrich. The former House speaker has relied on the free media from debates to offset Romney’s advantage in paid media. But Gingrich lost on both accounts in Florida.
South Carolina told another tale. Romney groups outspent Gingrich groups by about a 2-to-1 ratio in the state. Romney had seemingly won small in Iowa (we later learned he lost small) and won big New Hampshire. He came into South Carolina ahead in the polls. He had the Big Mo.
Then came the debates. Gingrich not only bested Romney, he provided sound bites -- attacking political correctness and an elite media -- that were looped from talk radio to cable news. It was prime red meat. And Republicans ate it up. On Election Day, Gingrich trounced Romney among conservatives. He also nearly split the minority of voters who identified as moderate or liberal. He won religious and secular alike. In other words, Gingrich proved more than a mere Romney alternative.
That Newt Gingrich did not show up in the Florida debates. He has won conservatives in recent months because he appeared the capable combatant. But he flailed in Florida. And shrunk. There was CNN’s Wolf Blitzer asking Gingrich about his past criticism of Romney’s tax disclosures. Gingrich attempted to be Gingrich-esque: dodge with a dig at the moderator. Only Blitzer pushed back. And Romney soon said: “Wouldn’t it be nice if people didn’t make accusations somewhere else that they weren’t willing to defend here?”
The Florida debates went that way for Gingrich. He was reduced to excuses. On Friday, fresh off the two debate losses, he complained about Romney’s “factually incorrect” statements. By Monday, he was on CNN with this excuse: “The reason I seemed flat in the second debate in Florida is I have never seen a candidate for president that methodically dishonest.” Meanwhile, Gingrich and aides complained to reporters about why they lost the debates. For debate one, the audience was silenced. For debate two, the audience was stacked against him. Gingrich, the historian, should know where the buck stops.
These anecdotes never matter in isolation. But they combine into a storyline. And that story helps undermine Gingrich as an alternative to Romney because it undercuts Gingrich's strength. Namely, his image of strength. Gingrich now looks like a bully, black-eyed and backing off. He didn’t help matters by shooting for the moon. He proposed a lunar colony in these austere times. Really, he did. And then there was the GOP establishment. Bob Dole et al. pummeled Gingrich’s past. This was the story across the media for the past week. Not Gingrich the strong but Gingrich the weak. He was the worst incarnation of his old Washington self -- unhinged, mercurial and deflated. Could Romney’s camp hope for more?
Romney appears significantly stronger than Gingrich in a general election. Yet he still must get there and prove he can do more than survive a war of attrition against flawed GOP opponents.
Romney has not yet overcome his primary obstacles. His vote share in Iowa was roughly the same in 2008 and 2012. His New Hampshire margin of victory was large, in part, because the conservative electorate was divided. His unfavorable rating is ticking up in national polls. Romney wants to pivot. Gingrich won’t let him.
Gingrich remains a contender for the nomination. He retains considerable conservative support, particularly among men and older voters. Gingrich had an awful week. Nevertheless, he will walk out of Florida with somewhere between a quarter and a third of the vote.
Conservative ranks have known Gingrich as a strongman for too long. In their eyes, he is not redefined by one weak week. Gingrich is likely to follow the southern road and contest Romney through spring.
That’s the bite of Romney’s likely victory tonight. In the general election, Republicans will face a more practiced, more disciplined and equally financed opponent. Gingrich should be the easy part. Yet it will remain hard. Gingrich is not going away. On money and performance, we have seen how one Republican after another can lose the race. Romney still has to prove he can win it.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






