
Benghazi Hearing: A Rollout for 2016 Contenders?
Published Jan. 24, 2013 • Read time: 5m
Join the Conversation
0It only took 48 hours after a presidential inauguration for the political discourse to shift into animated chatter about the next president, or at least conjecture about the candidates who might want the job.
On Capitol Hill Wednesday, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s riveting testimony about the Sept. 11 murders of four Americans in Benghazi and her candidate-like comments about future U.S. engagement in the world invited curiosity at every level.
At the same time, reporting about Vice President Biden’s 2016 ambitions, fanned in part by . . . well, Joe Biden . . . continued to heat up.
At the White House, spokesman Jay Carney tried valiantly (but with a certain loyalist exaggeration) to suggest Americans regard Clinton and Biden with equivalent regard. In fact, the former New York senator is ahead of the former Delaware senator in likability, according to an ABC News/Washington Post poll released Wednesday.
Carney at one point referred to the secretary of state as “President Clinton” during his daily briefing Wednesday before laughing about his Freudian slip. He deflected reporters’ questions about whether Biden would seek to become Obama’s successor.
The speculation about a future president just days after the coronation of the current one invited Obama’s spokesman to suggest the White House briefing room was infected with a worrisome strain of media madness.
“I think for the sake and sanity of all involved, it is worth taking a little bit of a break from presidential election-year politics,” he said.
No such luck. Politicos are curious to know whether or when Clinton might reprise her run for the Oval Office, so they eagerly examined her exchanges with potential rivals during a hearing of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. Sen. Marco Rubio, the young Florida Republican who is weighing his promising political trajectory, asked Clinton polite questions about U.S. help to Libya. But Sen. Rand Paul, the irascible Kentucky libertarian elected in 2010, delivered a withering lecture about leadership and told Clinton he would have fired her after the Benghazi attack “had I been president at the time.”
Lest anyone doubt that Paul has toyed with following in the footsteps of his father, Rep. Ron Paul, he sent a video clip to supporters Wednesday titled “Had I been president, I would have relieved Secretary Clinton of her duties."
In a few weeks, Clinton will conclude her service in the Obama administration and mull her next act. And because that exit has been so publicized and anticipated, her testimony, voice-choking grief, and then explosive, hand-waving anger during the Senate hearing became three-dimensional chess. (Clinton’s moment of teary emotion during the 2008 presidential race prompted some in the media to suggest the former first lady won the New Hampshire primary in part because she suddenly appeared human.)
Clinton’s explanations to House and Senate inquisitors about ongoing terrorist threats were carefully analyzed for any possible variances from the White House narrative that al-Qaeda has been decimated. As the experienced crisis communicator simultaneously “accepted responsibility,” and denied knowledge of cabled pleas from her Libya team for beefed-up security, she also protected Obama from any new involvement in the Benghazi affair.
But at one point she suggested that al-Qaeda’s reported demise might be too simplistic a narrative.
“We now face a spreading jihadist threat. We have driven a lot of the AQ operatives out of the FATA [federally administered tribal areas], out of Afghanistan, Pakistan; killed a lot of them, including, of course [Osama] bin Laden,” Clinton said. “But we have to recognize this is a global movement. We can kill leaders, but until we help establish strong democratic institutions, until we do a better job communicating our values and building relationships, we're going to be faced with this level of instability.”
The secretary has been an animated champion of “soft power,” the encouragement of democratic governance, human rights and economic empowerment as the way to deter extremist movements abroad. She sounded like a candidate, or a woman about to raise the roof, when she chided Congress for criticizing security risks abroad while underfunding the State Department in comparison to the Pentagon.
“And I do have a lot of thoughts about what more we can and should do, given this new reality we face,” she said in a firm voice.
As Clinton, 65, has become a global brand and international celebrity, shedding her public identity as an expert in health care and domestic policy, Biden, 70, has gone the other way, branching out from foreign policy in the Senate to become an expert for Obama in stimulus spending, legislative strategy, gun control and campaigning.
James Carville has predicted that potential Democratic candidates for the White House, eager to avoid a divisive and expensive primary contest in 2016, will pause before jumping in until they know Clinton’s intentions. Even the vice president -- irrepressible, ambitious and loyal -- is expected to think twice. Some believe Biden enjoys the public speculation about his presidential ambitions because it could prolong the relevancy of Obama’s second term.
The president’s spokesman said it’s premature to worry about 2016, but on all sides Wednesday, his quaint thinking was overruled.
RCP Today
Top stories on RealClearPolitics
The Takeaway
Polling intelligence and analysis delivered to your inbox
World News
Featuring the latest world news
Policy
Featuring the latest policy news
Support Our Mission
As part of RealClearPolitics, authors aim to provide balanced, non-partisan analysis by presenting top reporting and commentary from all sides of the political spectrum.
Trusted by policymakers and citizens alike since 2000






