
GOP Rivals Take Their Swings at Gingrich
Published Dec. 16, 2011 • Read time: 7m
SIOUX CITY, Iowa -- In the final debate before voting begins early next month in the Republican presidential primary, each of seven major candidates faced challenges to his or her biggest weaknesses Thursday night from a panel of four Fox News moderators.
Is Mitt Romney tough enough to take the fight to President Obama? Can Newt Gingrich overcome the charge that he is unreliable? Is Rick Perry skilled enough to debate President Obama? Among the other perceived candidate vulnerabilities explored: Ron Paul is too far outside the mainstream; Rick Santorum, who lines up with staunch conservatives, can’t break through; Jon Huntsman is too moderate; and Michele Bachmann is too conservative.
The mini-narratives have emerged over the past months as the field took shape, and they collectively have kept any single candidate from becoming the consensus choice to be the GOP nominee.
While Romney has remained relatively steady as either the front-runner or a runner-up, Gingrich is the latest to ride a burst of momentum to the head of the pack. And so just this week Romney and his campaign pushed into a higher gear, blasting Gingrich for his “zany” ideas and for profiting handsomely from advising the quasi-governmental housing giant Freddie Mac. They also bashed Gingrich as too close to former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, a Democrat, for conservative comfort.
Addressing the criticism as the debate began, Gingrich said, “I have a 90 percent American Conservative Union voting record for 20 years. I balanced the budget for four straight years, paid off $405 billion in debt. Pretty conservative. The first . . . entitlement reform of your lifetime -- in fact, the only major entitlement reform until now -- was welfare [a major piece of legislation he saw through into law in 1996 as House speaker]. Two out of three people went back to work or went to school. Pretty conservative. First tax cut in 16 years, largest capital gains tax cut in American history, unemployment came down to 4.2 percent.”
Later, he joked, trying to play down Romney’s assertion to the New York Times Wednesday that he’s “zany,” “I sometimes get accused of using language that's too strong, so I've been standing here editing. I'm very concerned about not appearing to be zany.”
Numerous attacks surfaced during the debate from the moderators and the other candidates, turning Gingrich into a punching bag for a healthy portion of the two-hour affair.
Michele Bachmann, who is trying desperately to regain the momentum she briefly enjoyed in the Hawkeye State, led the charge. She pummeled Gingrich for campaigning for Republicans who support partial-birth abortion, calling that a “seminal issue” and something the party cannot get wrong.
Gingrich accused the Minnesota congresswoman of inaccuracy and said, “I believe that life begins at conception.” He added, “I am against any kind of experimentation on embryos. And I think my position on life actually has been very clear and very consistent.”
But the two tussled more, earning Gingrich a slap from Bachmann for his repeated assertion that she was inaccurate.
“I think it's outrageous to continue to say over and over through the debate that I don't have my facts right, when as a matter of fact, I do,” she said. “I'm a serious candidate for president of the United States, and my facts are accurate.”
Bachmann continued: “Speaker Gingrich said that he would actively support and campaign for Republicans who got behind the barbaric practice of partial-birth abortions. This is not a small issue. This is a big issue.” His retort was that it was unwise to root out Republicans when leaders trying to govern the party should try to be attracting a wide range of support.
Gingrich also defended himself when Bachmann and Ron Paul insisted that the consulting work he did for Freddie Mac -- to the tune of $1.6 million -- was in fact lobbying and, additionally, wrong in light of the home loan corporation’s massive losses. Bachmann accused the former speaker of wanting to keep the lender afloat.
“First, my policy is to break up both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. It is not anything like what she just described,” Gingrich said. “Second, I want to state unequivocally, for every person watching tonight, I have never once changed my positions because of any kind of payment. Because I -- the truth is, I was a national figure who was doing just fine, doing a whole variety of things, including writing best-selling books, making speeches. And the fact is, I only chose to work with people whose values I shared, and having people have a chance to buy a house is a value I believe still is important in America.”
Gingrich did not engage in any heated exchanges with Romney, even though the former Massachusetts governor has turned up the heat on him this week. At one point, he said he wasn’t in the business of blaming Romney.
But Romney adviser Eric Fehrnstrom said after the debate that he thought Gingrich “spent a lot of time talking about dates in history and sounded like he was trying to win tenure, not the presidency.”
Predictably, Fehrnstrom said he thought his candidate turned in a solid performance and appeared presidential. Another Romney adviser, Stuart Stevens, told reporters that although Gingrich has performed well in each of the debates and has risen in the polls as a result, “He doesn’t have a favorable trajectory now.”
And that may explain why Romney steered clear of risk-taking during the debate. He chose not to attack his opponents, in particular Gingrich, with anything new. Instead, he rattled off the same lines he’s used since launching his candidacy in early June: That he has spent his life in the private sector, that he’s led multiple enterprises, and that he knows how the economy works.
It allowed him to offer one of the clearest defenses of his message: “Our president thinks America is in decline. It is if he's president; it's not if I am.”
And yet, here in Iowa, that message has not taken off. Asked by RCP if Romney would be in Iowa on the night of the caucuses to celebrate the outcome or if he would be campaigning in New Hampshire, Fehrnstrom said the schedule is not set yet but that Romney would return to Iowa before the caucuses.
Though relatively unscathed for the duration of the debate, Romney did come under fire from Rick Santorum on gay marriage.
The former Pennsylvania senator alleged that Romney sided with the Massachusetts courts that had ruled on the legalization of gay marriage and faulted him for granting marriage licenses. Romney, looking incredulous, said he had no choice in the matter. And he pointed out that he testified in Washington in favor of a federal marriage amendment.
Left untouched in the debate was Rick Perry, who joked that after a string of poor debates, he was finally starting to like them and was looking forward to debating President Obama. The three-term Texas governor said he hoped to be the Tim Tebow of the Iowa caucuses.
By contrast, Paul took a beating from Bachmann over how to handle the nuclear threat in Iran, saying that his position was another reminder of how far outside the conservative wing of the GOP his thinking is. He complained that Washington is overreacting to the threat and that he is not interested in starting a war like the one that just ended in Iraq.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






