Is There a State-National Polling Discrepancy?
Published June 29, 2016 • Read time: 2m
Join the Conversation
0Elections Analyst David Byler and I have both noted an apparent discrepancy between state and national polls, with Donald Trump seemingly running better in the former than the latter. We’ve both posited possible explanations for this.
One thing that occurred to me since then: What if there isn’t a discrepancy? The swing state polling is closer than we’d expect, given the national polling, but is the overall picture really skewed?
I decided to test this out. I took the RealClearPolitics polling averages for the various states and, when averages were not available, I looked at polls conducted in the last 60 days (when available). I then took a population-weighted average of these polls—in other words, I made it so that the polls from California counted more than the polls from Arizona, according to the states’ relative population.
The results? Hillary Clinton led Trump in the population-weighted average by 5.5 percentage points. This is similar to her 6.2-point lead in the national polls.
This methodology isn’t perfect, because we don’t have polling from every state. If you weight the “missing” states by their Partisan Voting Index, they do have a slight pro-Republican bias of about two points, which would suggest a modest discrepancy overall.
But even this marginal difference is tempered by three factors: First, the states that have not been polled are disproportionately smaller states, accounting for only one-third of the country’s population. If you include estimates for these states based upon their PVIs, and weight by population, the overall picture moves just a little more than a point (net) toward Trump.
Second, the PVI-based estimates might overstate Trump’s performance in the state polls, as Trump has tended to run behind 2012 nominee Mitt Romney in red states. So even this modest shift could be wrong. Third, as I suggested earlier this week, state polling tends to come out more slowly than national polling at this stage of the race. So a lot of the state polling comes from a time when Trump was doing somewhat better in national polling than he is today.
So I think we have to say that the overall picture painted by the state poll averages isn’t materially different from the picture painted by national poll averages. Instead, for now, the Trump-Clinton matchup seems to be weakening the recent hyper-polarized red-blue map.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






