
A group of Donald Trump supporters heckles protestors in front of the Alumisource plant in Monessen, Pa., where the Republican candidate stopped for a tour of the facility, Tues., June 28, 2016. Trump drew a crowd of supporters and protesters alike. (John Rucosky/The Tribune-Democrat via AP) MANDATORY CREDIT
How Not to Win Pennsylvania
Published June 30, 2016 • Read time: 4m
For the past quarter-century, Pennsylvania has been the Great White Whale for the GOP in presidential contests. It’s always in sight, but ultimately stays Democratic, as it has now done in six consecutive elections dating back to 1992. Donald Trump has focused on the Keystone State as part of a Rust Belt strategy for victory. If he is to lose Sunbelt states with growing minority populations, he’ll need states like Pennsylvania to give him an Electoral College majority.
His speech in western Pennsylvania this past week threatening withdrawal from NAFTA, opposition to a new trade pact with Pacific Rim countries and sanctions against China for currency manipulation represents a rejection of a longstanding bipartisan consensus on the benefits of trade and an attempt to capitalize on the forces that propelled the Brexit vote in Great Britain. This economic nationalism is troubling especially because America’s problems stem from a lack of economic growth under the centralized planning approach of the Obama administration. Increased trade barriers will only make growth more difficult to achieve.
But his speech is also an attempt to win Pennsylvania’s electoral votes. Sadly it’s misguided. Republicans have made strides with blue-collar cultural conservatives going back at least to the beginning of this century and have improved their margins in many western Pennsylvania counties even compared to Ronald Reagan’s successful campaigns. The Obama administration’s devotion to climate change and cultural liberalism guaranteed that. These are the people who cling to their God and guns. There is no reason to think they will suddenly embrace Hillary Clinton, whose views in these areas are in sync with Obama’s.
But the change in these voters’ attitudes has not been sufficient to bring Pennsylvania into the GOP fold. This is because their numbers are not increasing. As with the past few elections, we can expect that Trump to carry most counties in western and central Pennsylvania by healthy margins. The problem isn’t in the west among blue-collar workers who have Democratic roots. The problem is in the east among voters with Republican roots, especially women.
In 1980, Reagan was able to offset massive Democratic majorities in Philadelphia by winning large GOP majorities in four Philadelphia suburban counties -- Montgomery, Delaware, Chester and Bucks. He won those by over 200,000 votes, more than enough to neutralize Democratic majorities in the city of Philadelphia. President George H.W. Bush also won these counties in 1988.
Since then, the Eastern suburbs have changed and so has the GOP. Republicans continued to roll up large majorities in the rural central part of the state and have added cultural conservatives in the West, but the Philadelphia suburbs now contain large numbers of ancestral Republicans, many now Independent, with college degrees, white-collar jobs and higher than average incomes. Mitt Romney lost these suburbs by 100,000 votes in 2012. These are the voters, especially women, that Trump is having problems with nationwide. A broadside against international trade won’t do much to help him raise his vote totals among critical suburban voters.
This is not different from his task in other suburban rich states that should be winnable for Republicans, such as Virginia, Florida, Colorado, and other Rust Belt states including Ohio and possibly Wisconsin and Michigan. The key to winning these states has always been to bring nonaligned suburban voters back to their GOP home with a positive message focusing on jobs and economic growth. A far better governing model is to focus on an optimistic message to seize the many future opportunities America has, not on empty promises to restore the past.
Trade, technology advancement, educational excellence and tax reform are some of the positive messages that have far more bandwidth than building economic and border walls. That’s true in Pennsylvania and also for the country at large.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






