
Cruz-Rubio Rivalry Deepens as Both Rise in GOP Race
Published Dec. 4, 2015 • Read time: 5m
Join the Conversation
0As they rise together in national polls, Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz are seeking ways to use each other to break away from the pack and ultimately stand alone.
With Donald Trump still leading in national and early state polls and Ben Carson fading, the spotlight is on the number two spot in the race for the GOP presidential nomination. While each is competing in his own lane -- Cruz as the conservative consolidator and Rubio as the establishment’s consensus candidate -- each has a vested interest in exploiting the other’s vulnerabilities.
Cruz has made significant strides on his way to becoming conservatives’ choice, as would-be rivals for this segment, including Mike Huckabee, Rick Santorum, Bobby Jindal and Scott Walker, have either failed to gain traction or dropped out of the race all together.
And this week, a new Quinnipiac University poll showed Carson, whose appeal to evangelicals made him a top competitor for Cruz, dropped seven points after national security and foreign policy issues came into prominence on the campaign trail. Cruz’s camp believes Carson will continue to fade and that the Texas senator will continue to reap the benefits of his demise. What’s more, Cruz has built a well-organized and durable campaign, with competitive plans beyond the early states and well into the southern Super Tuesday primaries.
“If we nominate another candidate in the mold of Bob Dole or John McCain or Mitt Romney, the Democrats will win,” Cruz said Thursday at the Republican Jewish Coalition conference in Washington, attended by all the presidential candidates. Conservatives would stay home, he argued.
Cruz is hoping to cast Rubio in that mold. The problem for him, however, is that the Florida senator doesn’t neatly fit into it. In fact, some conservatives have praised the notion of the GOP race boiling down to Cruz vs. Rubio. The fact that they are leading contenders is a “tremendous testament to what conservatives have been able to achieve,” Heritage Action CEO Mike Needham told the National Review.
And much of Rubio’s candidacy depends on something of a different mold altogether: the candidate who is not only acceptable but also compelling to both conservatives and establishment Republicans alike. Part of his strategy involves promoting his conservative credentials on foreign policy and national security while toning down his chief liability among the party’s base on immigration. And this effort is being made at the expense of Cruz, whom Rubio is trying to portray as a moderate on foreign policy and not so different from himself on immigration.
In many ways, the rivalry underscores party divides on key issues in the primary and general election, from immigration reform to national defense. And while the two men have many things in common -- both are sons of Cuban immigrants, both are in their first term in the Senate and were elected with Tea Party support -- their candidacies represent two paths for the GOP: a purist who can galvanize conservative forces or a candidate with broader appeal for a general election matchup with Hillary Clinton.
While Cruz has already made strides in shoring up his lane, Rubio still has competition. Jeb Bush, Chris Christie and John Kasich are vowing to stay in the race at least through New Hampshire. While Rubio leads these rivals in recent national polls, and has earned a slew of endorsements from congressional colleagues as well as wealthy financial backers, there has been little consolidation thus far among the establishment bloc.
Still, this isn’t stopping Cruz from defining Rubio as the quintessential establishment figure. This week, he characterized his Senate colleague as a K Street crony. In an interview with Fox News’ Sean Hannity, Cruz blasted the “Washington cartel” that “gets in bed with special interests” to grow government. “Listen, there’s a reason that the lobbyists are all supporting Hillary Clinton and Marco Rubio,” he said. Specifically, Cruz has ripped Rubio for supporting government subsidies for sugar and ethanol, subsidies that are important economically and politically in Iowa and Florida. Cruz also opposes government subsidies for energy because he believes it’s tantamount to the government interfering with the market.
Also this week, Cruz tried to tie Rubio to Clinton on foreign policy, citing in an interview with Bloomberg News Rubio’s support for toppling Moammar Gadhafi in Libya, whom he called an ally in fighting terrorism. Cruz also tried to hit Rubio over Syria, arguing that the United States has “no dog in the fight” there, and that if “the Obama administration and the Washington neocons” succeed in taking out President Bashar al-Assad, “Syria will be handed over to radical Islamic terrorists.”
On Thursday morning, the Rubio campaign promoted a Wall Street Journal editorial written in light of the Bloomberg interview, asserting that Cruz is emulating President Obama on Middle East policy by “leading from behind.”
During his own speech to the Republican Jewish Coalition on Thursday, Rubio said support for keeping Assad in power is a “a fundamental, simplistic, and dangerous misunderstanding of the region.”
Marriage could be the next issue that comes to the fore in this competition for conservatives. The Cruz campaign believes Rubio’s statement that the Supreme Court decision on gay marriage is settled law could hurt him among evangelicals.
The Cruz team also hopes that Rubio’s effort to appeal to different groups within the party simultaneously will lead to his collapse, as was the case with Scott Walker. In the meantime, Cruz is actively trying to dampen Rubio’s appeal to conservatives who may be drawn to his rival. And Rubio, in an effort to court conservatives and advance ahead of Cruz, is drawing his own contrasts with the Texas senator on the same issues.
For now, however, a head-to-head race between the two is still in the distance -- and perhaps moot if Trump continues to gain steam.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






